5 ms·
This is my problem with Ubuntu and Unity, and why I much prefer Linux Mint as a "Windows replacement" OS. They say they made that side bar to "work well with to
by mtgx 14y ago
This is my problem with Ubuntu and Unity, and why I much prefer Linux Mint as a "Windows replacement" OS. They say they made that side bar to "work well with touchscreen devices, too", but as we can see Unity on a touchscreen devices offers a pretty poor experience, and the sidebar is just about the only thing that is meant for touchscreens in Ubuntu. The global menu and everything else is clearly meant for a PC and a mouse.
So why annoy the PC users with the sidebar, when it's not even that good of a UI for tablets? They're much better off designing a tablet-first UI for tablets, if they want to get into that, and stick with designing a well optimized PC UI for PC's.
I've never been a believer of one UI for all form factors and sizes, because you usually end up with the UI being optimized just for one form factor and size, and mediocre or downright terrible for others. You need to optimize the UI for its own form factor and size. It's the only way to make it work well.
- levesque 14y agoI'm going to argue that the real tablet UI elements developed by the guys at Canonical are the lenses (aka the dash), not the side menu. They are full screen, display large icons, allow you to implement a lot of features (e.g., see Music/video, Documents and Shopping lenses) while using the same UI. The top bar is only important for its notification icons - the global menu is slowly going to fade out, replaced by in-app icons (see for example google chrome). I agree with you that one UI for all form factors and sizes is probably a bad idea, but I think I see where they are going for tablets. I pretty much hate Unity for the desktop, but I think for tablets it will make sense.
- itry 14y agoI was an Ubuntu user for years. When tablets became famous, I was thinking: Wow, if I only could have Ubuntu on these devices. Then they lost me because of Unity. I tried several days, but it was simply not geared toward my workflow. Thank God I discovered Mint. Mint is awesome. Then they introduced this new find-something-thing that sends everything you type to their servers. A privacy nightmare. And a usability nightmare. Thats just the wrong philosophy. So I also dont want them on my tablets. Its surprising, how quick things can change. I was a huge Ubuntu supporter from 2005 to 2012. And now I warn people to not use it.
- Riesling 14y ago> I was a huge Ubuntu supporter from 2005 to 2012. And now I warn people to not use it. Wow, this is sad. Especially since it is so easy to install a different window manager on ubuntu. sudo aptitude install xubuntu-desktop will install xfce for example.
- itry 14y agoI tried it. But I like Gnome 2 a lot more then xfce. For example in xfce you cannot reorder the entries in the task bar.
- Riesling 14y agoThen install Gnome 2 with sudo aptitude install gnome-session-fallback The best part is that you can install a multitude of window managers and decide at login time which one to use. This is one of the big advantages of Linux.
- jiggy2011 14y agoUnity is a long way from perfect on tablet or PC. Having said that the sidebar has grown on me. Since almost every monitor out there is 16:9; vertical space is precious and another 50 pixels gives me another 2-3 lines of code on the screen. The best way to use the sidebar is to put your most commonly used program at the top and then launch them with Logo+<Number>. If you spend some time setting up your shortcut keys you can actually use much of your system mouse free. So I'm not really sure that it is targeted towards tablets. It could however be adapted to be tablet friendly a lot more easily than the MS Windows interface or older Window managers could be. So rather than having this jarring difference between Metro and Desktop like you do in Windows 8 they could have a much more subtle transition of the same interface depending on whether a mouse/keyboard was plugged in or not.
- seanl 14y agoI just wish that Logo+<Number> didn't require you to hold the Logo key for a second or so before you press the number. I want quicker switching between apps than that.
- fmstephe 14y agoWhile it is very true that Unity is slow to launch applications I regularly launch a browser with Logo+1 hitting both immediately and releasing. The browser is launched and the side bar never even makes an appearance. You don't need to wait for the side bar to slide out. :)
- jiggy2011 14y agoYou need to wait if you want the numbers to pop up on the icons, if you just want to switch programs you can do it instantly.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vondur 14y ago
- andrewaylett 14y agoNot all PC users are annoyed by the side-bar -- I really like it, despite thinking I'd hate it when I first upgraded. I actually have my Windows 7 PC at work set up in a very similar way -- task bar at the side. In both, Win-[1-9] will switch to the respective application. Most applications I use are pinned, so I don't have to interact with either start panel very often. My Unity task bar auto-hides, and with maximised windows losing their title bars and menus (until I disabled that feature as I like focus-follows-mouse) living in the panel, full-screen applications take up pretty much the whole screen.
- wazoox 14y agoWhat's so new with this side bar? It seems to me that I've been using my PC this way thanks to Windowmaker for the past 15 years already.
- dysoco 14y agoI like the sidebar, just reduce the icon size to something normal and you have something similar to Windows 7's panel.
- keithpeter 14y agoYup, I saw the original article and thought 'good look with LibreOffice on that' Then I checked the specifications of the tablet: headphone socket, built in microphone, and so I could get puredata running on it with (perhaps) jack audio. That would open up the prospect of sound generation by touch. Puredata allows you to make your own interfaces so large buttons to hit. Also http://dinisnoise.org/ http://dinisnoise.org/ I could almost justify a ton and a half in UK money for that alone. What I'm saying here is that a cheap touch tablet is not for me a general purpose device, but could fulfill a specific purpose.
- jordanthoms 14y agoThat would be cool, but keep in mind that the headphone output is (unfortunately) not so great.
- YokoZar 14y agoGlobal menubar is not exclusive to mice: it saves considerable screen space. This is a major feature on mobile.
- notatoad 14y ago>They say they made that side bar to "work well with touchscreen devices, too" did they say that? People said that when ubuntu released unity, mostly critics, but i don't remember any official statement saying that unity was designed as a touch-friendly interface. Bigger targets are better for mouse users as well.
- s_baby 14y agoThe sidebar is meant to work with keyboard shortcuts. Super + position of sidebar icon: launch application Super + W: layout all applications in workspace Super + S: layout all workspaces Unity is still quirky but the productivity I gain from the shortcuts is worth it.
- zurn 14y agoCan you expand on how Mint is superior on tablets? I agree it Ubuntu isn't very good on tablets. But the sidebar works OK on PC, like it does on Macs.
- mtgx 14y agoI meant I like Mint more on PC's, not tablets.