5 ms·
Well and good, but she might have written it with fewer $5 words. (Pardon me, "formulated it with a less sesquipedilian vocabulary.") "it fancifies a simple id
by cafard 14y ago
Well and good, but she might have written it with fewer $5 words. (Pardon me, "formulated it with a less sesquipedilian vocabulary.")
"it fancifies a simple ideal (be honest), but because in so doing, it’s emblematic of the very culture that fosters fraudulence in the first place: the too-often obfuscating, gate-keeping, stratifying milieu of higher education."
"I’ve seen young writers contort their prose into incomprehensibly pretentious muddles, all in a disastrous bid to sound more erudite than they are."
I bet she has. I hope she put her advice to them more plainly.
- thecosas 14y agoYou just used my favorite word (sesquipedalian) haha That said, it sounds like she struggles with it too (and clearly did with the article): “The first time I ever witnessed Mary do that,” I continue, “I swore to myself I’d follow her example, I’d be that brave. Guess how I’ve done?” They raise their eyebrows, half-hopeful, half-leery. “Not that great,” I confess. “It’s ridiculous! I still do it sometimes! Less often, but yes – from time to time, I still catch myself faking it!” I think for most people it's something you work at. Still, an article as an example of something it's railing against = funny.
- crntaylor 14y agoI think that her words are just on the right side of the line. It would be tough to make it more florid without sounding pretentious, but it seems fine at the moment. Here's an example of the kind of uncontrollable logorrhoea that she's talking about: "Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable must invariably be taken into account." That's from the George Orwell essay "Politics and the English Language" (I'm sure you're familiar with it - snarf) and it's a rewording of the following Bible verse "I returned and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favour to men of skill; but time and chance happeneth to them all."
- alan-crowe 14y agoI've never been happy with that Bible verse. To my mind, winning the race defines swiftness and winning the battle defines strength. The verse starts with two paradoxical examples, then shifts gears into three whines about unrecognised merit (which don't strike me as matters of chance). What is it actually trying to say? I write the point about swiftness and strength thus The race is to the swift and the battle to the strong but the odds are never so short as the bookmaker offers and when the sea take the unsinkable ship with no lifeboats everybody drowns.
- dkokelley 14y agoIf you take that verse in context (Ecclesiastes 9), you'll see that Solomon is lamenting the fact that "time and chance" ultimately negate any individual merit (strength and swiftness) in the long run (since in the end we all die). The swiftest runner could trip or pull a muscle, and in the chaos of battle anything could happen. Take David Vs. Goliath. Solomon's own father defeated the stronger opponent. Other circumstances of chance can change the tides of war, too. It's interesting to note that after Solomon became wise, he began to fall into something of an existential angst. I think that shows in this passage.
- vacri 14y agoWinning the battle defines the victor, not the strong.
- dwd 14y agoGladwell's Outliers is a good read on how time (timing) and chance (opportunity) have far more effect on success than innate ability. He may even have had that passage in mind when he wrote: "The biggest misconception about success is that we do it solely on our smarts, ambition, hustle and hard work".
- jerf 14y agoThere are two types of people who use "big words": Those who are trying to sound smarter than they are, and those who are so intimately familiar with the English language that they understand the subtle shadings of each word and can't help but use them fluently. English is often cited as an unusual language for the word count it has. What English has done is load a lot of connotations that in other languages might show in phrases or idioms into the words themselves. In the thesaurus, "conflagration" and "fire" are synonyms, but in fact they don't mean quite the same thing. One is a thing you might cook marshmallows over and the other certainly is not. Those in the second category can identify those in the first with a glance. Sometimes you can even see them flinch if you're looking at them at the right time, when someone claims to have roasted their marshmallows over a conflagration. The author is a professional writer and a professor, presumably of English or Writing. She comes by it honestly. If any of the vocabulary in that piece struck me on first reading (before I read your comment), I actually thought she was talking down to her students when she told the story about Mary. (I am sure Muphry's Law is in full effect for this post.)
- adam-a 14y agoThere are also two types of writing. Writing to convey a point and writing poetically. This is supposed to be advice so it would suit it more to be understandable rather than beautiful. Having said that I assumed she was making a joke in the first paragraph, she seems to calm down a lot after that. Surely the irony of > I’ve seen young writers contort their prose into incomprehensibly pretentious muddles, all in a disastrous bid to sound more erudite than they are. is apparent to the author.
- kscaldef 14y agoI'm not sure why it should be, as there's no irony to be found. That sentence is neither contorted nor incomprehensible nor a muddle nor a disaster. One might argue on the issue of whether it's pretentious, but given the target audience of other academics I would lean towards saying it's not.
- vacri 14y ago
- zwischenzug 14y agoIt read to me as over-written, much as the ideas within the article were over-stated.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI think the first sentence is clumsy. "Fancify," really? The second sentence looks fine to me though. "Erudite" is a bit pretentious, but I could chalk it up to irony there.
- chris_wot 14y agoI cannot believe you think "erudite" sounds pretentious. It sounds normal.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI said "a bit."
- dlitz 14y agoDid you actually have any problem understanding it? I suspect that you didn't.