3 ms·

How does this compare to https://strudel.cc/ https://strudel.cc/ ?

by Apreche 8mo ago

riedel 8mo ago
This is very much fun. Since I do not know what I am doing I simply ran Gemini on it to add a beat to pyramid song demo [0]. Is there music repls with LLM assistants built-in? [0] https://strudel.cc/#Ci8vICJQeXJhbWlkIFNvbmcgKFJhdyBBYnN0cmFjdCAtIEZpeGVkKSIKc2V0Y3BzKDEwNC82MC80KQoKY29uc3Qgc3BsaXQgPSByZWdpc3Rlcignc3BsaXQnLCAoZGVmbHQsIGNhbGxiYWNrLCBwYXQpID0%2BIGNhbGxiYWNrKGRlZmx0Lm1hcCgoZCxpKT0%2BIHBhdC53aXRoVmFsdWUoKHYpPT57CiAgY29uc3QgaXNvYmogPSB2LnZhbHVlICE9PSB1bmRlZmluZWQ7IGNvbnN0IHZhbHVlID0gaXNvYmogPyB2LnZhbHVlIDogdjsKICBjb25zdCByZXN1bHQgPSBBcnJheS5pc0FycmF5KHZhbHVlKT8oaTx2YWx1ZS5sZW5ndGg%2FdmFsdWVbaV06ZCk6KGk9PTA%2FdmFsdWU6ZCk7CiAgcmV0dXJuIChpPT0wICYmIGlzb2JqKSA%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%2BLzJgLCBpMjogYDxbW1o6LjQgWTouNF1AMyBZOi4zQDIgW0o6LjYgSjouOV1AM10%2BLzJgLCAKICBpMzpgPFtbSzouOCBYOi42XUAzIFk6LjVAMiBbWjouNSBaOi41XUAzXT4vMmAsIGk0OiBgPFtbWjouNCBZOi40XUAzIFk6LjRAMiBbWTouNCBZOi43XUAzXT4vMmAsCiAgb29vb2g6YDxbW1ggWF1AMyBZQDIgW1ogWl1AM10gW1taIFldQDMgWUAyIFtYIFhdQDNdIFtbWCBYXUAzIFlAMiBbWiBaXUAzXSBbW1ogWV1AMyBZQDIgW1kgWV1AM10%2BLzJgLAogIHYxOmA8W1tYIFhdQDMgWUAyIFtaIFpdQDNdIFtbWiBZXUAzIFlAMiBbWCBYXUAzXT4vMmAsCiAgdjI6YDxbW1YgVl1AMyBXQDIgW1cgV11AM10gW1tZIFldQDMgWUAyIFtZIFldQDNdPi8yYCwKICB2MzpgPFtbViBWXUAzIFdAMiBbVyBXXUAzXSBbW1kgWV1AMyBYQDIgW1ggWF1AM10%2BLzJgLAogIGVuZDpgPFg6MT4vOGAsIAogfSkuc3BsaXQoWzAsLjVdLCh4KT0%2BeFswXS5waWNrT3V0KGNocikudmVsb2NpdHkoeFsxXSkpLm5vdGUoKS5waWFubygpCiAgLmdhaW4oMC42KSAKICAubWFzaygiPDEgWzEgMF0gMSAwPiIpIC8vIEZvcmNlcyB0aGUgbWVsb2R5IHRvIGN1dCBvdXQgYXQgdGhlIGVuZCBvZiBiYXJzCiAgLnJvb20oLjQpLmxwZigxMDAwKQoKLy8gLS0tIFJBVyBJTlRFUk5BTCBCRUFUIC0tLQpkcnVtczogc3RhY2soCiAgLy8gSGVhdnkgS2ljawogIHMoImJkIFt%2BIGJkXSBiZEAyIH4gYmQgW34gYmRdIH4iKS5iYW5rKCJkcnVtcyIpLnZlbG9jaXR5KDEuNCkuc2hhcGUoMC40KSwKICAvLyBTbmFyZSArIFJpbSAKICBzKCJ%2BIFtzbjoxLCByaW06MV0gfiBbc246MSoyXSB%2BIHNuOjEgfiBbcmltOjE%2FMC41XSIpLnZlbG9jaXR5KDEuMykuZGVsYXkoMC4wNSkuY3J1c2goNCksCiAgLy8gQnJhc2ggSGktaGF0cwogIHMoImhoKjE2PzAuNyIpLmJhbmsoInJvbGFuZHRyODA4IikudmVsb2NpdHkoIjAuOCAwLjQgMSAwLjYiKS5jcnVzaCgyKQopLnNsb3coMikuZ2FpbigxLjUpLmRpc3RvcnQoMC4xKQoKLy8gR3JpdHR5IEJhc3MKYmFzczogIjxbZiMxQDMgZzFAMiBhMUAzXSBbYTFAMyBnMUAyIGcxQDNdPiIucygic2F3IikubHBmKDEzMCkuZ2FpbigwLjcpLnNoYXBlKDAuNikKCm9vb29oOiAiPH4gMCB%2BQDQgMEAyIH5AOD4vOCIucGlja1Jlc3RhcnQoWwogICI8ZiM1QDExIGU1Oi0yIGcjNTo0IGU1Oi00IFtmIzU6MiB%2BXSBbfiBnIzUgZTVdIGYjNUA0IGcjNSBmIzUgZTUgZDUgYyM1QDUgfkAzPio0IgogIF0pLnNwbGl0KFswLDBdLCh4KT0%2BeFswXS5wZW52KHhbMV0pKS5wYXR0KDAuMDQpLnMoInRyaWFuZ2xlIikuYXR0YWNrKC4wOCkucmVsZWFzZSguMDgpLm5vdGUoKS5nYWluKDAuMikubWFzaygiPDEhNyAwPiIpCg%3D%3D https://strudel.cc/#Ci8vICJQeXJhbWlkIFNvbmcgKFJhdyBBYnN0cmFj...
- eddyg 8mo ago
  Have you heard of Switch-Angel? If not, check out https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hbZb1Q0mM7k https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hbZb1Q0mM7k (to pick one) for a taste of what Strudel is capable of in "real time".
  - actsasbuffoon 8mo ago
    It’s been a lot of fun watching her subscriber count go through the roof. She’s outrageously talented. It’s also funny because usually it’s hard to reproduce what a musician does. I can listen to someone play guitar, but there’s so much nuance to how it’s played that you need to be pretty good to reproduce it. But so much of her music is code, and she shows you the code, so she’s really teaching you how to reproduce what she’s doing perfectly. It’s awesome for learning.
  - riedel 8mo ago
    Thanks! I saw a few live vids. However it is cool to see someone saying what they are doing (guess that would be perfect training material for an LLM ;)). Seriously, I do not think an LLM can replace any artist. It is exactly that live thing that makes it cool. However I remember some research projects that were trying to reinforce also music selection with crowed movements in a club. iMHO would be some fun to create actually some live reinforcement from audience reactions and see where this is going.
- soulofmischief 8mo ago
  I made one a couple weeks ago, it also has visuals. You can use a key or use a local LLM running right in the browser. I'll drop it online somewhere, maybe do a Show HN. Would you like me to email you when I do?
  - riedel 8mo ago
    Cool, yes: I just send you DM (aka email) with my contacts.

