15 ms·
Linking SaaS Software Pricing to Value
- swombat 18y agoI think the best way to price your software, if you can do it, is based on what actually costs you money. For instance, in our case, the thing that scales up as our users use the service more is the storage they use. That costs us money every month, so we'll be charging per gigabyte of storage per month. Adding users, on the other hand, costs us nothing - and in fact increases the spread of our app. Therefore, we have no interest in charging per user.
- jacquesm 18y agoThat makes very good sense at first reading, but the exact reason why software was such a successful product in the first place is because the real profits are in decoupling that 'paying for what costs you money' relationship and to focus on getting people to pay something for something that costs you very little to nothing but has perceived value for them. Otherwise you'll always be a marginal business at best. To illustrate that with the software example, the costs were in the development, but people ended up paying big time for the distribution media. Real multipliers are not found in the 'pay for what you use' arena, they are more likely to be found in exactly the opposite direction.
- swombat 18y agoThat's a very good point. I guess it depends on a number of other factors. In our case, we can see a much larger very-targeted, high value advertising opportunity if we do manage to saturate our niche - so user spread is very important, and if we could we would even offer it for free to grab the market share (unfortunately, if we do that we'll run out of money before we get a chance to bring in the advertising). I can see how for many other kinds of businesses, this would change dramatically.
- patio11 18y agoI think the best way to price your software, if you can do it, is based on what actually costs you money. Egads no! Why on earth should my customers care what my technical capabilities or cost drivers are?! Instead, let them concentrate on what they perceive as most important: the value to them of the product/service. Not charging your customers for free things which are in your business interests, on the other hand, that I wholeheartedly approve of.
- ericb 18y agoMy brother described pricing thusly: there are two main types of pricing, cost plus, which is good if you like to be poor, and value-based pricing.
- swombat 18y agoMinor nit-pick: Amazon does cost-plus... Jeff Bezos doesn't seem that poor to me. Also, letting what costs you money drive your prices is not quite the same as doing "cost-plus". We're not saying "We need a margin of X% on our cost per gigabyte". We're saying "Gigabytes are what costs us, so, since we want to charge as little as possible, we'll charge for gigabytes used (since they cost us), to maximise adoption. Now, how valuable is a Gigabyte to our customers?" The result is a price that is quite detached from our actual cost.
- jacquesm 18y agoJeff Bezos doesn't sell a service, he sells goods. Well, other than EC2 and such, but arguably they are not what you think of when you refer to 'Amazon'. This actually makes me wonder if there is a breakdown of income for Amazon separating out services and goods.
- forkqueue 18y agoI'd say you've got the wrong idea. You look at what costs you money to work out your break even. You look at what the value is to the customer when working out what to charge.
- jonas_b 18y agoFrom the comments: "SaaS = Software as a Service. It's a subscription model. In a way it's like going to the gym, instead of buying the equipment" I never seen that analogy before, kind of says it all I'd say. It's good cause Saas is tricky to explain to most non-tech people.
- sh1mmer 18y agoI'm surprised nobody mentioned that services like Salesforce that charge per user SaaS could easily not bill "idle" users that don't login, or possibly operate below some threshold. I think swombat's point about balancing adoption and profit is a good one. For example the US pharmo-giants miss out on the market of millions of Africans who need really cheap drugs because they are seemingly too afraid of cheap imports. It's not the production cost it's their refusal to lower the "value price" to an appropriate level in that market.
- anamax 18y agoIt's not necessarily true that they'd make more money selling to more people at a lower price. Revenue = avg selling price * #sales Cost = avg cost * #sales Profit = (avg selling price - avg production cost) * #sales If they double #sales but the average price goes down by <50%, they're going to lose revenue. If they triple the number of sales, they'll reduce profit if the cost is >50% of the post-reduction sales price. Yes, increased sales can result in reduced average production costs, through both reduced marginal costs and spreading the fixed costs across more units. (The latter can be a big deal for drugs.) However, the actual numbers matter. US drug companies try to do price discrimination to address these issues. However, if selling low-priced pills to Africa reduces their average selling price too much, they're not going to sell to Africa.
- Timothee 18y agoInteresting discussion. Unfortunately, there's no one-size-fits-all solution. I saw one comment (#16) saying that SaaS vendors have the ability to charge by usage and should do so because companies wants to see the link between what they pay and what they use/get. But that doesn't work for all products. Charging per usage can mean these two things: 1. The final cost might be hard to evaluate and can get out of hand. Some companies don't want that and want to be able to know in advance exactly how much it will cost. 2. It might tend to limit the usage of the software because you don't want to upgrade if you can get by with what you have. But I'm not saying charging per usage is not good! I'm trying to point out that you need to look at the problem from different points of view (value you bring, your costs, etc.) and see what works best in your case. Not everybody can charge depending on what costs them either. Many web-apps don't cost much to operate (if it's mostly displaying pages), so bandwidth costs wouldn't be enough. Is it easy to give a price to the value you give to your customers? If you can say "it saves you that much time vs. what you have right now", it's easier than for "make your customers happier thanks to a better service". Is there a metric that would make sense to charge for? Is that metric easy to grasp by your customers? I'm thinking of how Apple markets the sizes for iPod: by songs. 8GB might be obscure but 2000 songs is much easier: I know what a song is (about 3 minutes) and I can easily know how many I already have.
- akeefer 18y agoI know everything is moving to SaaS for very good reasons (both for the developers and for the customers), but one thing the old packaged software business had going for it was that costs were totally decoupled from pricing: your largest cost tended to be development, which meant that you could (in theory) just sell the same thing to 10x the number of people without substatially increasing your costs. Ironically, at least in the enterprise space our experience is that companies will pay much more for installed software than for SaaS, which seems totally counter-intuitive. When you're selling them installed software, they look at it as an investment, evaluate ROI, compare against the amount required to do an internal build, etc. When you're selling them SaaS, they look at it as a cost center to be minimized, and their interest is primarily in driving your costs through the floor. To put it another way, with installed software they realize they're paying your development costs, and that even if 100 other people are as well they know that it's still cheaper to buy from you than to build themselves. With SaaS, they act like they're paying you for hosting and support and totally ignore the development cost aspect of things, so their acceptable price is much lower. Irrational? Sure. But when my company investigated doing a hosting offering of our enterprise insurance products, we basically saw that it would probably end up just lowering our margins significantly, as well as probably lowering a potential future market valuation. Any sales we lose from not having an official hosted offering (we have partners that will host our software for them, but they're still paying us the full license fee) are ones we're willing to live with. My understanding is that public markets have tended to value companies with that exponential profit growth ability at higher valuations than companies with more linear, fixed margins. There aren't all that many SaaS business public at this point, so it'll be interesting to see how the market values them once they are; my impression is that equivalent installed-software and SaaS businesses (same revenue stream and profit, say) will have wildly different valuations, fair or not, due to the theory that the installed-software vendor can much more easily turn the crank to increase revenue without increasing costs.