3 ms·
I just looked into this, and to me it represents philosophy masquerading as logic. Reasonable people may differ. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almost_surely htt
by lutusp 14y ago
I just looked into this, and to me it represents philosophy masquerading as logic. Reasonable people may differ.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almost_surely http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almost_surely
A quote: "In probability theory, one says that an event happens almost surely (sometimes abbreviated as a.s.) if it happens with probability one."
This is like saying a dollar is approximately 100 pennies, or every woman is approximately pregnant (or the reverse).
Another quote: "Equivalently, we can say an event E happens almost surely if the probability of E not occurring is zero."
With probability theory being guided by notions like this, no wonder insurance is so expensive. To me, it is to probability theory what post-modernism is to literature -- it reduces everything to a matter of opinion.
In analysis, we have the notion of a limit, the idea that we can say something about a quantity that is only approached, never reached. Example:
lim x -> 0, 1/x = ∞
Technically this says "as x approaches zero, 1/x approaches infinity." But I can't tell you how many times I have heard this stated as "as x approaches zero, 1/x equals zero." But that's not so -- division by zero is undefined, so the problem as stated can never be described as anything but a limit, an approach.
The reverse logic applies to a probability of 1.0 -- 1.0 is not approximately anything, it's 1.0. It's not "almost one", it's "one". And if you subtract one from it, the result is not almost zero, it's zero.
> but it makes sense from a Math point of view.
Only if probability theory transcends the axioms of logic, and with the assumption that logic is the foundation on which mathematics is built.
- cdavid 14y agoYou're confused about the meaning of almost surely, and your comparison with dollars and pregnancy is misleading. The almost does not apply to the probability being one, but to the meaning of of P(S) = 1 for S a member of your sigma-algebra. So when one says that a real number is almost surely normal, it means P({a is normal; a is real}) = 1, but it does not mean that any real is normal. Indeed, there are infinitely many non normal numbers (for example, every integer is obviously not normal), even though the probability that a number is not normal is 0. In the case of finite probability spaces, this usually does not happen, because for two finite sets A and B, #A != #B usually implies P(A) != P(B) [1], which is why your comparison with pennies/pregnancy is misleading. [1] it is certainly possible to build probability spaces on finite sets where P(A) == P(B) and #A != #B.
- lutusp 14y ago> You're confused about the meaning of almost surely ... Yes, but I'm not the only one. I think most people who read the justification for describing p = 1.0 as "almost surely" will have the same reaction, regardless of their training. Not to argue that logic must accept responsibility for our confusion. > your comparison with dollars and pregnancy is misleading. As to dollars, yes (because it's finite and trivial), but as to the parturient state of a set of women, it depends on the size of the set. For an infinite set of women, to describe them all as almost surely pregnant (or not), is a reasonable corollary to describing p = 1.0 as "almost surely" in the general case. > Indeed, there are infinitely many non normal numbers (for example, every integer is obviously not normal), even though the probability that a number is not normal is 0. This compares two infinite sets and draws a conclusion based on the outcome (the set of integers is infinite in size, and the set of numbers (reals and integers) is also infinite in size). I'm not sure this is comparable to making a statement about the mapping of a single well-defined probability (for example the appearance of War and Peace) into a single infinite set, like the presumed infinite set of the digits of Pi. Which leads to an obvious question -- does the "almost surely" qualifier apply to all p = 1.0 probabilities, or only a subset? In other words, does the qualifier depend on the construction of the probability, or does it always apply?
- jules 14y agoTo understand these issues, you should read up on measure theory: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measure_(mathematics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measure_(mathematics) pi is a single fixed number, so it doesn't help to talk about probabilities. Either every finite length sequence appears in pi, or at least one doesn't. The technical term "almost surely" applies to all p=1 probabilities, even those where it's really certain that the event happens. This does not match with common understanding of "almost surely" because we'd not usually make a statement like "the decimal expansion of pi almost surely contains the number 4", but mathematically it's a correct statement. It's important to keep in mind that this is technical terminology, so intuition does not always apply. It also means that it does not make sense to talk about women being almost surely pregnant without first defining a probability distribution. If we define each woman to be pregnant with a probability of 1%, independent of the pregnancy status of other women, and we have an infinite number of women, then almost surely at least one of them is pregnant. That is, the probability that at least one of them is pregnant is 1. But it's not certain that at least one of them is pregnant, it could be that all of them are not pregnant. Similarly, if we choose a number uniformly in the interval [0,1], then the probability of choosing 1/3 is 0, but it's possible that we chose 1/3. We cannot ignore that as an impossibility either, otherwise when we chose a number x, we could always claim "it's impossible that we chose exactly x!".