3 ms·
> same goes for the literary canon that college professors claim as a requirement for real literacy. It's all despair at the perceived loss of status in society
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> same goes for the literary canon that college professors claim as a requirement for real literacy. It's all despair at the perceived loss of status in society
Strongly disagree. I say this as someone who went to a state school and didn’t start reading literature until well after college.
The classics are classics for good reason. Even if one can’t learn to appreciate them, they’re critical for understanding entire epochs of political thought and history. It would be like trying to navigate modern retail politics while ignoring memes.
- j_bum 10mo agoWell I am pretty much you but maybe several years junior. I went to a state school, was obsessively focused only on my field of study, and scoffed at the idea of exploring anything else (save for some Jung and Nietzsche). But as I’m “aging” into the real world after grad school, I’ve similarly realized how silly it was to turn my head to literature. Curious if you’d be willing to recommend a classic, or share the genres that you’ve been enjoying.
- greenhearth 10mo agoI don't understand the "silly" part. Classic lit is amazing and also good for you. I am a late comer to it as well and I'm so glad that I have discovered it. I am finishing Ulysses now and it absolutely rocks.
- j_bum 10mo agoI realize I mistyped, I shouldn’t have said “turn my head to” I mean “ignore” but was being verbose.
- zrn900 10mo ago> The classics are classics for good reason. Yes. They reflected the culture of the ruling strata in their contemporary periods. That's why they are classics. The rest of the society (~90%) had no means to do any literature. That's why the classics were out of touch with their own times - which made Dickens such a difference by the way -, and the upper strata that was educated on them up until today are still out of touch with their own societies.
- ottah 10mo agoRegular society had oral traditions, folk tails, stories and songs.
- zrn900 10mo agoYep. Unfortunately, they werent the ones that became 'classics'. Even worse, they were hardly documented and a lot of them were lost. That's what I meant - even the elite class were into regular songs for regular fun - its 100% certain that the songs that were being played in the bars that Karl Marx and his friends went through in their famous London pub crawl, weren't playing any classical music...
- ottah 10mo agoI strongly disagree agree with the classics having any cultural relevance outside of the elite class. It entirely dismisses the bulk of all media commonly enjoyed by people in the period, which has more significance to society and its politics. Focusing on the classics filters everything through the point of view of the people in power, which is an incredibly poor way of understanding the world. Besides the classics were elite fashion. Like speaking French or fencing. They were a means to distinguish class, with hard to access knowledge and habits. It wasn't because these things were good, it was because the average person could not easily attain access to them. The great books canon was partly constructed retroactively by people with agendas about what civilization meant. A real collection of classics would have much more folk stories, common herioc figures and fantasies.