3 ms·
> whilst orbits are fast satellite manoeuvres are slow, so the notice you need to avoid a conjunction is measured in hours rather than seconds I'm not arguing
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> whilst orbits are fast satellite manoeuvres are slow, so the notice you need to avoid a conjunction is measured in hours rather than seconds
I'm not arguing against collisions becoming more likely. I'm arguing aginst it becoming commonplace to the point that it becomes a commercial concern.
> satellite manoeuvres use up a finite supply of expensively-launched propellant
Nobody is plane changing out of a collision. And for the foreseeable future, in LEO, the birds are not propellant constrained. (And launch is getting cheaper.)
> you either need bigger satellites carrying more propellant or have to accept significantly higher collision risk than they currently do
We're decades away from this being a problem. That gives ample runtime to developing e.g. magnetic station-keeping (if we go reactionless) or more-efficient engines.
- defrost 10mo ago> e.g. magnetic station-keeping I've not kept up for decades now .. what's the state of solar powered magnetorquers these days? I'd quietly assumed it would be more commonplace. I dimly recall a couple of small satellites magnetically locking fifteen or so years past?
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> what's the state of solar powered magnetorquers these days? Academic. We don't currently have a pressing need for reactionless thrust in the magnetosphere. Each of semiconductors, launch vehicles and telecommunications standards are moving faster than satellites last.
- defrost 10mo agoThanks for the reply. > Each of semiconductors, launch vehicles and telecommunications standards are moving faster than satellites last. That's certainly a pragmatic cost based argument for not using them in the fast moving world of commercial magnetosphere constellations. > Academic. I feel they've moved past academic and transitioned to deployed .. at some evolution of implementation. Not commercially relevant is certainly one state of play. I guess I was more interested in the nonlinear control issue in a field of highly variable intensity.
- minetest2048 10mo agoA bit pedantic here.. I think you might be thinking about space tether propulsion. I don't know if that has been deployed yet. Magnetorquers, as in a device that uses magnets to rotate the satellite are very common in cubesats, you can buy it off the shelf
- defrost 10mo agoHmm, there's a throwback. I first encountered space tethers in 1980 reading an Introduction to Engineering text where the example was given of unrolling a flat spool of thin metal through shaping rollers to extrude a very long boom with a spring on the end to stabilise the orientation of a satellite. That was one of the first times I noodled about with the dynamics of a pendulum in a potential field. These days, of course, there's a few more tricks that can be done with a dangling lasso, including interacting with the magnetic field via a looped current. That aside, I was curious about traditional magnetorquers and their variations actively providing force in the magnetosphere. The Earths magnetic field has a lot of diurnal pulsing .. the gravitational field is lumpy but stable. There's a control challenge in getting a smooth desired response from a choppy field. Cheer's for the lookout though, it hadn't occurred to me that some would be talking about magnetic force against the field using "space tether" as the base description - my background was more about the field equations than the physical implementation. ( Magnetorquers are also used in the US Navy for twisting controls inside a fully sealed container. )
- notahacker 10mo ago> I'm not arguing against collisions becoming more likely. I'm arguing against it becoming commonplace to the point that it becomes a commercial concern. Minimising collision risk already is a commercial concern, and the number of conjunction avoidance manoeuvres SpaceX takes in order to achieve this has been growing exponentially (which presumably is a major factor driving their move of 4k satellites to a lower orbit which involves more station keeping) Obviously this gets harder when most of the satellites avoiding their orbits coming too close don't have the same owner, particularly if some of the other megaconstellations aren't even particularly cooperative (hi China!) > Nobody is plane changing out of a collision. And for the foreseeable future, in LEO, the birds are not propellant constrained. (And launch is getting cheaper.) No which is why I mentioned the fact that constellations pre-emptively plane change to avoid conjunctions. The frequency with which they have to do this scales superlinearly with the number of satellites operating in or intersecting the orbital plane. Ultimately propellant use for those manoeuvres and station keeping defines the satellite lifetime: agree it's not a huge problem when a satellite is only making small orbital changes a handful of times a year and its got a decent sized delta-v budget for station keeping and EoL deorbiting anyway, but another 70k satellites in the same plane would require quite a lot more adjustments, never mind them operating at aircraft density as proposed earlier. > We're decades away from this being a problem. That gives ample runtime to developing e.g. magnetic station-keeping (if we go reactionless) or more-efficient engines. Depends how fast the satellites get put up there (and also whether orbital megastructures become a reality, although non-trivial numbers of them actually might be decades away). There's some scope to improve propulsive efficiency (hi colleagues!), but within the power/mass constraints of a smallsat, you're not likely to see orders of magnitude more improvement in specific impulse over current gen EP, and we are forecast to need orders of magnitude more avoidance manoeuvres, which is generally going to mean more reaction mass. Sure, if we get reactionless propulsion suited for precise orbital changes in LEO then we can forget all about the tyranny of the rocket equation, but hey, if we perfect flying cars we won't have to think about the implications of congestion on the roads!