4 ms·
I personally like the model "try to do something illegal and then complain on the Internet". When people realize the laws are wrong, they'll change them. (Reme
by jrockway 14y ago
I personally like the model "try to do something illegal and then complain on the Internet". When people realize the laws are wrong, they'll change them. (Remember how epically SOPA failed? Awareness is a key catalyst for change and many laws are for special interest groups rather than general interest.)
But even ignoring that, this article is crap. It basically claims that taxi licensing exists for safety and that Uber is jepordizing the safety of the average man for the benefit of the out-of-touch Silicon Valley elitist. Using facts to support this view, however, is difficult as there are none. Uber uses licensed car services that are licensed to transport passengers but not to pick up people without a certain amount of notice. The law that's being broken is saying "I want a car now" when the law says you have to say "I want a car in one hour" or otherwise hail a medallion vehicle. Presumably the licensing process for drivers of cabs and car service cars is around the same (drivers must not rape their passenger, to use the example from the article).
The worst side effect of letting car services pick up passengers immediately is that the artificial value of taxi medallions will return to its true value of zero dollars, making a lot of people very poor very quickly. There is an argument to limiting the number of cabs as a traffic-calming measure, but there is really no reason to discriminate based on vehicle type -- just implement a congestion charge and everything will work itself out.
Anyway, I like to see counterpoint articles on HN so I'm glad this was posted. But writing a whiney blog post about how Uber is sticking it to the poor man is tiresome.
- bpatrianakos 14y agoThe article isn't crap and you're too focused on the wrong part of it. You're missing the bigger point. It wasn't about whether the laws that Uner had trouble with we're justified or not, it was about how Disruptive startups try to paint any and all regulation and laws as unjustified despite there often being merit to them. It's about not being a cry baby and just because you label yourself Disruptive doesn't mean that the rules don't apply to you. At the same time yes there are laws that are laughable and truly need disruption. It's a real fine line to walk and this article points out the danger in the Randian attitude. I personally think that Rand did have some good points. Unfortunately the entire ideology is entirely one-dimensional and self-serving to the point where it ignores any and all counter arguments even if they really are more correct. This kind of mentality is dangerous in the same way religion is dangerous. Or can be dangerous. On the one hand you have you the moderates who are all about the good parts and loving everyone but stop short of holy war. On the other hand you have the zealots who take every word of their book as objective fact and will blow up a building to remind you. Not everyone believes what I believe. Luckily, my beliefs do not require them to.
- nirvana 14y agoYou actually called a mentality "dangerous" that you aren't even being honest about! Instead of internalizing leftist propaganda and repeating it as fact, you should actually read the book. "it ignores any and all counter arguments even if they really are more correct." The most accurate characterization of that statement is that it is the exact opposite of what he philosophy actually advocates. Which you would know if you'd read Atlas Shrugged. "On the other hand you have the zealots who take every word of their book as objective fact and will blow up a building to remind you." In this case, you are the zealot who is taking lies told about the book as fact, and advocating violence against those who disagree with you. And of course you have to characterize them in derogatory ways. If Ayn Rand was so wrong, why can't you, and others like you, such as Paul Carr, be honest about what she actually said-- and address her actual arguments and philosophy, instead of lying about them and characterizing them in a derogatory fashion? Which is, as far as I'm concerned, nothing short of calling them names. If you weren't a zealot, you'd have read the book to find out what it actually said. If you claim to have read the book, then lying about it makes you a zealot. But worse, anti-intellectual. And that's what I really find offensive.
- barrkel 14y ago"limiting the number of cabs as a traffic-calming measure" I would rather expect limiting the number of cabs to be traffic neutral; if anything, I think such a limit's biggest effect would be to reduce available parking and increase its costs. Increasing the number of cabs ought to reduce parking costs.
