3 ms·
It's unclear if this experiment actually happened the way Rosenhan claimed. A journalist went through Rosenhan's archives and tried to verify his story. She man
by ggreer 9mo ago
It's unclear if this experiment actually happened the way Rosenhan claimed. A journalist went through Rosenhan's archives and tried to verify his story. She managed to track down one of the pseudopatients, who disputed some of Rosenhan's claims such as the amount of preparation, and whether Rosenhan had worked out a legal backup plan in case the institution refused to release the patient.[1] She also noted large discrepancies in various numbers. Apparently she wrote a book about the whole thing, but I haven't had the chance to read it.[2][3]
1. https://sci-hub.red/10.1038/d41586-019-03268-y https://sci-hub.red/10.1038/d41586-019-03268-y
2. https://www.npr.org/2019/11/13/777172316/the-great-pretender-investigates-a-landmark-moment-in-psychiatric-history https://www.npr.org/2019/11/13/777172316/the-great-pretender...
3. https://www.susannahcahalan.com/the-great-pretender https://www.susannahcahalan.com/the-great-pretender
- dbgrman 9mo agoThanks for sharing, will read these.
- arcfour 9mo agohttps://spectator.com/article/how-a-fraudulent-experiment-set-psychiatry-back-decades/?edition=us https://spectator.com/article/how-a-fraudulent-experiment-se... Goes over things pretty well - the experiment seems to have been almost completely fraudulent with fabricated or heavily cherry-picked data.