3 ms·
It's the same kind of schizm that has lead to a lot of hate and mass murder over the last century or so: Abstraction/dimensionality reduction vs. concrete logic
by accidentallfact 9mo ago
It's the same kind of schizm that has lead to a lot of hate and mass murder over the last century or so:
Abstraction/dimensionality reduction vs. concrete logic and statistics
Concrete statistician: I can learn the problem in its full complexity, unlike the dumdum below me.
Abstract thinker: I understand it, because I can reduce its dimensity to a small number of parameters.
CS: I can predict this because I have statistics about its past behavior.
AT: I told you so.
CS: You couldn't possibly know this, because it has never happened before. You suffer from the hindsight bias.
AT: But I told you.
CS: It has never happened, you couldn't possibly have statistics of when such things occur. You were just lucky.
CS: I'm smart, I can be taught anything
AT: You are stupid because you need to be taught everything.
War (or another sort of mass death or other kind of suffering) emerges.
- iammjm 9mo agoWhat are some concrete examples of wars that you believe emerged due to this schism?
- accidentallfact 9mo agoIt seems that a large majority of conflicts did: The revolutionary war: CS America vs AT british empire. The french revolution: CS revolutionaries vs AT aristocracy. American Civil war: CS North, vs AT South WWII: AT Nazis, vs CS jews. Probably many more.
- dcre 9mo agoIncredibly ironic to make this argument using such an abstract and low-dimensional framework.