- saurik 14y agoThere is a a whitepaper that, in three parts, went into some detail on the situation in NYC, examining the causes and pulling apart the proposed solutions, for various of the complaints people have about the system. http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi1.htm http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi1.htm "Factors of Production in a Regulated Industry: New York Taxi Drivers and the Price for Better Service" http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi2.htm http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi2.htm "Villain or Bogeyman? New York's Taxi Medallion System" http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi3.htm http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxi3.htm "Fixing New York City Taxi Service" > Critics of the medallion system urge that "competition" in the form of additional cabs be let loose to spur better service. The analysis below finds that the growth of taxicab leasing over the last 15 years has had a far more pernicious effect on service quality than has the medallion system.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vm 14y agoUber has strong support from NYC consumers. They positioned this battle - rightly or wrongly - as "Uber vs. unjust cronyism" and all my friends in NYC avidly support that image of Uber in the not-totally-accurate fight. Admittedly a limited sample set, but those people are BIGGER supporters of Uber now and use the black car service more. As for Uber having problems rolling out the taxi service in Feb 2013... the consumer demand is there. Give drivers a way to make more money and the rational ones will join. Economics is a powerful force.
- untog 14y agoApologies- I deleted my post by mistake. I've reposted it, but now your reply is lost. In my experience Uber has a middle-to-none brand recognition for most people in New York. The only people I know that use it are techies. Uber launched their product too early because they are scared of competition- it's as simple as that. By Feb 2013, Hailo and GetTaxi will be in the city and they both have far more experience with yellow cabs than Uber- and haven't already annoyed a large group of them.
- oijaf888 14y agoI live in NYC and don't see the use for Uber unless you live in an area that isn't serviced by yellow cabs especially given the premium that they seem to charge. The vast majority of NYC residents don't use taxies frequently (roughly 241M passengers per year, on par with a single subway line) and a very small subset of those use livery cabs.
- untog 14y agoI feel like the Rand stuff was shoe-horned in to make the title fit. It's a shame, because there are a lot of good points about Uber's New York plans in there. What you're talking about doesn't quite apply here- the laws are outdated, yes- the NYC taxi commission themselves agreed with that. But they were bound by contracts until February 2013 that meant they were unable to change the rules. Uber/Travis pushed ahead with their plans anyway, assuming that the powers that be would buckle. That's stupid. And they're using being "disruptive" as an excuse for ignoring legal realities- and because they slap the label "disruptive" on it, plenty of people back them up. If I was an investor I would be pretty damn annoyed at what must be a lot of wasted cash on this endeavor, when anyone that bothered to investigate would have realised that failure was inevitable. If you read further, it discusses how Uber basically screwed over yellow cab drivers by urging them to break existing rules, then ambushed them to try and retrieve the iPhones they gave out once they'd given up on the service. Make no mistake- Uber will have an extremely difficult time re-launching their UberTAXI product in NYC now that they've alienated cab drivers.
- DanielRibeiro 14y agoI feel like the Rand stuff was shoe-horned in to make the title fit Not really. It is just buried in the long article (probably too deep). TL;DR: he likes Rand, has the cover of one of her books as his Twitter avatar, and defends her ideas on the web. The passage: From an interview with the Washington Post: “WP: I noticed your Twitter avatar is the cover of Ayn Rand’s “The Fountainhead.” Kalanack: I don’t know what you’re talking about. [Laughs.] It’s less of a political statement. It’s just personally one of my favorite books. I’m a fan of architecture.” See. Not a political statement. He’s just a fan of architecture. And one can only assume, then, that it was a completely different Travis Kalanick who responded to the Mahalo question “How would Ayn Rand react to the current policies and realities in the USA?” thusly… One of the interesting stats I came across was that 50% of all California taxes are paid by 141,000 people (a state with 30mm inhabitants). This hit home as I had recently finished Atlas Shrugged. If 141,000 affluent people in CA went “on strike”, CA would be d one for… another reason you can’t keep increasing taxes to pay for unaccountable gov’t programs that offer poor services.
- nikcub 14y ago> value of taxi medallions will return to its true value of zero dollars, making a lot of people very poor very quickly. Including the City of New York, who plan on selling over a thousand new medallions over the next few years and raising over $3B from the proceeds. Taxi medallions have been a way for New York City to print money and to patch the budget with their own form of quantitative easing.