3 ms·
We don't have a definitive answer to that yet. We've talked to various companies and some experts. If you have specific knowledge of that field I would be very
by jgrahamc 14y ago
We don't have a definitive answer to that yet. We've talked to various companies and some experts. If you have specific knowledge of that field I would be very interested to talk to you.
The Analytical Engine will have something like 40,000 parts...
- josephagoss 14y agoThat is amazing, will the simulation be open source at some point, I would love to run that!
- jgrahamc 14y agoYes. There are a number of reasons for doing the simulation (not least of which is checking that it will actually work), but one is that I want to make the simulation public. As a charity Plan 28 is set up to educate the public at large about Charles Babbage and the Analytical Engine while building it. That means publishing openly as much as we can. Study has been ongoing for a while now and first public results will be early in 2013.
- keithpeter 14y agoWill the simulation assume perfect mechanics or try to simulate friction, flex &c based on materials around then? If latter, then strikes me as very difficult project.
- willyt 14y agoWhen you say 40000 parts, is that 'just' moving parts or every single nut, bolt, rod, plate etc? When i was doing some 'blue sky' research at an architectural practice a few years ago I looked at a variety of mech eng packages for modelling skyscrapers at a level of detail which would have exceeded 40000 parts. I was interested because they were more advanced than the AECCad software available at the time and had better options for managing complexity. CATIA seemed to be the gold standard, but its very expensive and not at all intuitive. It seemed like we would need specialist technicians to operate it. Solidworks was most accessible in terms of usability. Spaceclaim was interesting but immature and didn't have much in the way of simulation. I didn't like Inventor as much as Solidworks, but that's maybe just because I tried Solidworks first. I dont know if any of these would be able to simulate the mechanical operation of the whole mechanism in one go though. I'd be very interested in hearing what you choose.