3 ms·
He uses the metric "if you can't see the individual pixels, then a higher resolution won't help", which is absolute and complete bunk. Improvements are notice
by bryanlarsen 14y ago
He uses the metric "if you can't see the individual pixels, then a higher resolution won't help", which is absolute and complete bunk. Improvements are noticeable well before then. Try this experiment: take an iPad 1 and put it far enough away from you so that you can no longer see the individual pixels. For me that's an outstretched arm. Now compare to a retina iPad. The difference is huge even though I can't "see" the individual pixels.
That being said, 4K isn't going to do much good with the typical 40 or 50 inch screen. Reports are that 80" is where the improvements really start to become real, though. Not surprising: at 80", the pixels on a 4K screen are about the same size as the pixels on a 40" 1080p screen. That's assuming that you don't sit further back. And you shouldn't.
There are reasons that IMAX is a much better experience than a typical theatre, and a reason why the large screen at the theatre is a better experience than the one you have at home.
- immersion, that feeling of being inside the movie yourself.
- peripheral vision. Movies properly framed for IMAX are zoomed further out than a typical movie. Your eyes are focused on the center of the screen, and the edges are only visible with your peripheral vision.
So yes, to really get the benefit of 4K you need to view Imax or similar content on it, sitting up close to a big screen. There isn't much of it, but perhaps there will be more in the future.
- pja 14y agoThe difference is huge even though I can't "see" the individual pixels. Take a lesson from the audio compression people: If you're not doing a blinded comparison, then you will fool yourself when doing this kind of comparison.
- mason55 14y agoIt really depends on your definition of "seeing the pixels". There is definitely a difference between the iPad screens however I wouldn't necessarily say that I can "see the pixels" on the original one. It's more that text and images aren't as clear due to a lower pixel density.
- tibbon 14y agoI agree. I never had a problem with my 3S screen until I had my 4S and turned on the 3S a few months later... looks terrible.
- pja 14y agoOnce again, the 3S screen is lower resolution than your visual acuity at normal viewing distance, so the 4S is a clear upgrade. The linked article is talking about the pointlessness of upgrading to a higher resolution when the screen in question is already higher resolution than your eyeball is capable of resolving.
- amorphid 14y agoI was thinking something similar. My 13" MacBook Air has a decent screen for my purposes,.but I noticed the retina display on the new 15" MacBook Pro is much sharper. I can definitely tell a difference, which may or Kay not be the pixel count.
- pja 14y agoThe resolution on a MacBook Air is low enough that you can resolve the individual pixels at your normal viewing distance. The difference here is that a 720P TV already has pixels smaller than the resolving power of your eyeball at normal living room viewing distances; 1080P even more so. Going to 4K is completely pointless unless you're viewing the screen from sufficiently close up that it makes a difference. People doing film editing want these kind of displays because they are going to be putting the data in front of viewers who will be close enough to resolve features at that kind of resolution. But that's because they're going to be putting the data in front of the viewing audience at their local multiplex, not in their living rooms.
- sageikosa 14y agoRemember to occasionally give your older screen a good cleaning. New displays always look clearer due to a lack of dust and skin oils diffracting and fuzzing the light.
- aw3c2 14y agoIf you cannot differentiate the smallest visible unit of the screen, the pixels, then what do you actually differentiate? Surely nothing related to screen resolution/density.
- mason55 14y agoI think there needs to be some clarification as to what "seeing the pixels" means. If you lean in close enough you can actually see the individual RGB components. Further back and you can see the separation between pixels still. Even further back and you can make out the difference between something that's aliased and anti-aliased. When someone says you can "see the pixels" I think of the second level there, where you can see gaps between the individual pixels. However upping the resolution can help decrease the jagginess in things like non-anti-aliased text.
- pja 14y agoThis is not about being able to see the gaps between the pixels. Anti-aliased vs not anti-aliased I'll grant you, because the whole point of anti-aliasing is to approximate what the eye would see if it really was averaging a real image over the solid angle taken up by each individual pixel.
- leviathant 14y agoOn my iPhone4, even though it's a 'retina' display, I can still notice the stair-stepping in movement. Still photos look great, but from a video perspective, 'retina' isn't necessarily an accurate descriptor. This is less true of full-motion video than it is of scrolling in an application. As thrilled as I am about pixel density on modern portable devices, it will benefit them to go higher still. The returns are diminishing, but they are there.
- pja 14y agoDoes the iPhone still drop the texture resolution when it's scrolling? (I haven't looked closely at anything recent.)