3 ms·
GNU Hurd Is "Almost There" with x86_64, SMP and ~75% of Debian Packages Building
- taylodl 10mo agoThis headline was pretty much true 5 years ago, 10 years ago, 15 years ago... Don't get me wrong, I think Hurd is interesting, but I seriously doubt it's going to have a big impact on anything as it reflects the software engineering philosophies of the 1980s.
- hayleox 10mo agoThe "75% of Debian archive builds" claim is exactly the same 7 years ago. In fact, look at this slide from the 2019 presentation: https://archive.fosdem.org/2019/schedule/event/roadmap_for_the_hurd/attachments/slides/3270/export/events/attachments/roadmap_for_the_hurd/slides/3270/2019_02_01_fosdem_roadmap.pdf#page=8 https://archive.fosdem.org/2019/schedule/event/roadmap_for_t... (page 8) It is barely distinguishable from the first slide featured in the Phoronix article from today: https://www.phoronix.net/image.php?id=2026&image=gnu_hurd_1 https://www.phoronix.net/image.php?id=2026&image=gnu_hurd_1 It seems like there has been progress on other fronts, so I'm not sure why Phoronix ran a headline focused on very old news. Interestingly, the 2018 version of the slide claims "80% of Debian archive builds"; I wonder what caused the regression. https://archive.fosdem.org/2018/schedule/event/microkernel_hurd_pci_arbiter/attachments/slides/2323/export/events/attachments/microkernel_hurd_pci_arbiter/slides/2323/2018_02_03_fosdem_pci.pdf#page=26 https://archive.fosdem.org/2018/schedule/event/microkernel_h... (page 26)
- philipwhiuk 10mo ago> so I'm not sure why Phoronix ran a headline focused on very old news. It's just coverage of FOSDEM 2026 and I guess they assumed that the FOSDEM slides would show notable changes rather than the state of play.
- AtlasBarfed 10mo agoAnother example of if llms are so good. Why isn't a gap like this closed very quickly?
- digiown 10mo agoGNU projects and LLM contribs mix like water and oil.
- hgs3 10mo ago> reflects the software engineering philosophies of the 1980s. It has a microkernel architecture. That's already an improvement over the "modern" monolithic kernels we are stuck with today. Given Big Tech's interest in hardening security and sandboxing you'd think this would get more attention.
- wolvoleo 10mo agoTrue but it's not exactly new. I remember Andrew Tanenbaum and Linus Torvald's heated discussions in the early 90s :) Minix featured a microkernel before linux existed.
- pjmlp 10mo agoYeah, but we are still far off making it mainstream beyond some key use cases, QNX, INTEGRITY, language runtimes on top of type 1 hypervisors, all kernel extension points being pushed into userspace across Apple,Google,Microsoft offerings, Nintendo Switch,....
- bcrl 9mo agoGiven the tectonic shift in priorities for Linux kernel development over the past decade, I'm willing to bet that many key developers would be open to a microkernel architecture now than ~25+ years ago. CPUs now have hardware features that reduce the overhead of MMU context changes which gets rid of a significant part of the cost of having isolated address spaces to contain code. The Meltdown and Spectre attacks really forced the security issue to the point where major performance costs to improve security became acceptable in a way that was not the case in the '90s or '00s.
- mannyv 10mo ago"Hurd Isn't Soup"
- imglorp 10mo agoHurd Uses Repurposed Debian
- wolvoleo 10mo agoTo be fair, GNU/Linux distros like Debian lean very heavily on the GNU part. They owe a lot to the GSF and its work is highly praised. Just their kernel somehow seems to be stuck in vaporware status. Probably because a lot of developers would think "why work on this when we already have Linux" which is a fair point too.
- imglorp 10mo agoI wonder if microkernels more relevant now than ever given their reduced attack surface, and also the recent availability of more cores. One big criticism from decades ago was the loss in efficiency. But what's changed since microkernels were conceived is how many processor cores are available to offload userspace drivers from the kernel. Is this a valid viewpoint? Is it time for microkernels to overtake monolithic kernels?
- rurban 10mo agoThey already did. There are more microkernels around than monolithic. All big CPU's use them internally, all phones use them.
- sillywalk 10mo agoLink to the actual presentation: https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/event/7FZXHF-updates_on_gnuhurd_progress_rump_drivers_64bit_smp_software_bootstrapping/ https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/event/7FZXHF-updates_on_gnu...
- scoperesolution 10mo agoHah! It's been almost there for over a decade...
- jethronethro 10mo agoPlease let me know what it is "there". Then I'll start caring. Until then ...
- acheron 10mo agoWhile I laughed at the headline, it also fondly reminds me of reading Slashdot in the late 90s-early 00s, back before the Internet and programming and computers had all gone to shit. Good luck guys. At least working on this for decades is less damaging to the world than anything people do at Google and Facebook.
- tonfreed 10mo agoI always liked reading about it in uni in the mid-late 00s. It made me feel smart in my OS tutorials when I could rattle off all the design choices and how they differed from Linux and Windows
- zeruch 10mo agoHurd is long past ever being anything but a pet project of RMS and his familiars.
- hulitu 9mo agoX11 ?