3 ms·
Hm, to me it sounds like a sequence of overlapping falling tones. There's a noticeable point where the falling tone is supplemented by one above it. This first
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
Hm, to me it sounds like a sequence of overlapping falling tones. There's a noticeable point where the falling tone is supplemented by one above it. This first happens about 20s in.
edit The noticeable change seems to be very close to 22s.
- mojuba 14y agoIt does sound like an auditory illusion to many, as not everyone can isolate tones in a mixed sound. I'm curious if you happen to be a musician or a sound engineer?
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoNope, I'm not a musician or sound guy. I'm a coder. But I do enjoy music. That falling tone on the Wikipedia page sounds like something from one of coil's tracks. I can't pinpoint which one though? they use similar sounds here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6IR90tgtDI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6IR90tgtDI and here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_R-mXRONh0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_R-mXRONh0 edit Expectation may pay a part - when told "come and listen to this 'endlessly falling' auditory illusion" of course I'm going to try and pick out the subtle seams. I might not notice if it was in the background, unannounced.
- fhars 14y agoI usually can't hear individual tones in, say, a chord, but I heard this effect too. But far more prominent on my crappy laptop speakers (which produce no low tones whatsoever) than with cheap headphones that have a more linear frequency characteristic.
- chad_oliver 14y agoI couldn't hear anything like that. Mind you, I expect the phenomenon is highly subjective and varies from person to person.
- niyazpk 14y agoFWIW I am also able to notice those points very clearly.
- jtheory 14y agoI studied music undergrad; I remember learning about Shepard tones in one of the early theory classes, and finding the idea fascinating, but it was a disappointment when we actually heard examples. I'm not quite sure what I imagined the experience would be, but to my perception you're right... even when the switch-over (from the higher note as the most prominent, to the one an octave below) is very smooth, there's just a moment where you hear both notes clearly, then the higher note fades out. It might be more interesting to play with Shepard tones in a more complicated arrangement -- i.e., instead of one prominent note that fades into the next one an octave down, you might have 4-5 prominent notes, fading into others with staggered switch-overs -- possibly all at octave splits, but possibly in a more interesting harmonic blend. The idea is still interesting. :)
- waqf 14y agoThe human ear is not equally sensitive to different frequencies, and it's most sensitive at a fairly narrow band at a few kHz. If you don't correct for that when synthesizing your tones, then one pitch may be much more prominent than the others.