3 ms·
Argh. As someone who's done this and is actively involved in the UKHAS (http://ukhas.org.uk/ http://ukhas.org.uk/) this article annoys me. People have been doin
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Argh. As someone who's done this and is actively involved in the UKHAS (http://ukhas.org.uk/ http://ukhas.org.uk/) this article annoys me. People have been doing this stuff for years, and here we have someone who seems to just not have bothered to learn about how to track a balloon using amateur radio, GPS altitude/speed limits, best practices in terms of the parachute and balloon rigging, and most importantly this article does not once mention the FAA.
There's no indication that he was aware of FAA regulations (FAA Part 101) on this type of launch. So, no consideration of payload weight, density, ...
Also, he does appear to have use a trajectory predictor but only to figure out where he was going to get his balloon back and not for predicting the path through restricted airspace etc.
There's a large community of people out there in the UK and US who are happy to help people get started doing this sort of thing. Please shout out for assistance!
http://ukhas.org.uk/general:beginners_guide_to_high_altitude_ballooning http://ukhas.org.uk/general:beginners_guide_to_high_altitude...
- belorn 14y agoPermission to launch a simple balloon with a camera. I mean it sound so simple, but then you might also be required to seek permission for filming if its done over a residential area. Add that with radio regulations if you are using any kind of receiver, and there might be 3 or more agencies one would need to get permissions for a simple launch. The 'blanket' permission groups like UKHAS is however nice (if one live in the UK), and there is a loot to learn by the people there. That said, ignoring the regulations is sometimes a viable option.
- jgrahamc 14y agoSo, is your point that permissions might be a nuisance so ignore them? FAA regulations exist to help ensure safe interaction between aircraft; radio regulations in part exist to minimize interference. Just ignoring them seems like a bad idea to me. Note that UKHAS is not a 'blanket' permission group. The society exists to promote the hobby and make sure it is safe. We don't provide permission to anyone, that's up to the individual.
- belorn 14y agoI was referring to the 2 main sites in Cambridgeshire which the website talked about, as it says you won't need to get your own permission for launching. As for risk to air crafts, I would love to see some numbers. Whats the historical reason behind allowing max 2m sized balloons with a weight of 2kg, but an unmanned aircraft with the wingspan of 3m is totally fine (so long its under 20kg). What's the risk/effects of a balloon hitting a aircraft, and is it larger than say, the risk one has from meteors? I am all for regulations when it regulates a industry or when someone is pushing the boundaries on what is safe (like dropping a car Mythbuster style). However, the current regulations looks to me at least as a bit random and inconsistent (and ... dated). Radio interference. wow, that's an old concept :). I suppose the FCC is undergoing some renewing and is slowly releasing frequencies and lowering the margins between them. The technology of handling radio interference has advanced quite a bit since the ww2/cold war where so much of the radio regulations was created, and the regulation is slowly moving forward. Know perfectly well that I will upset every licensed amateur radio operator out there, but my advice is still to take that regulation with a pinch of salt. I guess it all depend on the details of what one do, the effect the law might have, and how much common sense one apply. What the guy did however does not sound as something that should require government permission.