3 ms·
Isn’t this (part of) the point of MCP.
by paulddraper 9mo ago
Isn’t this (part of) the point of MCP.
- eddythompson80 9mo agoPossibly, but the point is that MCP is a DOA idea. An agent, like Claude code or opencode, don’t need an MCP. it’s nonsensical to expect or need an MCP before someone can call you. There is no `git` MCP either . Opencode is fully capable of running `git add .` or `aws ec2 terminate-instance …` or `curl -XPOST https://…` Why do we need the MCP? The problem now is that someone can do a prompt injection to tell it to send all your ~/.was/credentials to a random endpoint. So let’s just have a dummy value there, and inject the actual value in a transparent outbound proxy that the agent doesn’t have access to.
- paulddraper 9mo ago> Opencode is fully capable of running > Why do we need the MCP? > The problem now And there it is. I understand that this is an alternative solution, and appreciate it.