How does this compare to https://strudel.cc/ https://strudel.cc/ ?

by Apreche 8mo ago

How does this compare to https://strudel.cc/ https://strudel.cc/ ?

This is very much fun. Since I do not know what I am doing I simply ran Gemini on it to add a beat to pyramid song demo [0]. Is there music repls with LLM assistants built-in? [0] https://strudel.cc/#Ci8vICJQeXJhbWlkIFNvbmcgKFJhdyBBYnN0cmFjdCAtIEZpeGVkKSIKc2V0Y3BzKDEwNC82MC80KQoKY29uc3Qgc3BsaXQgPSByZWdpc3Rlcignc3BsaXQnLCAoZGVmbHQsIGNhbGxiYWNrLCBwYXQpID0%2BIGNhbGxiYWNrKGRlZmx0Lm1hcCgoZCxpKT0%2BIHBhdC53aXRoVmFsdWUoKHYpPT57CiAgY29uc3QgaXNvYmogPSB2LnZhbHVlICE9PSB1bmRlZmluZWQ7IGNvbnN0IHZhbHVlID0gaXNvYmogPyB2LnZhbHVlIDogdjsKICBjb25zdCByZXN1bHQgPSBBcnJheS5pc0FycmF5KHZhbHVlKT8oaTx2YWx1ZS5sZW5ndGg%2FdmFsdWVbaV06ZCk6KGk9PTA%2FdmFsdWU6ZCk7CiAgcmV0dXJuIChpPT0wICYmIGlzb2JqKSA%2FIHsuLi52LHZhbHVlOnJlc3VsdH0gOiByZXN1bHQ7IH0pKSkpOwoKbGV0IGNociA9IHtYOiJmIzIsYyMzLGEjMyxjIzQsZiM0IiwgWToiZzIsZDMsYjMsZDQsZiM0IiwgWjoiYTIsZTMsYTMsYyM0LGYjNCIsIEo6ImcyLGQzLGIzLGQ0LGc0IiwgSzoiZiMyLGMjMyxhIzMsYyM0LGc0IiwKICAgICAgICAgICBWOiJmIzIsYyMzLGEzLGMjNCxmIzQiLCBXOiJlMixiMixnIzMsYjMsZiM0In0KCi8vIFBJQU5POiBBZGRlZCBhZ2dyZXNzaXZlIG1hc2tpbmcgZm9yIHRoZSAicGF1c2VzIgpwaWFubzogIjxbaTEgaTIgaTMgaTRdIG9vb29oIFt2MSB2Ml0hNCBvb29vaEAyIFt2MSB2Ml0hMyBbdjEgdjNdIFt2MyB2Ml0gW2kxIGkyIGkzIGkyXSBbaTMgaTIgaTMgaTJdIGVuZD4vOCIucGlja1Jlc3RhcnQoCiB7aTE6YDxbW1g6LjYgWDouOF1AMyBZOi41QDIgW1o6LjUgWjouNV1AM10%2BLzJgLCBpMjogYDxbW1o6LjQgWTouNF1AMyBZOi4zQDIgW0o6LjYgSjouOV1AM10%2BLzJgLCAKICBpMzpgPFtbSzouOCBYOi42XUAzIFk6LjVAMiBbWjouNSBaOi41XUAzXT4vMmAsIGk0OiBgPFtbWjouNCBZOi40XUAzIFk6LjRAMiBbWTouNCBZOi43XUAzXT4vMmAsCiAgb29vb2g6YDxbW1ggWF1AMyBZQDIgW1ogWl1AM10gW1taIFldQDMgWUAyIFtYIFhdQDNdIFtbWCBYXUAzIFlAMiBbWiBaXUAzXSBbW1ogWV1AMyBZQDIgW1kgWV1AM10%2BLzJgLAogIHYxOmA8W1tYIFhdQDMgWUAyIFtaIFpdQDNdIFtbWiBZXUAzIFlAMiBbWCBYXUAzXT4vMmAsCiAgdjI6YDxbW1YgVl1AMyBXQDIgW1cgV11AM10gW1tZIFldQDMgWUAyIFtZIFldQDNdPi8yYCwKICB2MzpgPFtbViBWXUAzIFdAMiBbVyBXXUAzXSBbW1kgWV1AMyBYQDIgW1ggWF1AM10%2BLzJgLAogIGVuZDpgPFg6MT4vOGAsIAogfSkuc3BsaXQoWzAsLjVdLCh4KT0%2BeFswXS5waWNrT3V0KGNocikudmVsb2NpdHkoeFsxXSkpLm5vdGUoKS5waWFubygpCiAgLmdhaW4oMC42KSAKICAubWFzaygiPDEgWzEgMF0gMSAwPiIpIC8vIEZvcmNlcyB0aGUgbWVsb2R5IHRvIGN1dCBvdXQgYXQgdGhlIGVuZCBvZiBiYXJzCiAgLnJvb20oLjQpLmxwZigxMDAwKQoKLy8gLS0tIFJBVyBJTlRFUk5BTCBCRUFUIC0tLQpkcnVtczogc3RhY2soCiAgLy8gSGVhdnkgS2ljawogIHMoImJkIFt%2BIGJkXSBiZEAyIH4gYmQgW34gYmRdIH4iKS5iYW5rKCJkcnVtcyIpLnZlbG9jaXR5KDEuNCkuc2hhcGUoMC40KSwKICAvLyBTbmFyZSArIFJpbSAKICBzKCJ%2BIFtzbjoxLCByaW06MV0gfiBbc246MSoyXSB%2BIHNuOjEgfiBbcmltOjE%2FMC41XSIpLnZlbG9jaXR5KDEuMykuZGVsYXkoMC4wNSkuY3J1c2goNCksCiAgLy8gQnJhc2ggSGktaGF0cwogIHMoImhoKjE2PzAuNyIpLmJhbmsoInJvbGFuZHRyODA4IikudmVsb2NpdHkoIjAuOCAwLjQgMSAwLjYiKS5jcnVzaCgyKQopLnNsb3coMikuZ2FpbigxLjUpLmRpc3RvcnQoMC4xKQoKLy8gR3JpdHR5IEJhc3MKYmFzczogIjxbZiMxQDMgZzFAMiBhMUAzXSBbYTFAMyBnMUAyIGcxQDNdPiIucygic2F3IikubHBmKDEzMCkuZ2FpbigwLjcpLnNoYXBlKDAuNikKCm9vb29oOiAiPH4gMCB%2BQDQgMEAyIH5AOD4vOCIucGlja1Jlc3RhcnQoWwogICI8ZiM1QDExIGU1Oi0yIGcjNTo0IGU1Oi00IFtmIzU6MiB%2BXSBbfiBnIzUgZTVdIGYjNUA0IGcjNSBmIzUgZTUgZDUgYyM1QDUgfkAzPio0IgogIF0pLnNwbGl0KFswLDBdLCh4KT0%2BeFswXS5wZW52KHhbMV0pKS5wYXR0KDAuMDQpLnMoInRyaWFuZ2xlIikuYXR0YWNrKC4wOCkucmVsZWFzZSguMDgpLm5vdGUoKS5nYWluKDAuMikubWFzaygiPDEhNyAwPiIpCg%3D%3D https://strudel.cc/#Ci8vICJQeXJhbWlkIFNvbmcgKFJhdyBBYnN0cmFj...

