6 ms·
This piece is blatant anti-Iranian propaganda, because it fails to give any context for the events of 1979. It entirely omits any reason why Americans became un
by jdietrich 14y ago
This piece is blatant anti-Iranian propaganda, because it fails to give any context for the events of 1979. It entirely omits any reason why Americans became unwelcome in Iran. The islamic revolution occurred in Iran as a direct result of the hostile actions of the CIA, who in 1953 overthrew the democratically elected leader of Iran and installed the Shah as an absolute monarch, with full authorisation from Eisenhower and Churchill. It is an entirely uncontroversial matter of historical record that the British and American government acted to prevent the establishment of democratic rule in Iran, in order to secure supplies of cheap oil.
Without providing this context, the piece portrays American diplomats in Iran as hapless victims; In fact, they were active participants in the machinery used to oppress the Iranian people. Most Americans remain completely unaware of the events of the 1953 coup; This makes any mention of the '79 revolution without the context of the '53 coup propaganda, plain and simple. It is the direct moral equivalent of telling people that you were beaten up by some guy, while omitting the fact that you had raped his wife and shot his dog. The omission is as deceptive as any lie.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%C3%A9tat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%C3%A9tat
- agilebyte 14y agoThe article was a mildly engaging spy story, not a Wiki entry. Chillax...
- rdl 14y agoI think it's pretty reasonable to think both the Shah AND the Ayatollahs are bad governments, and additionally that both unilaterally nationalizing private property AND maintaining extractive industries in foreign countries without reasonable compensation to citizens are wrong.
- meric 14y agoIrrelevant. There's no reason to suggest, had United States and Britain not instigate the 1953 coup, the Iranian government would be a bad government.
- rdl 14y agoTrue -- if you didn't have the coup, it's unlikely you would have had an absolute monarch and thus probably not an islamic revolution either. The 1947-1953 government wasn't particularly stable on its own, though, and it's not like neighbors (or states anywhere) with massive natural resource finds tend toward good government, though. Reza Shah was probably the best government in modern Iranian history (although I'm not an expert). Still, if I were there in 1954-1979 I would have been against the Shah, and 1979-now against the IR. (although my level of "against" probably would have been "GTFO and go try to start a business in the UK or US or even UAE".)
- user9756 14y agoThe reason the "Ayatollahs" are a "bad government" has more to do with the fact that they do not yield to US power. The Shah on the other hand was considered, or would have been considered, a "moderate"--you know like the moderate Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Egypt (before their liberation), and so on.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe reason the "Ayatollahs" are a "bad government" has more to do with the fact that they do not yield to US power. To be fair, many also consider them a "bad government" because they execute rape victims and homosexuals, torture prisoners, that sort of thing.
- noarchy 14y agoHere's what Human Rights Watch had to say about Iran in 2011: http://www.hrw.org/world-report-2011/iran http://www.hrw.org/world-report-2011/iran
- user9756 14y ago"Human rights" -reports on Iran are highly politicised; criticism against Iran is often based on political reasons and not for a real concern about any “human rights” issue. Btw, if the report you're linking to is the same one I read about then it uses highly questionable sources (I think it was MEK operatives, not sure though).
- tptacek 14y agoThis isn't a "Human rights"-report on Iran. It's the Human Rights Watch report on Iran. HRW has been critical of the US as well. Any claim that HRW is part of a propaganda machine working against Iran is an extraordinary claim, and the onus is on you to back it up with evidence. It's particularly difficult to have that claim stand on its own when it's so easy to get firsthand narratives of the brutality of the Iranian regime from other sources. It doesn't take MEK spies to reveal the stories of people tortured hung from construction cranes for writing subversive blog posts.
- Radim 14y agoI also like how they consistently place "spies" in double quotes ... only to admit several sentences later that many actually were, with ample evidence published in the painstakingly reconstructed "Documents From the US Espionage Den" :)
- pflats 14y agoThose are called scare quotes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes
- Gring 14y agoAgree 100%. The 1953 coup was one of the worst things US foreign affairs did. It's probably the biggest reason why America is viewed with so much contempt throughout the middle east, still. Not mentioning this fact to an audience that might be oblivious to it is inexcusable. I wonder how the just released movie handles this fact?
