3 ms·
I seriously doubt the capabilities of animals when it comes to language. Sure they have a wide spectrum of gestures and facial expressions (of course especiall
by ari_elle 14y ago
I seriously doubt the capabilities of animals when it comes to language.
Sure they have a wide spectrum of gestures and facial expressions (of course especially apes or gorillas, with which we share a great amount of our genetics), but do they really understand?
Is the record of "Alex" the Grey Parrot impressive?
Yes, but don't forget that a qualified animal researcher and scientist made it her life's project to teach this parrot.
I think that most animals just learn to loosely "say"/do things when it's wanted from them, because of very loose connections and patterns they recognize, not certainly as a way of deep emotional expression.
Maybe someone has Sources for Neurological Studies on this?
Could in my opinion clarify a little bit, what these animals actually "think" while issuing sign language gestures or while talking, therefore maybe unraveling their real capabilities of understanding.
- Thomvis 14y agoRegarding Sources for Neurological Studies: this paper [1] by Michael Arbib explores the neural and functional grounding of language skills in humans and their ancestors. [1] Michael A. Arbib, From monkey-like action recognition to human language: An evolutionary framework for neurolinguistics, Behavioral and brain sciences 28, 2005, pp. 105-124. PDF: http://users.ecs.soton.ac.uk/harnad/Temp/arbib-bbs.pdf http://users.ecs.soton.ac.uk/harnad/Temp/arbib-bbs.pdf
- stonemetal 14y agoKoko the Gorilla once ripped a sink off a wall. When asked about it, she signed the cat did it. To me this shows a certain amount of thought and understanding, maybe as much as a three or four year old human.