5 ms·
This thread is going to be hilarious. There's nothing quite so beautiful as people who read the same half dozen pop science books arguing about nutrition, a stu
by jacques_chester 14y ago
This thread is going to be hilarious. There's nothing quite so beautiful as people who read the same half dozen pop science books arguing about nutrition, a stupidly complex science about which almost no universal statements can be made (with one and only one exception[2]).
For example: I am an intermittent faster[1]. I don't have breakfast, have a modest lunch and a large dinner (heavy or light on carbs, depending on my training). I lift weights 5 or 6 evenings a week.
I am as productive as hell in the mornings.
The reason I eat this way is because I suck at portion control. 3 small meals, fiddling with plates or not, is torture. Whereas I am perfectly capable of not eating in the first place.
[1] http://chester.id.au/2012/04/17/my-diet/ http://chester.id.au/2012/04/17/my-diet/
[2] That net calorie balance is the determinant of long term average bodyweight. Lots of people are annoyed by that: http://chester.id.au/2012/05/26/fat-and-simple/ http://chester.id.au/2012/05/26/fat-and-simple/
[3] Yes, I know I'm spamming links to my own blog. It's just easier than typing out the same stuff all over again.
- graeme 14y agoI eat that way too. You (well, I) simply don't get hungry until you eat, once you adapt. Adaptation only takes 2-3 days. Now I feel high energy all morning.
- jinfiesto 14y agoI also eat this way. I feel great all day. Especially during the fast. It's much better than grazing, in my experience, which usually just leads to me being hungry all the time.
- fingerprinter 14y agoMan, huge +1 that you reference Cheat Mode. If you are actually doing that, you are well on your way to a healthy lifestyle. I've been advocating some form of carb-cycling diet for years (Cheat Mode, Carb Back-Loading and Lean Gains are all styles of carb-cycling). It. Is. Awesome. And the science backs it up too. In all my fitness books I advise this style of eating as well. Huge success with it for both me and the readers. One note: I don't know how quickly you want to lose weight, but it notes in your blog that you were at 133kg. If you want to accelerate that and save your muscle (muscle sparring) at the same time, I suggest you change up the carb-cycling like this: 6.5 days of VLC (very low carbs, less than 30grams) and then have a very big carb night. This is essentially Keto with carb refeeds and it is great for shedding fat. Accelerate it further by doing some steady state cardio (walking on a treadmill) for 30 minutes 3-5 days a week. Don't do HIIT training EXCEPT the day after your carb refeed. HIIT will help you clear the glucose from your system on that day, but on any other day it will start to eat your muscle. Now, however, if you are comfortable at that weight and want to do a more steady recomposition, you are doing the right thing. I just suggested the above if you wanted to lose fat faster.
- radicalbyte 14y agoInteresting, I had lots of success with the Body4Life plan. That combines weight training, HIIT and the 6/1 split of protein/carb-overload. It works really well for fast weight loss: in 12 weeks, 22kg fat burnt and 7kg raw muscle mass added (if the measurement is to be believed). Sure, I've gained 15kg fat back since I stopped, but that's the Achilles heel of all diets..
- karolist 14y agoNo, you most certainly did not grow 7kg of raw muscle in 12 weeks. What method to measure body fat did you use?
- radicalbyte 14y agoThere's a reason that I qualified the statement. They used a factory-calibrated scales, which uses impedance to measure your body fat percentage. I don't trust the measurements: if you're using impedance to measure it then hydration and the salt balance in your body will dominate any small scale changes in body mass (7kg is < 9% of my body mass). The initial measurements look anomalous, the muscle % and fat % were well out of bounds with my girth/height when compared to the US military-sourced base lines.
- fingerprinter 14y agoI don't look at them as 'diets' per se. I think of them as lifestyles that fit my current goals. So, for instance, when I want to maintain weight, I eat moderate carbs after I workout. If I want to gain weight, I'll eat more carbs, and higher GI carbs, after I workout. If I want to lose fat, I'll do the 6.5 day refeed approach (this was nutshelling in its heaviest form....there are many nuances, but you should get the idea). You don't have to gain the weight back. Just realize what made you successful and start adapting that to how you live after you hit your goal, whatever that is.
- jacques_chester 14y agoLike I say in my blog post: we are are our own controller. Observe inputs and results. These days I have lost enough fat that I can, by eyeballing, see what I had for dinner the night before. Lots of carbs --> retain water --> some veins disappear. Few carbs --> less water retained --> veins more visible. At the moment I try to schedule particularly carby dinners for hypertrophy days, on the theory that this will work better for sarcoplasmic hypertrophy purposes. But at this point in the discussion I am well and truly majoring in the minors. The headline is still that I am losing fat through caloric deficit and that for me, the easiest way to do so is intermittent fasting.
- JohnsonB 14y ago>This thread is going to be hilarious. There's nothing quite so beautiful as people who read the same half dozen pop science books arguing about nutrition, a stupidly complex science about which almost no universal statements can be made (with one and only one exception[2]). I'm confused, you argue that nutrition is a "stupidly complex science" and as far as I can tell, are insinuating that most of these people who read "pop science books" on nutrition will be overconfident in their knowledge/understanding on the issue. But in your second reference to your blog you argue on one side of the issue, specifically taking the side against popular authors like Taubes. If the science is so utterly complex, why do you simply take the side arguing against ketosis diets (in that they are not superior to simply following calories in, calories out logic?) Are you more informed because you read blogs like Guyenet's instead of books by Taubes? From a blind perspective, I wouldn't say that Guyenet is strikingly more scientific than Taubes. I'm not sure what the line about Guyenet being a "sciency scientist", but supposedly Taubes not, is about. On the one hand you argue against casual confidence in nutritional science based on popular science writings, and on the other you take a high level of confidence yourself in certain theories...based on popular science writings. hmmm. From your blog: >Net calories is, therefore, a forcing element in this system. It's funny how you argue against simplifications, but this one of the biggest made in any dietary context. Calories in, calories out, is only relevant to the weight loss issue in one direction. You can't burn more energy than you take in, but you do not necessarily store in fat energy that you take in but don't specifically burn out. So the argument is that with a ketosis diet, you can intake extra calories and not get heavier, so long as they are protein/fat calories. This is backed up by fairly strong empirical evidence, which as your blog suggests, is more important than knowing the dangerous and deceptive complexities of the exact chemistry of the human body. Go with what works, and for most people, losing weight on a low-carb diet will be a helluva lot easier than on a low calorie, high-carb diet, your personal experience notwithstanding. And: >"Calories in minus calories out, ultimately, settles the body weight balance." In that this is not unreasonably universal advice, but that it should just be the default diet advice instead of "low calories" for weight loss, that statement is incorrect. It is ridiculously easier to lose weight on a low-carb diet and sustain it than on a simply low calorie diet. For most people. If you enjoy persistent food cravings and low energy levels, and potentially deleterious effects on your long term health (from low fat diets.), then sure, eat a high-carb diet.
- vidarh 14y ago> I don't have breakfast, have a modest lunch and a large dinner If you're anything like me, this doesn't necessarily contradict his claim that productivity is likely to drop if you go hungry: After a couple of weeks, I adjusted to the pattern and stopped getting hungry in the morning.