29 ms·
"You can legally be prescribed codeine, an opiate, by a doctor and take it, but this doesn't mean you can drive while under the influence." There is no per se
by Alex3917 14y ago
"You can legally be prescribed codeine, an opiate, by a doctor and take it, but this doesn't mean you can drive while under the influence."
There is no per se DUI for codeine. No one is objecting to the concept that marijuana users could get charged with a DUI if they are actually intoxicated. Rather they are against per se DUI limits, because the science shows them to be arbitrary and capricious. If the science supported per se DUI limits then I'm sure most people would support them.
- kolektiv 14y agoI genuinely don't know much about this question. What makes them more capricious than DUI limits for alcohol for example? People vary in their metabolism and intoxication levels there - is there much greater or less predictable variance with marijuana? I also have to admit that trying to in effect argue that people should not be prevented from "driving stoned" (yes, I know that's not really what they're saying - I hope!) is a peculiar strategy to get the majority of people onside. I rather like a drink. But I wouldn't argue in favour of drink driving.
- sliverstorm 14y agopeculiar strategy to get the majority of people onside I've seen stranger. Some people don't seem to grasp the concept of reasonable requests and gradual change; they want it all, and they want it now.
- Alex3917 14y ago"What makes them more capricious than DUI limits for alcohol for example?" Because if you look at the NHTSA data, it's very clear that the risk for someone driving at .08 is about 5x the baseline risk. If there was similar research showing that driving at 5ng/ml of marijuana had the same 5x increased risk then it would make a lot of sense. But that is not in fact the case. What they are essentially saying is that it's ok to drink and drive until your risk of killing someone is 5x increased, but it's illegal to smoke and drive even if your risk factor is only 1.1x or whatever. http://www.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/research/AlcoholHighway/2__overview.htm http://www.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/research/AlcoholHighway/2... (See figure 2-6)
- aaronbrethorst 14y agoSome States (Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Utah, Virginia, and Wisconsin) have passed “per se” laws, in which it is illegal to operate a motor vehicle if there is any detectable level of a prohibited drug, or its metabolites, in the driver’s blood. Other State laws define “drugged driving” as driving when a drug “renders the driver incapable of driving safely” or “causes the driver to be impaired.” http://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/drugged-driving http://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/drugged-driv...
- Alex3917 14y agoI don't think there is any state where these per se DUIs apply to prescribed drugs, though obviously correct me if I'm wrong.
- electromagnetic 14y agoI'm sick of these bullshit arguments. You want to drive, drive sober or don't drive at all. I have to be on the road with you too, and I don't want to drive from your drunk or druggy ass. I can't go to work and operate machinery drunk, high or doped up. I don't drive drunk, or high because it's irresponsible and should be a criminal act regardless of level of intoxication. DUI limits should be zero tolerance, and I can't wait for the day it is with alcohol. All DUI limits are arbitrary. Alcoholics can drive competently well above the legal limit. People can drive competently buzzed off of weed, completely stoned. I know people who have made 5-hour drives whilst on acid. Just because 1 person can drive drunk, doesn't mean you should allow thousands of others to as well. The limits are arbitrary because intoxication effects people differently. The only effective and rational way is to restrict driving to those who can do it competently: the sober. I drink and I smoke weed. You won't find me driving until 12 hours after I've last consumed. Edit: for the record, yes there is a DUI charge for opitates. It's called a DUI or DWI depending on the jargon. On top of that, they would just charge you with distracted driving or careless driving.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 14y ago"Just because 1 person can drive drunk, doesn't mean you should allow thousands of others to as well." I think this is the appropriate stance to take with alcohol because there is lots of data establishing that driving while above .08 does have a greatly increased relative risk. With marijuana though there is lots of research, but it all shows that that drivers under the influence of marijuana are much less dangerous than drivers who are at the legal limit for alcohol. What no one like talking about though is that if you want to really understand what's best from a public policy perspective, you need to understand that the absolute risk of driving while intoxicated is actually relatively small. If you drive 10 miles at a .08 your risk of dying would be ~1 in 4,000,000, as opposed to ~1 in 20,000,000 while completely sober. I'm certainly not advocating driving while intoxicated. But that being said, if you want to decrease your overall odds of dying then driving half as much in general would be much more effective than not driving while intoxicated once or twice a year. And similarly, good public transportation would be much more effective at reducing fatalities than harsher DUI penalties. So far we've spent $1.5 trillion enforcing the war on drugs in the last 40 years, which combined with the lost tax revenue would be enough to build the entire nationwide high speed rail corridor roughly 3 times over. If we really want to reduce fatalities over the next 40 years, then we'd be much better taxing and regulating drugs and using the money to redesign our cities and nation around an internationally competitive public transportation system.