4 ms·
> It's funny how you argue against simplifications, but this one of the biggest made in any dietary context. I was wondering when someone would point this out.
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> It's funny how you argue against simplifications, but this one of the biggest made in any dietary context.
I was wondering when someone would point this out.
Oh wait, I already did that: " I’m about to do what every smart person likes to do: drastically simplify a complex phenomenon."
and
"Well, if it please the court: I’m guilty of this too. I’ve simplified enormously."
The point of that particular song and dance was that the ultimate cause of long term weight is net caloric balance. That's the one, simple, verifiable truth about nutrition that everybody agrees on. Everything else is a bunfight.
Any hypothesis which sincerely proposes that net caloric balance does not necessarily determine long term average weight must explain by what biological mechanism the conservation of matter and energy is being violated.
> Go with what works, and for most people, losing weight on a low-carb diet will be a helluva lot easier than on a low calorie, high-carb diet, your personal experience notwithstanding.
You have no idea what my macros are, you're just assuming. For me protein is the number one priority and I let the rest of the chips fall where they may.
Lots of people swear by keto. Swing past /r/keto and you'll find a success story every day. You can also swing past /r/paleo, /r/loseit and so on and so forth.
I don't really care about how the caloric deficit is imposed. In my case it was through intermittent fasting. What matters is that it was imposed.
Funnily enough, I thought of that point too:
"The key to weight control is finding the dietary template that you can stick to for the rest of your life. That will be different for different people. Some folks are happy with calorie counting a la John Walker. Some people are happy with paleo, primal or ketogenic diets. Others swear by zones or low fat and so on."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JohnsonB 14y ago>The point of that particular song and dance was that the ultimate cause of long term weight is net caloric balance. That's the one, simple, verifiable truth about nutrition that everybody agrees on. Everything else is a bunfight. Any hypothesis which sincerely proposes that net caloric balance does not necessarily determine long term average weight must explain by what biological mechanism the conservation of matter and energy is being violated. Consider this complete hypothetical, just to prove a point. Suppose that one individual's body functioned like this, due to a bizarre genetic mutation: Any excess calories this person ate under a high-carb diet would be turned into fat. Any excess calories eaten in a zero-carb diet would be turned into pure muscle mass, burned off in a raised metabolism, or are simply excreted. Simply put, this shows that calories in/out can remain true, but only a fraction of what you need to consider to keep your weight under control, and this is essentially the assertion by Taubes et al., backed up by significant empirical evidence that these diets actually work, even if you disagree with the biochemistry of his arguments. In addition, there are issues like how hungry you feel (more likely to consume excess calories) under each diet, even after consuming enough calories to maintain a healthy body weight, and therefore how sustainable each diet is. What you should care about when trying to lose weight is how fat you get under a certain diet, period. Not calories in/out, just everything. So while you can say that "in the end calories in/out is the ultimate rule that determines weight gain, everything else is an inaccurate generalization," you're missing everything else that could potentially interfere with your control of calories in/out. It's like saying "The only thing that determines whether I can drive to my destination in my car or not is if I have enough fuel for the journey, so I don't need to concentrate on things like remembering to inflate the tires or inserting the keys into the ignition." Excuse the left-field analogy, but I hope you see what I'm getting at. The truth is that Taubes et al. never disagreed with and add enormousness value to the line "Calories in/out" by saying "Yes but low carbs and eat a lot of fats!". Again, as a rule for most people, or a helpful generalization. >You have no idea what my macros are, you're just assuming. For me protein is the number one priority and I let the rest of the chips fall where they may. Well I stated it as a contradiction just to hedge that your diet wasn't similar or overlapping with ketosis diets. If it is, one could argue the point that a lot of the success people have with non-keto diets is at least partially because they actually are following a ketosis diet, albeit inadvertently. >Lots of people swear by keto. Swing past /r/keto and you'll find a success story every day. You can also swing past /r/paleo, /r/loseit and so on and so forth. I agree that different individuals can have success under a variety of diets. My argument is that the default diet advice should be low carb, high fat, etc., rather than just low calorie. Although I would say most paleo diets are actually a very strict keto diets themselves, and almost all are low-carb anyway.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI think we're approaching some form of angry agreement here. To give you background, I have in the past year found myself arguing with "ketards" who have come up with some hilariously impossible theories. Such as: eat 8,000 calories a day; so long as you are in ketosis, you will lose weight. Or: the human body is complex, so applying the law of conservation of matter and energy is erroneous. Keto absolutely works for lots of folks. Protein is filling and delicious. But as a personal pet peeve, pinning everything on carbs/insulin when a) protein causes insulin spikes to, b) net calorie balance is still the bottom line and c) there are more hormones involved in appetite and satiety than just insulin gets up my nostrils a little bit. And that's what I was referring to in terms of over-simplifications of a complex science via pop science books.
