3 ms·
There are two types of people who use "big words": Those who are trying to sound smarter than they are, and those who are so intimately familiar with the Englis
by jerf 14y ago
There are two types of people who use "big words": Those who are trying to sound smarter than they are, and those who are so intimately familiar with the English language that they understand the subtle shadings of each word and can't help but use them fluently.
English is often cited as an unusual language for the word count it has. What English has done is load a lot of connotations that in other languages might show in phrases or idioms into the words themselves. In the thesaurus, "conflagration" and "fire" are synonyms, but in fact they don't mean quite the same thing. One is a thing you might cook marshmallows over and the other certainly is not.
Those in the second category can identify those in the first with a glance. Sometimes you can even see them flinch if you're looking at them at the right time, when someone claims to have roasted their marshmallows over a conflagration.
The author is a professional writer and a professor, presumably of English or Writing. She comes by it honestly. If any of the vocabulary in that piece struck me on first reading (before I read your comment), I actually thought she was talking down to her students when she told the story about Mary.
(I am sure Muphry's Law is in full effect for this post.)
- adam-a 14y agoThere are also two types of writing. Writing to convey a point and writing poetically. This is supposed to be advice so it would suit it more to be understandable rather than beautiful. Having said that I assumed she was making a joke in the first paragraph, she seems to calm down a lot after that. Surely the irony of > I’ve seen young writers contort their prose into incomprehensibly pretentious muddles, all in a disastrous bid to sound more erudite than they are. is apparent to the author.
- kscaldef 14y agoI'm not sure why it should be, as there's no irony to be found. That sentence is neither contorted nor incomprehensible nor a muddle nor a disaster. One might argue on the issue of whether it's pretentious, but given the target audience of other academics I would lean towards saying it's not.
- vacri 14y agoThe sentence is contorted. It's correct, but that doesn't mean it's not contorted - it scans poorly and is not particularly readable.
- scott_s 14y agoThe game reviews over at gametrailers.com suffer from this. I cringe every time they use a vocab-word in place of its pedestrian synonym. While it's a synonym, it's not quite what the word implies.
- biscarch 14y agoThank you for this comment. I started talking like that when I was younger as, I believe, a direct result of reading 6-7 books a week. The language would just surface as I was in the middle of a sentence. That language was quickly derided by my peers and those "above" me. I found that conversing in a more general manner ("fire" vs "conflagration") is conducive to moving conversations forward, even if it results in a muddled understanding. I now make efforts to speak in a less exact fashion in most circumstances and I've lost a good bit of my vocabulary as a result. On occasion I write (privately) in such language so that I retain the ability to speak in a more exacting fashion, but it's rare these days and I often feel like I'm not presenting my arguments as well as I could be.
- blaines 14y agoDon't repress yourself.
- chris_wot 14y agoIn other words, repress repression.
- vacri 14y agoBetter still, speak to your audience's level. Set a high bar by default, but don't maintain it to the detriment of communication.
- biscarch 14y agoI agree with this, and believe it has implications for being able to communicate well and give greater precedence to the ideas one is presenting. ie: being able to grok someone else's though process to the level of allowing them to reach your conclusion on their own.
- precisioncoder 14y agoI had the same problem, especially because I loved learning words, I managed to satisfy my hunger for words by practicing different dialects in the area and working them in and out of my speech which was a lot of fun and people didn't notice/mind. Later I learned a second language which was a great outlet for that hunger.