5 ms·
I think it's pretty reasonable to think both the Shah AND the Ayatollahs are bad governments, and additionally that both unilaterally nationalizing private prop
by rdl 14y ago
I think it's pretty reasonable to think both the Shah AND the Ayatollahs are bad governments, and additionally that both unilaterally nationalizing private property AND maintaining extractive industries in foreign countries without reasonable compensation to citizens are wrong.
- meric 14y agoIrrelevant. There's no reason to suggest, had United States and Britain not instigate the 1953 coup, the Iranian government would be a bad government.
- rdl 14y agoTrue -- if you didn't have the coup, it's unlikely you would have had an absolute monarch and thus probably not an islamic revolution either. The 1947-1953 government wasn't particularly stable on its own, though, and it's not like neighbors (or states anywhere) with massive natural resource finds tend toward good government, though. Reza Shah was probably the best government in modern Iranian history (although I'm not an expert). Still, if I were there in 1954-1979 I would have been against the Shah, and 1979-now against the IR. (although my level of "against" probably would have been "GTFO and go try to start a business in the UK or US or even UAE".)
- user9756 14y agoThe reason the "Ayatollahs" are a "bad government" has more to do with the fact that they do not yield to US power. The Shah on the other hand was considered, or would have been considered, a "moderate"--you know like the moderate Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Egypt (before their liberation), and so on.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe reason the "Ayatollahs" are a "bad government" has more to do with the fact that they do not yield to US power. To be fair, many also consider them a "bad government" because they execute rape victims and homosexuals, torture prisoners, that sort of thing.
- noarchy 14y agoHere's what Human Rights Watch had to say about Iran in 2011: http://www.hrw.org/world-report-2011/iran http://www.hrw.org/world-report-2011/iran
- user9756 14y ago"Human rights" -reports on Iran are highly politicised; criticism against Iran is often based on political reasons and not for a real concern about any “human rights” issue. Btw, if the report you're linking to is the same one I read about then it uses highly questionable sources (I think it was MEK operatives, not sure though).
- tptacek 14y agoThis isn't a "Human rights"-report on Iran. It's the Human Rights Watch report on Iran. HRW has been critical of the US as well. Any claim that HRW is part of a propaganda machine working against Iran is an extraordinary claim, and the onus is on you to back it up with evidence. It's particularly difficult to have that claim stand on its own when it's so easy to get firsthand narratives of the brutality of the Iranian regime from other sources. It doesn't take MEK spies to reveal the stories of people tortured hung from construction cranes for writing subversive blog posts.
- user9756 14y ago"Any claim that HRW is part of a propaganda machine working against Iran" - never made that claim "the onus is on you to back it up with evidence." - funny how that burden never seem to apply to those making the actual accusations. Often someone makes a claim about brutality and it's accepted at face value simply because the accused is somebody we don't like politically.
- tptacek 14y agoThe people making the accusations include Human Rights Watch. Are they lying? Are they shills for the MEK?
- eternalban 14y agoShah of Iran was considered a threat to the Western interests in the 70s. http://masoudbehnoud.com/weblog/s2.pdf http://masoudbehnoud.com/weblog/s2.pdf (Real history)
- user9756 14y agoAnd what happened to him? Thanks for the link, I'll look into it later. I have read about how the US negotiated with the "Mullahs" so that they could replace the Shah with them (in hope to have another Saudi Arabia?), but the US was "betrayed". If we had some real journalist rather than those sad bunch of propagandist working for the corporate/state interests, we might have had a better understanding of what is going on in the world.