4 ms·
Almost certainly. The law should also be amended to require conviction or settlement, not merely investigation, to revoke someone’s PreCheck or Global Entry sta
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
Almost certainly. The law should also be amended to require conviction or settlement, not merely investigation, to revoke someone’s PreCheck or Global Entry status.
- bri3d 10mo agoOverall you can have Global Entry revoked for almost anything; one of the clauses is “The applicant has been found in violation of any customs, immigration, or agriculture regulations, procedures, or laws in any country.” which falls dramatically short of a crime or investigation. There are many reports of GE revocation for stuff like failure to declare fruits at checkpoints.
- metadat 10mo agoHow is attending a protest a potential violation of customs regulations? This doesn't track.
- bri3d 10mo agoThe argument, if there is one, would probably be that following ICE was a violation of an immigration procedure (note that the person who had their GE revoked doesn’t claim they attended a protest, but rather that they were following ICE and got their picture taken). Given what I’ve seen of GE revocations historically, though, it’s equally likely to have been something like “you lived with a felon” or “unpaid traffic ticket became a warrant” or “family member was accused but never convicted of an obscure crime.” There’s always been a pretty clear mantra that GE is a privilege not a right and that it’s always been an arbitrary and capricious system. In some ways I think maintaining GE is probably as hard or harder than maintaining a low level (ie Secret) security clearance; it seems to be based on similar databases and discretion with less transparency, human touch, or opportunity to appeal. They are at least (according to the 9th circuit) supposed to disclose why the GE was revoked though: https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2024/05/22/22-56015.pdf https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2024/05/22/2...
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> How is attending a protest a potential violation of customs regulations? FTFA: “Protesting isn’t a listed or ‘valid’ reason for having Global Entry revoked, but being arrested at a protest is. Impeding or interfering with the agency is. And being investigated is.”
- throw2937374 10mo agoLooks like this is a social credit system.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> Looks like this is a social credit system To the extent it’s a government program with any discretion, yes. In every other respect, no.
- bri3d 10mo agoGlobal Entry absolutely is a completely voluntary social credit system? It’s an optional thing you literally subscribe to that says “I’m squeaky clean so I can skip the investigation line.”
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> Global Entry absolutely is a completely voluntary social credit system? They’re making analogy to China’s social-credit system. It would be like if Global Entry was held by most Americans and you needed it to get a credit card or board a train.
- toofy 10mo agoright, but as the post above says: > “Protesting isn’t a listed or ‘valid’ reason for having Global Entry revoked, but being arrested at a protest is… And being investigated is.” its no secret they're declaring everything a protest. they are actively and seemingly randomly roaming, demanding ids, and then declaring everything from that moment forward a protest. this isnt imaginary, its happening regularly. it’s no secret how many people they have arrested and released an hour or two later once they’re "investigated." it’s also no secret that they’re simply arresting people, who arent at a protest, but who happen to be in the same street they’ve roamed to. if they roam into my neighborhood, and if i were to be outside walking my dog, they demand my id which i probably wouldnt have because im just walking my dog. so they arrest me. hours later let me go because they’ve "investigated" and oops, just a neighbor out walking his dog.. if they've declared it a protest, this would mean i would have just been arrested and investigated at what they call a protest. so now in this situation i would barred from global entry because they’ve declared everyone in their eyeline worthy of arrest and then wrongly arrested and investigated me? what a cluster fuck. we need to get due process back, this is insanity. not to mention that protesting, just like legally carrying a firearm is absolutely protected by the constitution and not at all a criminal offense. getting arrested at a protest because they dont like protesters is absolutely not a reliable indicator of any kind of illegality.
- ajross 10mo agoYes, but even so doing it because of protest is a restraint on speech, and that's expressly prohibited by the constitution. The first amendment may be frustratingly silent on fruit trade regulations, but it's 100% not unclear about abridging the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
- necubi 10mo agoExpressing your first amendment right to protest is not “almost anything.” Historically, courts have taken very dim view of government retaliation for first-amendment protected activities.
- ottah 10mo agoIt's trivial for the state to punish you and nearly impossible to assert your own rights. It is a very hard legal battle to get those rights acknowledged and upheld by the courts.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> nearly impossible to assert your own rights. It is a very hard legal battle to get those rights acknowledged and upheld by the courts What are you basing this on? This administration is constantly losing in court.
- SilverElfin 10mo agoThey mean it’s costly - in time and money - so in practice random individuals who are abused by the government can’t defend their rights and simply have to accept losing them. Plus even if the administration loses, why would they care? They aren’t going to jail for those losses.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> They mean it’s costly Which is far from “nearly impossible.” > even if the administration loses, why would they care? They aren’t going to jail Neither is someone whose TSA PreCheck is revoked.
- NotSammyHagar 10mo agoThey lose but ignore that they have lost, just keep going, the courts aren't shutting them down very effectively.
- asdfaslkj353 10mo ago[dead]
- aqme28 10mo agoHeck, you can be on a terrorism watchlist and entirely barred from flying without a conviction
- tokyobreakfast 10mo agoTrusted Traveller programs are a privilege and not a constitutionally protected entitlement. They can be revoked at any time for any reason and you don't get your money back. What law are you talking about? Show us where in the Constitution it says you're entitled to cut in line at the airport. We're now in the Find Out phase of "Let's fuck around with DHS and see if they take us off their club's VIP list".
- amanaplanacanal 10mo ago"Congress shall make no law". If there is a law, it's unconstitutional. If there is no law, then how is the executive doing it? By what constitutional authority?
- datsci_est_2015 10mo agoPersonally, I don’t think that anyone should be speaking authoritatively on this subject because it seems to me to be untested constitutional law, unless a constitutional scholar would like to chime in. In which case, it’s up to the Supreme Court to either explicitly (through judgment) or implicitly (through denying a hearing of the case) decide.
- junofan 10mo agoOk, I am a Constitutional Scholar and there is no way that not getting to jump the line at the airport is a “material adverse action” because you can simply get in line. In general, there need to be damages when you talk about liability.
- datsci_est_2015 10mo agoWelcome to the thread! I trust your expertise, but am a little put off by your flippant tone: > getting to jump the line at the airport is a “material adverse action” This is rhetorical device of framing. I could just as easily say: > Pretending to open an online cupcake shop and pretending to be forced to serve gay people isn’t a “material adverse action” And it would sound equally ridiculous, yet the highest court in the land ruled in that individual’s favor.
- SilverElfin 10mo agoThere are also no consequences for the president, his agency leaders, legislators, or anyone else involved in this when they violate the constitution. At best, the victims sue and get money from taxpayers. The law must be changed to remove all types of qualified immunity from anyone in a government position.