3 ms·
Without tying to be harsh I'd say 'get over it'. Many people come up with the same idea around the same time (take a look at Newton and Leibniz). Also, it wou
by jgrahamc 18y ago
Without tying to be harsh I'd say 'get over it'.
Many people come up with the same idea around the same time (take a look at Newton and Leibniz). Also, it wouldn't be a great surprise if information leaked inside YC. I bet PG isn't willing to sign an NDA when you come to see him (and no VC will sign an NDA). That's not to say that PG is being malicious, it's just the nature of being exposed to thousands of business plans that they'll be leakage between them.
- jacquesm 18y agoWithout trying to be harsh, and given your 'orange' status I realize I'm walking on thin ice here ;), but don't you think that to say that you would not be surprised that there would be leakage within YC of people pitching to established contacts is potentially highly damaging for YC and that that in turn would make people skittyish of pitching to YC ? I know the VC's that I work for are exceptionally dilligent in avoiding such exposure, they would never ever stand for such a claim being made about them.
- swombat 18y agoJust a little meta-nit-pick, but honestly, his "orange status" should not make you feel like you're "walking on thin ice" or otherwise impede your urge to declare your disagreement.
- inklesspen 18y agoHis orange status should not exist.
- jacquesm 18y agohence the ;) I thought that was pretty obvious, forgive me.
- jgrahamc 18y agoI agree. Ignore my oranginess when replying to my posts.
- sethg 18y agoAs I understand it, VCs routinely refuse to sign NDAs, because (as mentioned elsewhere) it's very common for two teams to independently come up with the same idea, and the VCs don't want to be in a situation where they have to convince a jury that they didn't reject a certain team's proposal and then leak the underlying idea to someone else. (And yeah, I'm cynical enough to assume that once in a while that's exactly what happens.) So in this respect YC is no worse than anyone else.
- davidw 18y agoYour Orangeness, I have a niggling doubt about YC - that their connections and network and the whole environment might make the difference between success and failure in marginal cases, or the difference between a moderate success and a big success in other cases, if other things are mostly the same: a couple of smart, motivated hackers. If this is indeed the case, people are right to feel bad if they get rejected, because they lost out on a big opportunity. It would be interesting to be able to test the "YC effect", but difficult. One way might be for PG and company to select a group of people who are ... perhaps not 'mediocre', but not quite as good as the rest, and see how well they do (obviously you can't tell them that they're the test group). However, that has obvious problems: 15K+ is a decent chunk of change to spend on an experiment, and it's not a 'double blind'. (Disclosure: never applied to YC, likely never will, unfortunately)