6 ms·
I don't get what is being discussed here. How is universal healthcare like fuel to a fire where cancer is concerned? I live in a country with universal care, so
by lostlogin 14y ago
I don't get what is being discussed here. How is universal healthcare like fuel to a fire where cancer is concerned?
I live in a country with universal care, so my perceptions will obviously differ to others, but I'm totally not getting what is being discussed.
- niels_olson 14y agoThe topic of universal health care is actively debated in the US. Some people have adopted a position that universal health care is less ideal than our current fee-for-service model. As they explore the merits of their position, they try adopting various arguments. He tried adopting the argument that universal healthcare leads to more access to care, which leads to more interventions between diagnosis and death for people with cancer. However, and perhaps our responses help persuade him of this, that argument ignores the vast middle ground of people who survive several years or even are effectively cured for life. It also, as my prior comment pointed out, ignores the value of routine screening, especially at the extremes of age.
- glenra 14y agoA big part of the problem in the original article is that of TOO MUCH CARE being provided regardless of cost without much consideration for whether the care is worth providing. One plausible concern about adopting "universal care" in the US is that it will make a bad situation worse, even further insulating patients from the cost of the care provided to them and thus making it more likely that we waste effort on extremely expensive procedures that don't do any good. Now, certainly one might IMAGINE putting rules in place such that this didn't happen, but that doesn't mean such rules will get put in place or will actually work as intended given our generally messed-up political process.
- pyre 14y ago> Now, certainly one might IMAGINE putting rules in > place such that this didn't happen, but that doesn't > mean such rules will get put in place or will > actually work as intended given our generally > messed-up political process. Isn't the assumption that universal health care will have no rules just as based in speculation as the idea that it will? 'Universal health care' is a pretty broad term. Most discussions that aren't about particular implementations are meaningless.
- glenra 14y agoNo, I'm sure it'll have rules intended to control costs and reduce unneeded care, but our regulatory history suggests the rules won't work as advertised. And that doesn't seem speculative at all - it's a dead certainty. Because the problem we have is NOT that individuals pay for health care, it's that health care is ludicrously expensive and ineffective and over-regulated and not subject to significant market competition on price or quality. Merely changing who writes the checks won't fix the other stuff which is the core of the problem. In every other field, new technology makes production of goods cheaper. Even in medicine, if you look at the parts where people pay without insurance - LASIK, plastic surgery, dentistry, veterinary medicine - costs get cheaper over time. The parts of medicine that tend to get ever more expensive are the parts that involve third-party payment. The book _Priceless_ has some decent suggestions for mechanisms that might help improve matters even given the existing (terrible) constraints we face.
- crusso 14y ago> The parts of medicine that tend to get ever more expensive are the parts that involve third-party payment. Medicine has a problem with third party payments that are invisible to consumers, coupled with insurance premiums invisibly negotiated by employers, coupled with ridiculous regulations that have created an enormous amount of dislocation of the economic incentives that would tend to drive prices down. In short, government got involved. What's our national solution? More government involvement. See any similarities between health insurance, retirement planning (Social Security), "free" healthcare (Medicare & Medicaid), student loan programs and the cost of college education, or maybe in the home loans that caused the housing disaster? Disaster after disaster is caused by applying heavy-handed Federal Government "solutions" to problems better solved by individuals, free markets, or at worst local and state governments.
- infinite8s 14y agoSo then do you agree with the following statement: "Individuals who do not have health care or can not pay for it should be denied treatment". That's what happens when you leave it up to free markets.
- ams6110 14y agoIn the USA, universal care is seen as a silver bullet by many who have never dealt with the reality of what it would bring. To a lot of people who support it, it's a vague undefined concept onto which they are projecting a lot of things out of their own imaginations, hopes, and fears. Depending on the implementation, "universal health care" could make some things better than they are under the present system. Some things would be worse. People will still get sick. People will still die. People will still avoid seeking treatment until their condition is untreatable, because people avoid doctors and hospitals for a lot of reasons besides monetary cost.