3 ms·
Show HN: HN Companion – web app that enhances the experience of reading HN
HN is all about the rich discussions. We wanted to take the HN experience one step further - to bring the familiar keyboard-first navigation, find interesting viewpoints in the threads and get a gist of long threads so that we can decide which rabbit holes to explore. So we built HN Companion a year ago, and have been refining it ever since.
Try it: https://app.hncompanion.com https://app.hncompanion.com or available as an extension for Firefox / Chrome: [0].
Most AI summarization strips the voices from conversations by flattening threads into a wall of text. This kills the joy of reading HN discussions. Instead, HN Companion works differently - it understands the thread hierarchy, the voting patterns and contrasting viewpoints - everything that makes HN interesting. Think of it like clustering related discussions across multiple hierarchies into a group and surfacing the comments that represent each cluster. It keeps the verbatim text with backlinks so that you never lose context and can continue the conversation from that point. Here is how the summarization works under the hood [1].
We first built this as an open source browser extension. But soon we learned that people hesitate to install it. So we built the same experience as a web app with all the features. This helped people see how it works, and use it on mobile too (in the browser or as PWA). This is now a playground to try new features before taking them to the browser extension.
We did a Show HN a year ago [2] and we have added these features based on user feedback:
* cached summaries - summaries are generated and cached on our servers. This improved the speed significantly. You still have the option to use your own API key or use local models through Ollama.
* our system prompt is available in the Settings page of the extension. You can customize it as you wish.
* sort the posts in the feed pages (/home, /show etc.) based on points, comments, time or the default sorting order.
* We tried fine tuning an open weights model to summarize, but learned that with a good system prompt and user prompt, the frontier models deliver results of similar quality. So we didn’t use the fine-tuned model, but you can run them locally.
The browser extension does not track any usage or analytics. The code is open source[3].
We want to continue to improve HN Companion, specifically add features like following an author, notes about an author, draft posts etc.
See it in action for a post here https://app.hncompanion.com/item?id=46937696 https://app.hncompanion.com/item?id=46937696
We would love to get your feedback on what would make this more useful for your HN reading.
[0] https://hncompanion.com/#download https://hncompanion.com/#download
[1] https://hncompanion.com/how-it-works https://hncompanion.com/how-it-works
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42532374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42532374
[3] https://github.com/hncompanion/browser-extension https://github.com/hncompanion/browser-extension
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- annjose 8mo ago[dead]
- rayshan 8mo agoThis is one Chrome Extension I can't live without. I've been using this ever since Manifest v3 killed Hacker News Extension Suite (HNES). HN comment threads are getting longer over time. Top links often have 1k+ comments now. The AI summary saves me a ton of time. I also use the extension with the new sorting function, sorting frontpage links by points, so I can focus on what's important.
- georgeck 8mo agoThanks a lot, Rayshan! Your feedback through GitHub issues has been instrumental in helping us prioritize specific features. Additionally, the Chrome Web Store team has approved our extension for their ‘Featured’ badge, which could enhance the trust in installing the extension. I’m curious to know if you’ve had a chance to try the web app.
- annjose 8mo agoCo-author here. Forgot to share the link to the fine-tuned model [0]. [0] https://huggingface.co/georgeck/models https://huggingface.co/georgeck/models
- Muhammad523 8mo agoThe only thing that's rolling in my head right now is: WHY Why would anyone want an AI-generated summary of an online discussion??
- georgeck 8mo agoWhen people hear about AI summaries, this is what comes to mind. And I understand their concern. Wouldn’t a summary strip away the essence of a conversation? Let me explain with an analogy. When we’re overwhelmed with information, we benefit from a system that organizes it. For instance, I might use a tool to declutter my desktop files and categorize them into logical groups. Once the categorization is complete, I can view these clusters and focus on the specific files within those clusters that pique my interest. However, if the summarization process also alters the files, I wouldn’t want to use that tool. In the context of HN Companion, our objective is to examine lengthy threads and group them into 3 to 4 topics. Within each topic, we present the actual discussion that represents that cluster. We invested significant effort in developing a system that enables you to not only read the actual comments but also seamlessly jump to that discussion and continue the conversation there. I encourage you to explore a few of the summaries in the app. I’d greatly appreciate your feedback on how we can enhance our service.