5 ms·
The biggest problem I see is that it will discourage deep exchanges which are one of the most valuable phenomena that occur here.
by dasil003 18y ago
The biggest problem I see is that it will discourage deep exchanges which are one of the most valuable phenomena that occur here.
- TrevorJ 18y agoThe other thing that didn't hit me is that I enjoy commenting on things that are on the "new" page -many of those stories don't make it to the front page and as a result comments don't get replied to or upmodded as much.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThis has multiple unintended consequences. Forget commenting on anything that won't hit the front page. Also forget commenting later on in a story when it gets stale. Best to hit a hot story when it is fresh and a lot of other people will be piling on later.
- gravitycop 18y agoNoted in a submission: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=467427 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=467427
- bloch 18y agoYou seem to imply that people primarely comment to get an orange highlight. I don't think the majority of users are that stupid.
- Xichekolas 18y agoGive people a status symbol and they invariably try to attain it.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'm amazed that you would have a karma system, special colored status indicators, and yet people would still claim that it doesn't affect user behavior. That's the point, guys. If the karma/colored system didn't affect user behavior, it wouldn't be there
- far33d 18y agoCreate a game, and people will play it as a game. Put a number next to someone or a color and people will change behavior to change the color/number. Especially hacker/gamer/competitive males, which are clearly represented pretty well here at HN.
- Jebdm 18y agoThat's a really good point. I thought that maybe you could solve this by dividing the story karma by the comment karma, but then you get the opposite effect; it hurts you to make a new comment on a front-page item and helps you to make one on a less-upvoted item. Maybe that itself would be a good thing. Another approach would be to normalize the comment's score against the other comments on that story, and use a threshold on that. If there were 4 comments with karmas 1 to 4 and another story with 100 comments from 1 to 100, the 4 on the first would be just as good as the 100 on the second. That might be too much work, though ;)
- eru 18y agoHow about: comment karma / min (1, max (story karma, 10) But your normalization idea might work better.
- nostrademons 18y agoI've found that much of my karma has come from commenting on stories on the New page. Yeah, many don't make it to the front page - but the ones that do haven't been seen by many people, and so when they do, everyone reads your comment and hopefully upvotes it. It's much like startups. Many of them fail, but the ones that succeed tend to succeed big.
- xenophanes 18y agoThose are also discouraged by PG asking people not to do them, and punishing people who do.
- jmackinn 18y agoCould you please elaborate on that.
- xenophanes 18y agoHe has several times asked people to stop posting in deeply nested threads. e.g. a recent thread about parenting. And he has sometimes disabled accounts for participating in deeply nested threads he didn't like.
- jmackinn 18y agoI don't think pg has ever disabled accounts for having a long discussion. I've also have never read the idea of long conversations being discouraged by anyone here.
- xenophanes 18y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=416933 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=416933
- tptacek 18y agoGod knows there are things about the pg-cult that irritate me, but the point of this site is that it has an opinion on what its culture should be. I'm the other half of the thread you're pointing to, and when the site's "curator" said "please stop", it didn't take much thought to figure out the right response. What's weird is, why are you still thinking about this? It was weeks ago. Life is very short.
- xenophanes 18y ago
- trominos 18y agoI agree. I think the algorithm should take comment depth into account. Make it take thread age/traffic into account too. I don't want to worry about posting in dead or near-dead threads. Overall, though, if we can figure out how to implement this without discouraging good commenting, it could be a pretty nice change. My biggest problem with the system as it stands is this: there are two HN posters who I think of as exceptionally insightful, prolific, and committed to the maintenance of the community, and one of them doesn't have a highlighted name -- I assume because he's posted a lot in low traffic areas. That's a major bug.
- pg 18y agoDo you mean deeply nested comment threads? I don't think many users would be calculating enough to resist replying to something just because their comment wouldn't get attention. After all, most people who make a comment they really believe in will sit and watch it get modded down rather than delete it. But if there does start to be a problem, it will certainly be visible.
- jhancock 18y agoIts one of the first things I thought of, after thinking "The Rich Get Richer" as I predict there will be accelerated upvoting towards those that are orange. However, as you note, I decided "ehhh" and still replied to you right here anyway ;).
- swombat 18y agoI agree. I reply to comments because I feel the overwhelming urge illustrated by http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/ , not because I think the comment will be seen or ignored. I for one think this is a good move, though the best part of the recent change is not so much the username highlighting, but the capping of negative karma at -8. Referring to the recent thread where I was being seriously downmodded, with this cap I probably wouldn't bother defending myself (and creating all that "waste of space"), because -8 or -16 is not all that much karma. Thanks!
- pbrown 18y agoCounterpoint: I read the thread to which you refer, and while I didn't agree necessarily with some of what you said, or some of what the others said, it was insightful to me to see both sides of the argument spelled out in more detail. I think this makes the comments more compelling, and helps us to get to know the other users a little better.
- jonnytran 18y agoYes, different sides of the argument is definitely what makes a thread interesting. I think downmodding comments that people disagree with needs to be discouraged. I'm guessing people have become accustomed to doing this on other sites like Reddit, but that's not what it's for here.
- GHFigs 18y agoI'm not so sure about that. The deeper the thread, the fewer participants, and the less benefit there is to the site as a whole. If karma is considered a measurement of that benefit rather than simply a score (as it should be, but on most sites that use the term is not), then it makes sense that threads with less participation would accumulate less in the way of extrinsic reward. Also, consider that people so concerned with karma that they would be dissuaded from participating in a worthwhile discussion are among the least likely to have worthwhile discussions.