4 ms·
Actually, they need a law that requires immutable MAC addresses, routers that expose their NAT tables and MAC tables to "trusted third parties", and ISPs to exp
by javajosh 14y ago
Actually, they need a law that requires immutable MAC addresses, routers that expose their NAT tables and MAC tables to "trusted third parties", and ISPs to expose their physical-address-to-IP tables. Altering a MAC address, possessing contraband "open" hardware, would be a criminal offense. Like a car at the DMV, computers would need to be registered and private party transfers would have to be registered. Possession of a device with either an unregistered MAC address or an address associated with someone else would be a serious crime.
Let us hope that one day we get this, so that the MPAA and RIAA can be empowered to do the right thing and protect their copyright holders' rights.
- jiggy2011 14y agoCan you elaborate? I'm not sure what the point of such a law would be.
- pmorici 14y agoThe point would be so you could identify an individual computer and upon investigation tie it definitively to an owner. As it stands you can easily change a MAC address and the translation of private -> public IP address done by a NAT capable network device combines the traffic of multiple computers to look like it is a single one. This means you can only attribute file sharing activity to a public ip which in practice might have numerous clients behind it. Hence if there were a law like that and everyone obeyed it then you could generally identify the exact machine that did the file sharing.
- jiggy2011 14y agoYou will only usually only know the MAC address of the last hop since a new layer 2 frame is generated every time a packet hits a switch or router. For example if I watch the source MAC address of incoming HTTP requests to my server it always reports the MAC address as being the one for the router/firewall in front of the server even though the source IP addresses will vary. The only way I can think this would be possible to achieve would be to require a signed certificate and HMAC (message authentication code) from the the originating client to be sent with every IP packet and make sharing private keys a serious criminal offence. Even then it would probably be basically unenforceable on any kind of scale.