3 ms·
We sit in the YC house. We full well know that we rarely end up with the idea we start out with. This makes the idea itself, worthless, and starting to validate
by j45 14y ago
We sit in the YC house. We full well know that we rarely end up with the idea we start out with. This makes the idea itself, worthless, and starting to validate any idea much more important and valuable.
Ideas are relatively worthless because there's so many out there that are reasonably possible. "Software is eating the world".
Ideas are also relatively worthless because any idea person is paralyzed by at least 47 of their own before someone shows up asking to sign an NDA for the 48th. Ask any technically capable business minded person.
Ideas are also worthless compared to execution on them.
Ideas are also worthless without the implementation expertise and marketing expertise to get it real, and the money that it might take, whether its funding or bootstrapped.
If the idea doesn't come with an owner who can code or market, they better be bringing their own money or some way to pay for the time of others. I have plenty of my own reasonably validated ideas and niches dying for attention that I could rather lose time and my own money on.
The "idea" guys in my life know now an idea is worthless without the real legs that will prop it up, the skills to build, the skills to build the right thing, and the skills to find and reach your audience. Giving an idea more value than traction with a paying audience is confusing activity with results in many ways.
Ideas might be more valuable to someone who doesn't have any other value to add in getting from activity to a measurable result.
Got an idea that still stands that test? It's much more worth talking about :)
- lubujackson 14y ago"Possible" ideas and "profitable" ideas are two different things. YC is a place where ideas are devalued the most since PG has admitted he's just taking a scattershot approach to investing and focusing instead on teams. At the end of the day, you need to have a good idea. Yeah, there are many ideas that are feasible but only a few blockbusters - that's the point.
- j45 14y agoI don't disagree with you. The clarification between possible and profitable is a subtle and important one. An organization is only as good as the people behind it and their ability to chart a course forward. I'm not sure if YC devalues them or values the team more -- I'd certainly want the people beside me to be of a certain caliber regardless of what we faced or came up with.
- dasil003 14y agoOne thing to consider is the negative value of executing on a bad idea. This increases the abstract value of good ideas because the bad ideas actively sap execution potential.
- j45 14y agoTotally. One bad decision snowballs another and someone tries to channel their inner Steve Jobs, when, no one is Steve Jobs. It's one of the things I really like about lean. It forces me to shut up and forget my own opinion or beliefs. It forces me to pursue a craft and get the measurements before moving forward instead of falling risk to hallucinating my own grandeur accidentally. I like it because it helps keep me grounded, pragmatic, and focused.
- rhizome 14y agoThat's total sunk-cost fallacy. You can only work on what you think makes sense at the time. Don't borrow trouble, or even borrow hindsight-bias.
- dasil003 14y agoHuh? I'm talking in the abstract. Yes, people work on what they think makes sense, but they don't know what makes sense. Therefore an "idea guy" who tends to have good ideas has a value that may never be achieved by an engineer who can execute phenomenally well but tends to have bad ideas. Just because you can't quantify it doesn't mean it's not there.