4 ms·
I really don't understand how Wikipedia feels like a "secondary source" is meaningful: most secondary sources (newspapers being a great example) just print what
by saurik 14y ago
I really don't understand how Wikipedia feels like a "secondary source" is meaningful: most secondary sources (newspapers being a great example) just print whatever they are told by random non-expert or highly biased primary sources; I have seen this first-hand while talking to reporters doing interviews with me on various topics. In practice, the fact checking departments, even for headline stories in the physical version of the paper for the largest publications in the country, end up just calling the primary source to get a clarification: so, if an article about Roth were to have ended up in the New York Times, Roth himself actually would have been consulted on whether or not it was true, and yet somehow going through that intermediary makes the situation more credible to Wikipedia... insanity.
Further, many secondary sources are actually themselves based on Wikipedia as their primary source: if you then are willing to cite secondary sources as verifications of information that is then posted to Wikipedia, it is highly trivial to end up with self-reinforcing information loops; in addition to there being multiple highly-cited examples of this, I have seen it happen first-hand with a friend constructing such a situation (which eventually got noticed and deleted, but only due to a highly suspicious editor that attempted to track down whether the sources were actually using Wikipedia as their reference; had it been slightly more vague I bet we would forever be stuck with that particular misinformation).
I will even argue that the idea of using secondary sources at all is short sighted: the very secondary sources that Wikipedia is attempting to cite are slowly dying out due to Internet replaces that happen to include Wikipedia itself. In another decade, the source material for remotely credible secondary sources is likely to have dwindled to almost nothing: we will be left with things more akin to wikis and blogs and the kind of broken thought streams that are characteristic of today's Twitter and Facebook: we are (quite sadly, I will argue) quite likely to no longer be allocating such funds to centralized larger sources like the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal to keep them operational.
Finally, I will point out that it ignores the heritage of an encyclopedia: as far as I understand, the way the great encyclopedias were written actually did involve conscripting the world's great minds to write what were in essence summary articles of various parts of their fields so that people in other disciplines, or even the lay person, could rapidly get a general understanding of the subject matter. (One specific place I got this impression was from reading a book about Thomas Young, who wrote a number of articles for the Encyclopedia Britannica). Yet, now, the encyclopedia that has become the de facto standard--I will argue entirely due to technology and community, and not due to the dictates that it claims are so holy--requires information to have first been published in sources like newspapers, rather than sources like academic journals... it is honestly highly depressing.