3 ms·
Alex, based on your kind reply to DanBC, you are tired of people calling you out for relying on Google University for your knowledge on controversial subjects.
by tokenadult 14y ago
Alex, based on your kind reply to DanBC, you are tired of people calling you out for relying on Google University for your knowledge on controversial subjects. That may be tiresome, but it may also be good for the overall level of factual discussion here.
My general observation of what excites people on Hacker News is that negative metathreads get more upvotes, by two orders of magnitude, than positive metathreads. I would love to see more replies to the old thread "Ask HN: What do you like about the Hacker News community?"
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4399678 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4399678
from 60 days ago, if people are so inclined. I posted that soon after a metathread that complained about comments that were insufficiently kind and affirming, from someone who has asked advice about external website designs in days past. I figure if I ask for advice about a website, people are very well going to give me advice, and I might as well man up and take the advice. But, yeah, one thing I like about HN is that people look things up in good-quality offline sources in many instances, and ask other participants here to check their facts. And there are other good features of the community here that help me learn and develop in my work, in my community citizenship, and in my family life.
- Alex3917 14y ago"you are tired of people calling you out for relying on Google University for your knowledge on controversial subjects" I think it's funny how the more books I read, the more 'controversial' my knowledge becomes. I realize this is about as self-serving an argument as possible, but honestly I don't think I'm inherently interested in controversial topics, I think it's just that the more you know about something, the more wrong you're going to sound to the average person. To give an example that most people on HN will agree with, why do you think the general public thinks eVoting is completely secure, while CS folks are generally horrified by the products that are actually used in elections? The same phenomenon applies to virtually every other area of life. Doesn't matter whether you're talking about medicine, agriculture, religion, climate change, education, etc. The more you know, the more wrong you're going to sound. (C.f. the presidential debates.) Also, I'm usually fairly anti-Wikipedia these days. That's why I generally avoid linking there in the first place, though also to encourage people to actually read quality books or academic research. Wikipedia is often useful for finding primary sources, but A) it's rarely comprehensive. Usually they just link to one or two primary sources at random, rather than the best ones or all of them. B) it generally does a poor job at properly characterizing the arguments for or against something. Usually you just get 'some people believe this, other people believe that' without any indication that the case for one side might be much stronger than the case for another side. C) It also tends to be out of date at any given time. Often not seriously so, but if you look up any of the statistics that the CDC or BLS publish on an annual basis then more often than not you're getting last year's data. D) I agree with Jaron Lanier's point of view in his Digital Maoism essay. Specifically I think knowledge is inherently tied together with authorship, and that an article of 'facts' without a voice is just a "faux-authoritative, anti-contextual brew." Granted Wikipedia has a lot of advantages, but I think it's a poor substitute for reading actual books. And I especially think that it's generally a dick move to pretend that you're an expert on something after having only read the Wikipedia article, except for in certain niche areas where there is no authoritative source. And again, I'm not trying to claim that I know everything by any stretch of the imagination, just trying to explain why some of my comments may seem 'controversial'.