10 ms·
Megaupload Is Dead. Long Live Mega
- milliams 14y agoIt sounds like a lot of the things that SpiderOak (https://spideroak.com/ https://spideroak.com/) is doing.
- stephengillie 14y agoBoth Megaupload and The Pirate Bay have recently announced plans to use redundant datacenters in a multi-country approach to eliminate downtime. Why would a person host their entire company from one location, like AWS US-East?
- true_religion 14y agoIn order to minimize complexity in your set up maybe?
- jaggederest 14y agoAs well as to avoid paying transfer fees between regions. If you're querying a database in a different region, you're gonna have a bad time.
- DrStalker 14y agoWouldn't you have a DB set up in each location with some sort of replication? So there would be DB -> DB log shipping inter-region but everything else would be intra-region.
- jaggederest 14y agoThat can still add up a ton. I was thinking regional sharding where you might end up having records in a different region that are local to 'that region' queried by other regions.
- pyre 14y agoIt depends on your goals. As someone stated the other day in the ThePirateBay thread, their priority is mobility, rather than keeping their setup close-knit.
- JoachimSchipper 14y agoUsers are required to hand over encryption keys in several countries, including the UK. Worse, encryption keys are likely to find their way to Google ("check out this great $POPULAR_ARTIST song: www.mega.com/mykey"), so proving that Mega hosts lots of infringing content will be really easy. Finally, Mega can easily detect such files just by looking at the access patterns (10MB plus lots of hits from all over the world? Likely pirated MP3.) Of course, all of this assumes that they get the crypto right in the first place.
- learc83 14y ago>Mega can easily detect such files just by looking at the access patterns (10MB plus lots of hits from all over the world? Likely pirated MP3.) How is that pattern any different from a musician legitimately distributing an mp3?
- JoachimSchipper 14y agoMusicians legitimately distributing their songs don't get any hits. (No musician likely to generate a pirate-ish number of hits is going to use Mega to distribute the song - people who make money don't send their users to sites with completely different branding.)
- learc83 14y agoYou can say that, but there's no way to prove it short of commissioning a study. I don't think the DMCA requires you to hire statisticians to investigate the usage patterns of your site. And what if someone uploads a wikileaks like pdf that gets downloaded by thousands of people? Is that going to get automatically shut off.
- goatforce5 14y agoPlenty of musicians post the official copies of their music videos on YouTube (and don't always embed the videos directly on their own site).
- makomk 14y ago
- batgaijin 14y agoSo would this be AES written in JS, or an extension?
- robin_reala 14y agoAES JS libraries do exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AES_implementations#Javascript https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AES_implementations#Javascript
- ars 14y agoBut there is no way to use that to download a file. Javascript has no way to output data that is then saved to disk. It will have to be a browser extension or an offline tool (download the encrypted file, decrypt it once you are done). However I shudder to think about how much malware people are going to get from sites purporting to make "special megaupload decryption tools".
- kanzure 14y ago> Javascript has no way to output data that is then saved to disk. First, there's HTML5 window.saveAs which apparently nobody has implemented. Second, you can always fall back to some swf. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2897619/using-html5-javascript-to-generate-and-save-a-file http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2897619/using-html5-javas...
- ars 14y agoPeople routinely download GB+ messages - neither of those options are practical for files of that size.
- robin_reala 14y agohttps://github.com/eligrey/FileSaver.js https://github.com/eligrey/FileSaver.js FileSaver.js implements the W3C saveAs() FileSaver interface in browsers that do not natively support it. No IE support, but what’s the intersection of Mega users and IE users?
- arscan 14y ago>Mega will also grant direct access to their servers for entities such as film studios, allowing them to remove copyright-infringing material themselves. How? Is this if the person that uploaded the file is openly distributing the key?
- TeMPOraL 14y agoI guess this was a joke. They can look through the data stored on the servers for as long as they want; they won't find anything because they don't have the keys.
- pyre 14y agoBut they will have the keys if something is being widely distributed.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoSo they can pop in and remove it, just to have it reappear ten times. It will be completely futile waste of time, unless Mega lets them automate this process somehow.
- pyre 14y agoChances are that the most widely distributed things will be on centralized sites (e.g. ThePirateBay). The RIAA/MPAA could probably easily write a bot to scrape these sites for access information and then go into MegaEncryptedUpload and remove the files.
- davidp 14y agoYes. Basically it's giving 3rd parties (content owners) a self-service account in Mega's admin tools so that they can take down items without involving Mega, and in this case to verify that the content is infringing they'd have to have the keys somehow. It's fairly routine for large media sites to supply this access, since it's more about administrative efficiency for the hosting site than anything else.
- leeoniya 14y agothat's all good and well, except for it to resemble the previous model, there would need to be a mechanism for key exchange and search by title => key, which would need to move underground. without a search facility it loses most of its piracy value.
- stephengillie 14y agoIf Mega doesn't do that, another group will. Then that group will be partially liable too. Part of the point of this is to make the problem too big to raid, too many people to litigate.
- davidp 14y agoMy inner civil libertarian cheers at this, although one wonders how useful a public storage locker is without any associated content discovery tools. But my inner policeman hesitates. If actual bad guys (organized crime, drug cartels, spies, terrorists, governments, script kiddies, or anyone else working outside the law) can communicate and operate with impunity, the technology is not an unequivocally good thing. The broadly accepted way we deal with this is to have warrant-based interception and eavesdropping; it's hard to argue that our law enforcement services would best operate without any tools other than direct physical surveillance. So presumably even Mega would need to comply with legal wiretapping requests. Happily for Mega, and unhappily for law enforcement, doing it at the server doesn't get them anything with this scheme. But that simply compels law enforcement to get much more invasive, in a way that's hard for citizens to monitor: Find a way to install eavesdropping tools on the suspect's machine so access is gained before encryption. I'm not sure where all this is headed; it's a brave new world. (Heading off potential replies about the growing use of warrantless wiretaps -- of course those are unacceptable. But wiretapping with a warrant is a vital, crucial tool, and that's all I'm discussing here.)
