5 ms·
I think we're approaching some form of angry agreement here. To give you background, I have in the past year found myself arguing with "ketards" who have come
by jacques_chester 14y ago
I think we're approaching some form of angry agreement here.
To give you background, I have in the past year found myself arguing with "ketards" who have come up with some hilariously impossible theories. Such as: eat 8,000 calories a day; so long as you are in ketosis, you will lose weight.
Or: the human body is complex, so applying the law of conservation of matter and energy is erroneous.
Keto absolutely works for lots of folks. Protein is filling and delicious. But as a personal pet peeve, pinning everything on carbs/insulin when a) protein causes insulin spikes to, b) net calorie balance is still the bottom line and c) there are more hormones involved in appetite and satiety than just insulin gets up my nostrils a little bit.
And that's what I was referring to in terms of over-simplifications of a complex science via pop science books.
- koningrobot 14y agoKeto absolutely works for lots of folks. Protein is filling and delicious. I've spent some time among "ketards" and they ate much more fat than they did protein. I think the recommended ratio was around 80% fat vs 20% protein.
- beagle3 14y ago> To give you background, I have in the past year found myself arguing with "ketards" who have come up with some hilariously impossible theories. Such as: eat 8,000 calories a day; so long as you are in ketosis, you will lose weight. Why do you think it is impossible? I failed to lose weight on a ~1200 kcal/day diet for several years of relatively active lifestyle. Does that seem impossible to you as well? And then I kept more or less the same kcal intake (from the labels, which I don't find trustworthy, but I don't have any other source), but I dropped anything grainy (corn, wheat, rice), and lost 30 pounds within one month. Does that sound impossible to you? After those 30 pounds, my weight stabilized, and started rising again very slowly (2 pounds over a few months) And then following some parts of the "The Bulletproof Diet", I went to ~2500 kcal/day, (about twice what I had before, mostly fat), and started losing weight again, at about 1 pound/week. Does that seem impossible to you? When I called out the wrongness of "caloric balance" in another thread, you said "well, that's true but it doesn't matter, you should observe inputs vs. outputs". Which is true, and is correlated, but very far from being inferable from the caloric balance.
- Pzychotix 14y ago>I failed to lose weight on a ~1200 kcal/day diet for several years of relatively active lifestyle. Does that seem impossible to you as well? Yeah, I would think that's impossible. I'm going to just state user error as the leading cause here for your inability to lose weight. Unless you're completely unique in some shape or form such that reducing your caloric intake also reduced your BMR down to basically 0 (i.e. dead), I'm going to have to call bullshit.
- beagle3 14y agoI'm unique by virtue of exhibiting extremely improbable input/output relation, but I don't think my biology is unique - I've probably just gotten it stuck into an uncommon state. My ex was an MD. At some point she told me "well, I'm going to eat what you eat for a few weeks to show you that you must be eating more than you think" (She was studying for exams, and we actually ate almost every meal together for a few months). She started having blackouts after a few days, continuously feeling starved, and stopped the experiment after less than two weeks. What did she do afterwards? put a big SEP field over the experiment (and my food input). What did other nutritionists and doctors I consulted say? One called me a lier (about a few things; all of which -- except my food intake -- I was able to prove him wrong). Another said I should start eating meat (I'm vegetarian) - not because I'm missing anything, but because he couldn't find enough relevant statistics to compare me to. My BMR _was_ reduced, but I didn't have enough money at the time to spend on getting it tested. But my body temperature in those years was ranging between 35.2 and 36.2 celsius (normal is 36.7) -- obviously I generated much less heat. Just about _everything_ you know about medicine and nutrition is statistics that works for 90% of the population 99% of the time. I'm (un?)lucky to be stuck in the 1% of the time and 10% of the population in many respects. I'm not sure if I should be annoyed or amused of how religiously people tend to assume nutrition and medicine are hard sciences like math and physics. (See my long reply to jacques_chester above for deconstructing his popular argument)
- jacques_chester 14y agoI am always presented with anecdote of this format. "I used to eat <X>, now I eat <Y> and <delta Z>. Where is your precious net calories now!" Well this leaves us with two alternatives: 1. Something in biological systems is capable of defying the conservation of matter and energy. Somewhere in the spaghetti bowl, matter or energy are being wicked away or added in a fashion so subtle that it has never, ever been observed. 2. You measured incorrectly. Nothing personal, but I know which hypothesis I will back. (Also note the careful use of the qualifying phrase long term average weight to account for the general noisiness of weight).