6 ms·
Prison May Be the Next Stop on a Gold Currency Journey
- cubicle67 14y agothis is where your US infinite detention becomes interesting. Both Obama and Romney support the infinite detention of American citizens without trial, but most people aren't worried as it's "only for the bad guys" What happens when you get on the bad side of the gov, like this guy? Declare someone a Domestic Terrorist and you can lock them away for good. Sure, it almost certainly won't be used in this case but that's not the point; the option shouldn't event exist anyway, good on the guy. Rosa Parks hyperbole aside, what's the problem with people trading in gold coins if they like? more power to them
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wseymour 14y agoI think you should be stating _which_ economic theory you claim to know. Those who subscribe to the Austrian school of economics, for example, might argue that allowing banks to print their own currency which represents their gold holdings, is _more efficient_ and less liable to failure than the centralised fiat system we have right now.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoDemocracy (+Capitalism) is not working for many countries and USA is the best example, I honestly think that even monarchy would be better; there is a small chance a prince would happen to grow up to be an intelligent good person but in your system the only 2 candidates are cherry picked by the people with very deep pockets trying to make those deeper.
- boon 14y agoSpot. On. When the laws can be used to put anyone in jail for just "annoying" the "civilized and obviously good for you" status quo, you are in big trouble.
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoThis article, and the concept of Liberty Dollar are interesting to compare with BitCoin. Whereas the head of the created currency is looking at hard prison time (20 yrs), there is no real one entity involved in BTC. My next question: will BTC be popular or threatening enough that the US treasury take hold and launch lawsuits on counterfeiting as they did in the Liberty Dollar case? And if so, how might they go about it?
- bluedanieru 14y agoNo, they'll go after the exchanges and, failing that, users of the currency. I think any assault on Bitcoin would have a lot more in common with the tactics of the copyright cartels, than this. The decentralized nature of peer-to-peer sharing and Bitcoin is more relevant than the fact that the Liberty Dollar and Bitcoin are both 'currencies' depending on who you talk to. Numerous lawsuits, harsh penalties bordering on unconstitutional (not that it really matters), and selective media exposure of same.
- hristov 14y agoBitcoin is clearly not a counterfit. It is not at all similar to us currency. I doubt any us attorney will even launch a suit against bitcoin. They only file suits they are pretty sure they can win. So bitcoin is very different than the liberty dollar in this respect.
- raverbashing 14y agoGold backed currency is overrated If you disagree with me you can go and convert your savings into gold (but you are probably doing it already) Remember, you still need US dollars to buy oil. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrodollar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrodollar
- mseebach 14y ago> Remember, you still need US dollars to buy oil. Good thing, then, that gold is very easy to convert into US dollars. "the fluctuating value of the dollar makes it very hard to gauge whether oil prices themselves are rising or falling… Oil today at 2 grams, is about the same as it was in the early 1950s; but if you measure the price in US dollars, you would get the impression that it is about 30 times more expensive today!" http://pricedingold.com/crude-oil/ http://pricedingold.com/crude-oil/
- bluedanieru 14y agoHow many Big Macs for a barrel? Honest question.
- mseebach 14y agoSure, show me anyone who will consistently convert big macs to US dollars, and I will happily show you the division button on your calculator. In case you need it spelled out, there is, and has always been, a liquid market for the conversion of gold into US dollars. There isn't one for converting Big Macs into anything. They're worthless for trading the second they cross the counter at McDonald's. For someone lashing out at "illiterate college students playing at economics", you're not exactly showing off your deep insight.
- wintersFright 14y agoHe is referring to the Big Mac Index - a measure of purchasing power parity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Mac_Index http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Mac_Index
- bluedanieru 14y agoWhatever asshole compared this guy to Rosa Parks needs to get some perspective.
- bluedanieru 14y agoDownvoted, eh? Yeah I suppose we can compare the struggle of an entire race to break free from systemic and institutional oppression and exploitation, to a bunch of illiterate college students playing at economics.
- Kliment 14y agoI feel sorry for people whose parents force eccentric names upon them. Random and Xtra? Really?
- s_henry_paulson 14y ago"All the perplexities, confusion and distresses in America arise not from defects in the constitution or confederation, nor from want of honor or virtue, as much from downright ignorance of the nature of coin, credit, and circulation." - John Adams in a letter to Thomas Jefferson
- mseebach 14y agoThis bit confuses me: At his federal trial, witnesses testified to the Liberty Dollar’s criminal similitude to standard American coins. They said his coins included images of Lady Liberty and cheekily reversed “In God We Trust” to “Trust in God.” Then again, his coins were made of real gold and silver, as American coins are not, and came in different sizes and unusual denominations of $10 and $20. They may be similar to US coin, which is, if nothing else, dumb. But if they're made from gold and silver, wouldn't they be more valuable than the coins they were confused with? Is that not solid proof against mens rea? Gold is $55/g, silver is $32/g. A US dollar coin is 8.1g, a quarter 5.6g.
- bitops 14y ago> But if they're made from gold and silver, wouldn't they be more valuable than the coins they were confused with? Sort of, but not really. The issue here is mixing the ideas of "a dollar" with "a piece of gold worth a dollar" or "a piece of silver worth a dollar". They are not the same thing. There's an abstract notion of 'Value: $1.00' that both a piece of paper and a piece of gold links up to. Hopefully that is a clear explanation.
- mseebach 14y agoNo, I get they're not the same thing, that's why I stated that it's dumb they've been issuing coins that resemble dollars. But it would appear that the counterfeit coins are actually worth more than the real coins - that's usually not the point of counterfeiting, and that makes it unclear who the victim of this crime really is.
- bitops 14y ago[original comment redacted] > that makes it unclear who the victim of this crime really is. Ah, okay - sorry, I missed this. There isn't really "a victim" here per se; it'd be hard to point at a person and say that they were hurt by what this guy was doing. Rather, it's a crime because it has the potential to destabilize the rules of how our financial system works. And, by implication, how our political system works. Money and politics go together, everyone accepts this. Government rhetoric (I guess) requires them to label it terrorism, but that's really stupid. They could have used it as an opportunity to explain how our economic system actually works. Of course, if you explain how the system works, people may ask deeper questions, etc.
- seacond 14y ago"...with his sons Random and Xtra..."
- carsongross 14y agoOne thing is clear: the government really hates gold. Good enough for me.
- bunderbunder 14y agoI'm not sure I buy the idea that this is as simple as the Federal government wanting to ban all currencies that are not the dollar. I don't buy it because there's still no sign of them trying to crack down on other alternative currencies such as Ithaca Hours. And Ithaca Hours are, I believe, older and more well-established. It wouldn't be the implication that the alternative currency has a cash value in US dollars, because Ithaca Hours are pegged at $10 per Hour. I wonder if it's that the Liberty Dollars were issued by a for-profit organization rather than being community organized like other alternative currencies I'm aware of. If I remember right, the "dollar monopoly" was originally enacted in response to the fracas around Civil War tokens. During the war companies had been issuing their own scrip that started to be used as currency in the surrounding communities. There were a number of minor financial catastrophes that happened whenever the issuing company would stop honoring its scrip, thus causing the currency to collapse. And the scrip issuer essentially made off with however much US currency they had received in exchange for the script. So the government decided to ban that as a form of (at the time clearly much-needed) consumer protection. Anyone who's more knowledgeable about the applicable law and its history who can comment?