7 ms·
You could have written the same about MS in the 90s. It's not just that they're suing folks, it's that their actions seem to be deliberately designed to suppre
by Nursie 14y ago
You could have written the same about MS in the 90s.
It's not just that they're suing folks, it's that their actions seem to be deliberately designed to suppress the market and suppress competition. It doesn't feel genuine.
And while they do innovate, I don't think they do half as much they're given credit for. They didn't invent the smartphone, nor the mp3 player, yet most people likely think they did.
- smegel 14y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but Apple has only really gone hard against Samsung over the design patents? There are lots of other Android makers who produce models very different to the iPhone but haven't come under attack (maybe because they aren't as successfully though). So it doesn't really seem right to say they trying to suppress the whole market. At least with Apple they are trying to protect (justifiably or not) genuine, recent innovation, and they are being open about it. MS is suing more Android makers than Apple over alleged Linux patent violations in Android that it will not disclose (thus prevent Linus from fixing the supposed infringements), but probably relate to some ancient, legacy FAT file-system standard. This is just as dirty as the worst of MS misbehaviour in the 90s and shows they have not changed at all.
- Nursie 14y ago'(maybe because they aren't as successfully though)' I think this is the key. Samsung are the target because they're making a huge success of their phones and threatening (even in the US) Apple's position as the perceived 'gold standard' for smartphones. That perception has already faded away in other parts of the world. Perhaps they are only suing Samsung because only Samsung's designs are close enough to be covered by their design patents. That doesn't mean (to me) anything other than that the patent system is broken. I don't think that proceeding with these lawsuits is the right thing to do. Just because you can doesn't mean you should. I agree MS's android tax is just dirty, btw.
- bakedbeans 14y agoNobody credits them for inventing the smartphone. They invented the iPhone. Nobody credits them for inventing the mp3 player. They invented the iPod.
- Nursie 14y agoNobody? You don't read the popular press very much do you?
- rmc 14y agoFor a large percentage of the population, "mp3 player = ipod" and "smartphone = iphone".
- takluyver 14y agoAn anecdotal example: a couple of years ago, I mentioned to my mother that I had bought an mp3 player. She sounded puzzled for a moment and asked 'is that like an iPod?'
- safeaim 14y agoHere's sort of the flipside of that anecdote: Me and a group at my school are currently developing a mobile communication app for elderly for a interaction design-course, and we are in close cooperation with two local elderly homes for testing and feedback. During the initial phase we didn't settle on whether we should develop for iOS or Android but focused primarily on how the interaction should work. But after a while the local leader/our contact insisted that we develop for the iPad since the elderly at both homes had been to a iPad-workshop. 2 weeks later she tells us that she's bought two iPads for us that we could use for testing. When we get there, with our low-fi PowerPoint-prototype, it turns out that she's bought two Galaxy Tab's!
- rmc 14y agoI'm sure many people think "mp3" means "digital audio file"
- bennyg 14y ago
- pilsetnieks 14y agoSpeaking of Apple lawsuits, MS and the 90s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_v._Microsoft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_v._Microsoft
- v0cab 14y ago> their actions seem to be deliberately designed to suppress the market and suppress competition But then why aren't people on HN down on Samsung in the same way?
- Nursie 14y agoBecause it didn't seem to be Samsung that launched a war to get Apple's products banned, it seemed to be the other way around. I agree it is now an all-out war and neither side is going to come away clean, but in the most trivial sense 'They started it!'
- v0cab 14y agoBut the original iPhone was banned from South Korea for 2 years, almost certainly at Samsung's behest.