- rjbond3rd 14y agoIt is well covered in the film's expository introduction, which uses storyboard-like illustrations and a voice-over to explain the history.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe story is about the ingenious use of diplomatic and intelligence resources to accomplish a daring cross-border mission in an innovative way. It is not to provide a balanced summary of the geopolitical structure of the Middle East. An article about a CIA exfil from Iran need cover the full socio-political context as much as a story about a Berlin entrepreneur need re-hash WWII. One of the strengths of the Wired article is that it presents the nuclear story and avoids the proximal drama. The preceding comment, on the other hand, labels the six subjects of the article as "active participants in the machinery used to oppress the Iranian people".
- enraged_camel 14y agoWe get what the story is about. What the preceding comment points out that the story in question lacks important context in an effort to impart the wrong messages and ideas. This is not OK.
- rdtsc 14y agoI get this strange feeling you might not be supporting a similar purely technical description of the story had it been about the Taliban finding a new way to remotely detonate IEDs to blow up Western convoys using a cool spread spectrum in order to avoid jamming.
- melling 14y agoI saw the movie Argo yesterday. It did a great job of not presenting the Iranians as the bad guys. Within the first 10 minutes you know why they took the embassy. In fact, I'd say I have a much more positive view of Iran now. It was an excellent movie.
- eternalban 14y agoNote the timing, as well. I take issue with your thoughtless repetition of given "facts" via NYTimes and other interested parties regarding 53. The Shah of Iran was the Shah of Iran prior to '53 and after '53. Dr. Mossadeq was appointed per constitution of Iran and was dismissed per the same constitution by the monarch. He refused to accept his dismissal. Did you know he was a prince of the prior (deposed and alien) ruling family? Did you know he dissolved the parliament? The counter-coup of 53 was initiated and carried out by the Iranian military officers who upheld their constitutional oath. The fact that NYTimes, and other "interested parties" to this day take joy twisting facts, rewriting history, and casting calumny on a man (that most certainly will be remembered as one of the greatest Persian Kings of Iran) is fully informative for the student of history/geo-politics ...
- evan_ 14y ago> Note the timing, as well. The article was published April 24, 2007.
- eternalban 14y agoThe movie.
- elteto 14y ago> The omission is as deceptive as any lie No it isn't. This is not about why the events happened. It is about how one CIA operative mounted a brilliant operation to rescue a group of people from a hostile environment. It is all about facts, which is what journalism should really be about. > Without providing this context, the piece portrays American diplomats in Iran as hapless victims. In fact, they were active participants in the machinery used to oppress the Iranian people. Bullshit. Not one janitor, clerk attendant and marine soldier that worked on the embassy took part in any oppression of the Iranian people. Two wrongs don't make one right, and saying that the attack was in someway justified is just disgusting. So what's next? 9/11 was justified because a bunch of ordinary people are part of the imperialist machine?
- Evbn 14y agoIf the janitor is being used as a human shield, the shielded is culpable.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoDespite coups, despite wars, etc. the embassy has been held as being above all that. Civilized societies do not invade embassies, they do not hold diplomats as hostages, they do not kill or threaten to kill diplomats, period. This is true even in a time of war. When the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor with a sneak attack the US did not storm the Japanese embassy, they did not hold Japanese diplomats hostage. They did not claim that the Japanese diplomats were secretly spies. Etc. That sort of boorish behavior is not and should not ever be tolerated. If you cannot tolerate the continued presence of a country's diplomats in your country then you eject them, you do not hold them hostage. Period.
- rayiner 14y agoThey might well have done that had Pearl Harbor been an overthrow of Congress rather than a bombing of a far-flung military base. It did result in Japanese Internment after all.
- rohamg 14y agoOk I agree with your point but bad example: America did not storm the embassy but did forcibly intern thousands of Japanese Americans in concentration camps. Also- its important to note a few things: 1) the embassy storming was carried out on a whim by one group of over eager revolutionaries, it was not officially sanctioned until it was a fait accomplie, 2) saying the 1979 revolution was a direct result of the 1953 coup is bumbling self centrism at best - a lot happened in the country over that period that culminated in the revolution. Which leads to 3) Khomeini was not the stated aim of the revolution- a democracy was. Khomeini and the Islamists hijacked the revolution and killed, imprisoned, or exiled all other parties involved until that point. They have maintained control since then with history's most sophisticated religio-political machinery combining censorship and xenophobia, police state security infrastructure, and a unique brand of divine mysticism. Fascinating and tragic.
- Evbn 14y agoYour vision falls apart where embassies are actively involved in espionage, as they nearly always are. Embassy immunity is like saying it is OK to shoot an and enemy soldier but not an enemy president? Why, because he real war isn't nation vs nation, but sociopolitical elite vs humanity.