- spindritf 14y ago> But my inner policeman hesitates. If actual bad guys (organized crime, drug cartels, spies, terrorists, governments, script kiddies, or anyone else working outside the law) can communicate and operate with impunity This tool is still just a cyber-locker, it doesn't allow you to launch a ddos attack, or run scripts, or even communicate, you need a channel of communication established elsewhere to pass the keys. It's just an easier way to share files with people you're already communicating with in some manner.
- blntechie 14y agoEven today, nothing stops bad guys from encrypting using available tools in their PC and upload to a public file sharing service. Only thing the proposed Mega service is doing is making the process simpler. Believe this is going to be the future unless governments ban encryption all together which might not picture them in a better light amongst all of us.
- res0nat0r 14y agoThis will probably go the way of Aimster. IE: You can't play dumb to shield yourself while knowingly assisting copyright infringement. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Aimster_Copyright_Litigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Aimster_Copyright_Litigat... The court held that in this case the users of the systems were the direct infringers, these who are ignorant or more commonly disdainful of copyright and in any event discount the likelihood of being sued or prosecuted for copyright infringement, however companies such as Aimster that facilitate their infringement, even if they are not themselves direct infringers can be liable for copyright violations as contributory infringers.
- btown 14y ago(IANAL) The key question is whether Mega is practicing "Willful Blindness" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willful_blindness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willful_blindness) by providing this service. The players involved, especially Dotcom, seem to have already "tainted" themselves as being _knowledgeable_ of infringement through their involvement in MegaUpload. So in what way is their "design" of a client-side encrypted system different from "designing" a drug trafficking briefcase so that the courier doesn't have a key? If the courier/service has reason to believe that the service is being used for copyright infringement, it could be argued that they are being criminally negligent by offering such a service.
- msg 14y agoIf the postal service invented physical systems that didn't allow mail to be opened in transit, would you accuse the postmaster general of facilitating criminal conspiracies? All they are doing is keeping private communication really private. What is the difference between this and encrypted email? Hint, you can break a large file into many chunks of email too.
- lucian1900 14y ago"the so-called Advanced Encryption Standard algorithm" What?
- stewartbutler 14y agoAES?
- lucian1900 14y agoI found the "so-called" bit weird.
- wmf 14y agoNow that's what I call balanced journalism.
- freehunter 14y agoI think they were using so called in the traditional sense rather than the colloquial sense. Rather than being sarcastic like is common with that phrase, they meant "using what is known as the Advanced Encryption Standard".
- lazugod 14y agoIt's a rather bland and encompassing name (are other encryption standards not advanced?), so saying "so-called" points out that it's a name and not a description.
- bpatrianakos 14y agoWow. Its just so incredibly obvious that this is just MegaUpload in a new form and that the entire point is to allow sharing of copyrighted data. Kim is hanging this whole thing on plausible deniability but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what's really going on. This infuriates me. Sharing copyrighted files isn't what pisses me off. What does is the arrogance of Dotcom to try to pass this thing off like its for legit sharing of files. We have Google Drive, Dropbox, Box.net, Amazon's thing, iCloud and a billion others and no one really messes with them. There's no doubt in my mind that those services are storing some copyrighted data but they don't get messed with because they're truly legit. The feds didn't go after MegaUpload because it allowed people to share files that may or may not be copyrighted. It did so because the worst kept secret on the web was that if you want to download the new Lady Gaga single you could probably find it pretty easily on MegaUpload because that's basically what everyone was using it for. I honestly have no qualms about not backing up my claims with specific examples and evidence in this case because everyone here knows what was going on at MegaUpload and anyone trying to deny is either twisting their minds into a preztel with the mental gymnastics they'd have to do to convince them otherwise or they're just outright lying. I said it. So now that they have this new approach I doubt they'll be successful. Because of the way the new Mega is set up you can't search for content. Allowing the ability to search for content would necessitate getting rid of their whole privacy scheme. I predict that the new Mega could still be used to share copyrighted files but the onus will be on third parties to keep track of such files in a database or something in order to provide links to people searching or it can just become a safe place to store your copyrighted files and share them on a case by case basis (through email, links on forums, or wherever). But if this really is supposed to be a legit service, which it isn't (come on, you know it), then I don't see how it can gain market share or mind share given the alternatives we already have had for a while now.
- mahyarm 14y agoBox.net, Amazon, iCloud and other 'cloud drive' style sharing services can actually be quite a large pain to share large amount of files with random people, even when your paying. For example, I ran into this pain trying to share 4GB of photos I took, mediafire split archives ended up being the least painless way to go about it. These digital locker services tend to be the cheapest way to host/share large amounts of files too when your paying as a normal person.
- jijji 14y agohow are they going to implement the browser based AES on files before/while they are uploaded?
- nnq 14y agoI think it's a conspiracy directed by an occult media producer's conclave to destroy the public image of file-sharing in general using this guy's butt-ugly face... (No really, I'd rather hear more about what happened to the poor Demonoid guys than see his face taking up more media space - it's obvious that he likes publicity even more than money so even the FBI just gave him what he wanted!)
- DrStalker 14y agoAs someone who never used Megaupload how did it differ from Dropbox/google drive/etc in terms of being good for piracy?
- E14n 14y agoAnything that allows the free flow of information is good for copyright infringement, but when you are contorting Laws in absurd perverse ways its better to have a fat ugly obnoxious guy on the receiving end.