4 ms·
> All comments, complaints, corrections, and retraction requests? Unmoderated? Einstein articles will be full of comments explaining why he is wrong, from racis
by Calavar 8mo ago
> All comments, complaints, corrections, and retraction requests? Unmoderated? Einstein articles will be full of comments explaining why he is wrong, from racist to people that can spell Minkowski to save their lives. In /newest there is like one post per week from someone that discover a new physics theory with the help of ChatGPT. Sometimes it's the same guy, sometimes it's a new one.
Judging from PubPeer, which allows people to post all of the above anonymously and with minimal moderation, this is not an issue in practice.
- bee_rider 8mo agoThey mentioned a famous work, which will naturally attract cranks to comment on it. I’d also expect to get weird comments on works with high political relevance.
- gus_massa 8mo agoLink to PubPerr https://pubpeer.com/publications/F9538AA8AC2ECC7511800234CC4910 https://pubpeer.com/publications/F9538AA8AC2ECC7511800234CC4... It has 0 comments, for an article that forgot "not" in "the result is *** statistical significative".
- Calavar 8mo agoIsn't a lack of comments the opposite of the problem you were previously claiming?