3 ms·
And context for the comment above: It is very common to sneer at Daily Mail readers as a way of demonstrating your own right-on, progressive credentials. Daily
by gadders 14y ago
And context for the comment above: It is very common to sneer at Daily Mail readers as a way of demonstrating your own right-on, progressive credentials.
Daily Mail readers are largely right-wing, but that doesn't by definition make them wrong.
- EliRivers 14y agoThe Daily Mail, however, is often wrong and frequently guilty of the sins I list above. Demonstrably so. Sometimes, we sneer at something not because it makes us look good (or, as you put it, to demonstrate "progressive credentials", and your assumption that I want to do that is insulting and ignorant, thank you very much), but because it genuinely is dross. If you like, I can balance the equation by criticising the Guardian for its ridiculous adherence to leftist views despite the most ferocious evidence in its own pages, or we can do the Economist which suggests less regulation as the solution to almost any problem that exists. Edit to respond to comment below: Of course it's doing something right. It's selling newspapers. It does it by, as I said, flattering its readership and presenting them emotional sensations that confirm their beliefs. That doesn't make it worthy or correct. It makes it admirable only in a "magnificent bastards" kind of way. They know what they're doing and they do it very well.
- gadders 14y agoLots of papers print stories that are demonstrably wrong, though. And the Mail does cater to the lowest common denominator sometimes, but then that is the business of being a tabloid. And it is one of the most popular tabloids in Britain, and one of the most popular websites in the world, so I would suggest that it is doing something right.
- jiggy2011 14y agoDepends what "right" is. They can certainly sell a lot of papers, no doubt. But do they help make create an informed electorate? Which is the most important function of a free press. The biggest problem I have with the Mail is not whether it is biased or even that it makes mistakes. My problem is more that they will often print a headline and first paragraph or a story that makes some claim that is often refuted in the article itself. I feel that this is intended to deliberately mislead those with lower critical thinking abilities. It's amazing the number of times I've had to correct people on stuff like the legal status of Sharia courts. Of course I can't blame the mail for all of this stuff, there are plenty of other papers and blogs doing the same thing but the mail seems to be the flagship for this sort of journalism.
- saraid216 14y ago> I feel that this is intended to deliberately mislead those who don't read the entire article. Fixed that for you. Keep in mind that "reading only the headlines" is a common speed-up-your-life piece of advice. Tim Ferriss, for instance, specifically advises this. It's not really the readership's fault that the Mail is exploiting this.
- jiggy2011 14y agoNo, but it is the paper's fault.
- gadders 14y agoI'd love an informed electorate, but it would be a very tricky thing to try and define whether a particular story is informing the electorate or not, and to whose definition.
- intended 14y agoIn a sentence, what they are doing right and wrong is selling entertainment as news.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI don't know if it's as simple as a left vs right wing thing. The telegraph for example is relatively right wing and does not seem to attract the same sort of ire.
- gadders 14y agoThat is true, but then the Daily Mirror is a left-wing tabloid and doesn't get so much opprobrium, even though (as the news today tells us) they were also guilty of phone-hacking.
- josephlord 14y agoBut nobody reads it (relative to the Daily Mail and The Sun) and it just doesn't seem to matter in terms of the political debate. That is why it doesn't get so much opprobrium - it just doesn't matter. The Daily Mail and The Sun can mount massive campaigns, ruin careers of politicians and swing large amounts of votes (or at least that is the perception). All the Mirror readers vote Labour whatever they say (not necessarily true but perception amongst politicians). August readership - Daily Mirror 1.1M, Daily Mail 1.9M, Sun 2.5M Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/table/2012/sep/20/abcs-national-newspapers http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/table/2012/sep/20/abcs-natio...
- EliRivers 14y agoYour comment is confusing. The Daily Mail IS right wing. That said, the Telegraph relies much less on emotional response and raw propaganda, and also does not seem to dedicate a vast amount of its time (almost as much as the Express does on house prices) to dividing the universe into things that cause or cure cancer (or sometimes both). I couldn't care less what the Mail's political leaning is; its a style thing rather than a (lack of) content thing.
- AlisdairO 14y agoI'm definitely leftist politically, but I make an active effort to consider alternative points of view. I read center-right newspapers (usually the Times, occasionally the Telegraph) because I don't like existing in an echo chamber - and I feel like it's far easier to be manipulated if you're reading a news source whose viewpoint you usually agree with. While I often disagree with these newspapers, I still generally respect them - election time excluded, where many papers lose their sense of virtue. I respect them because they respect me enough to limit their attempts to use my emotions against me. This is not the case for the Daily Mail. An example (one of many) that crystallised this for me, from way back in my youth: Europe's switch to the Euro was underway, and the time to switch to euros in cash machines/as public currency. The Daily Mail, being very anti-Euro, had to paint this as a dismal failure. It weighed heavily on the fact that people were having to queue to get their new notes. It then followed up with a passage along the lines of 'At [some square in Germany], where Hitler's troops once marched, people queued around street corners to access the new currency' Now, I get it. They didn't like the Euro. Quite sensibly, in fact - conservatives in the UK deserve a fair bit of praise for keeping us out of that mess. This doesn't make the quoted passage an acceptable means of delivering news, though. I'm not sneering at the Daily Mail because it is right wing, but because its writing style is that of a manipulative propaganda rag. Personally, I think propaganda rags deserve sneering at.
- regularfry 14y ago'At [some square in Germany], where Hitler's troops once marched, people queued around street corners to access the new currency' Given their (ancient) history of supporting fascism, there's a small part of me that wonders what tone of voice that was actually written in.
- antihero 14y agoIt's not the right wing thing so much (though that is a factor), it's more their hypocritical social conservatism mixed with over-sexualisation of anything they can spin a coin from.