- koningrobot 14y agoKeto absolutely works for lots of folks. Protein is filling and delicious. I've spent some time among "ketards" and they ate much more fat than they did protein. I think the recommended ratio was around 80% fat vs 20% protein.
- beagle3 14y ago> To give you background, I have in the past year found myself arguing with "ketards" who have come up with some hilariously impossible theories. Such as: eat 8,000 calories a day; so long as you are in ketosis, you will lose weight. Why do you think it is impossible? I failed to lose weight on a ~1200 kcal/day diet for several years of relatively active lifestyle. Does that seem impossible to you as well? And then I kept more or less the same kcal intake (from the labels, which I don't find trustworthy, but I don't have any other source), but I dropped anything grainy (corn, wheat, rice), and lost 30 pounds within one month. Does that sound impossible to you? After those 30 pounds, my weight stabilized, and started rising again very slowly (2 pounds over a few months) And then following some parts of the "The Bulletproof Diet", I went to ~2500 kcal/day, (about twice what I had before, mostly fat), and started losing weight again, at about 1 pound/week. Does that seem impossible to you? When I called out the wrongness of "caloric balance" in another thread, you said "well, that's true but it doesn't matter, you should observe inputs vs. outputs". Which is true, and is correlated, but very far from being inferable from the caloric balance.
- beagle3 14y ago> The point of that particular song and dance was that the ultimate cause of long term weight is net caloric balance. That's the one, simple, verifiable truth about nutrition that everybody agrees on. Everything else is a bunfight. Only in the tautologically meaningless sense, in which you define "calories in" by "what the body laters takes out at some point". Everyone agrees carbohydrates provide 4kcal per gram, right? Well, cellulose (e.g. paper) is a carbohydrate as well. But eating it does not provide you with energy. Xylitol is a sugar alcohol, which, when first introduced to a diet, makes zero (0) kcal per gram available to the body, but apparently settles at 2.7 kcal after a couple of weeks of consumption, in which the body ramps up the enzymes that can actually digest it. Furthermore, the amount of fat your body uses for e.g. skin lubrication, can vary by a few hundreds of percents (depending on factors not perfectly understood, as far as I can tell), so the "energy out" balance also includes "energy in the form of fat used for mechanical purposes". The "calories in - calories out" balance is a very crude approximation, that works for most of the people most of the time - but there's a very significant chunk of the population (under their present living conditions) for which it is completely useless.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> The "calories in - calories out" balance is a very crude approximation Yes. Yes absolutely! And a centrifugal governor in no way resembles the internal state of a steam engine. And it doesn't matter. Observing inputs and outputs is enough to control weight.
- beagle3 14y agoIndeed, but in ways much different from what is usually discussed, and from what you (I believe) implicitly imply. e.g., I've recently discovered that my unexplained weight gain (which over the last year looked like 4-5 step functions, rather than anything continuous) is a result of Niacin (Vitamin B3) deficiency. That's something I discovered (accidentally) by observing inputs and outputs, the input being B3 supplementation (taken for a completely different matter), which quickly undid all the weight gain (and a lot of other symptoms). 10 or so Doctors (specialists and generalists) and nutritionists have seen me over the last 15 years for my weird weight. Not one ever suggested B3 might be the problem, or ever had a test that would indicate I'm B3 deficient -- although, I have reason to believe I've been deficient for at least 20, and possibly 30 years. So, yes - observing input and output is definitely enough to control weight. But as this anecdote shows, it's not necessarily the caloric balance, which is what you stated in the first place.