4 ms·
> how many companies could actually do this before cascading collisions starts becoming a real worry? Twenty of them at 100,000 birds each to start approaching
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> how many companies could actually do this before cascading collisions starts becoming a real worry?
Twenty of them at 100,000 birds each to start approaching the density of planes in the sky [1]. Not around an airport. In all of the sky. Oceans and all.
Practically speaking, this is not a pressing concern for our generation.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46711405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46711405
- manacit 10mo agoIt's interesting that people have a hard time visualizing this. The area in Earth's LEO is, definitionally, bigger than the Earth itself. The SEA parking garage fits 12,000 cars in it. Two of those spread over the entire planet would be an imperceptible amount of space. You could drop a pin on a map your entire life and probably never hit one.
- paulb73 10mo agoSEA parking garage? Unfamiliar with this size reference.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- mlmonkey 10mo agoHere, "SEA" = "Seattle Tacoma International Airport" in the state of Washington, USA.
- doublesocket 10mo agoThat is ... an oddly specific reference?
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- skyo 10mo agoIt's one of the largest parking garages in the world
- y1n0 10mo agoThis is fair but the cars are stationary, occupying a parking space. Satellites occupy a ring.
- Gravityloss 10mo agoSpeed matters a lot. You can fit a lot more walking people than speeding motorcycles in the same space. Satellites need to travel at 8 km/s to not fall down.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> Speed matters a lot Not really. You're correct inasmuch as it increases collision energies. But it also increases momentum, which maintains orbital integrity within predictable bounds. Nobody is maneuvering around satellites, they–and their debris–stay where the math tells them to.
- notahacker 10mo agoOrbits are predictable, but they intersect and decay [at different rates] and occasionally get perturbed by space weather. This already needs periodic conjunction avoidance manoeuvres, and whilst orbits are fast satellite manoeuvres are slow, so the notice you need to avoid a conjunction is measured in hours rather than seconds. Can't imagine a scenario in which it would be sustainable for LEO to even approach the density of commercial aviation, except perhaps for a hypothetical where a single entity actually managed all the satellites. The other underestimated dimension is that satellite manoeuvres use up a finite supply of expensively-launched propellant. That's tolerable when Starlink is doing 50k conjunction avoidance manoeuvres in six months across its constellation, but once it becomes each satellite moving at least weekly you either need bigger satellites carrying more propellant or have to accept significantly higher collision risk than they currently do.
- dylan604 10mo ago> and whilst orbits are fast satellite manoeuvres are slow This is something people unfamiliar tend to misconceive in their limited thinking on the subject. You can't just tap the breaks to slow down. Changing altitude of satellites is done by speeding up to increase altitude and slowing down to lower altitude. Once you change the velocity and reach the desired altitude, you have to then undo that acceleration to get back to orbital velocity. Fuel is required in both directions. The less fuel used the better for the maneuver. Most satellites EoL is defined by remaining maneuvering fuel vs functionality of the hardware. My first understanding of accelerating in space was from the old Asteroids game. To slow down, you had to rotate 180° and start accelerating in that direction. Others might learn it from Kerbal.