eddyg 8mo ago
Have you heard of Switch-Angel? If not, check out https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hbZb1Q0mM7k https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hbZb1Q0mM7k (to pick one) for a taste of what Strudel is capable of in "real time".
- actsasbuffoon 8mo ago
  It’s been a lot of fun watching her subscriber count go through the roof. She’s outrageously talented. It’s also funny because usually it’s hard to reproduce what a musician does. I can listen to someone play guitar, but there’s so much nuance to how it’s played that you need to be pretty good to reproduce it. But so much of her music is code, and she shows you the code, so she’s really teaching you how to reproduce what she’s doing perfectly. It’s awesome for learning.
- riedel 8mo ago
  Thanks! I saw a few live vids. However it is cool to see someone saying what they are doing (guess that would be perfect training material for an LLM ;)). Seriously, I do not think an LLM can replace any artist. It is exactly that live thing that makes it cool. However I remember some research projects that were trying to reinforce also music selection with crowed movements in a club. iMHO would be some fun to create actually some live reinforcement from audience reactions and see where this is going.
soulofmischief 8mo ago
I made one a couple weeks ago, it also has visuals. You can use a key or use a local LLM running right in the browser. I'll drop it online somewhere, maybe do a Show HN. Would you like me to email you when I do?
- riedel 8mo ago
  Cool, yes: I just send you DM (aka email) with my contacts.