4 ms·
This sort of thing is also harmful for native IT development for an outsourcing destination such as India. Since the motive of work channeled to India is simply
by realrocker 14y ago
This sort of thing is also harmful for native IT development for an outsourcing destination such as India. Since the motive of work channeled to India is simply cheaper costs, good software engineers have a limited run. One of the direct fallout is time-based promotions instead of merit-based. Some salient points:
a) Average entry salary(0 years exp.) for an IT worker is about $6k. After applying PPP(purchasing power parity) of 2.9(source:http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/columns/harish-damodaran/article1540678.ece)it http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/columns/harish-d... amounts to $18k. In the US the average is about $60-65k (http://www.whatsalary.com/us/salary/SOFTWARE-ENGINEER-T6812.htm http://www.whatsalary.com/us/salary/SOFTWARE-ENGINEER-T6812....). TLDR:Entry level, India($18k after PPP) vs USA($60-65k).
b) Why is the above data relevant to this discussion?
H1B is a red herring basically saying, "Look we tried looking for locals alright. They are just not qualified. Look at the Indians we got, they work all the time." I don't think the 800-900 workers IBM imports translate to a huge savings compared to 100,000+ workers it employs in India. While in India, the H1B is a carrot for workers to continue slogging on.
c) How is it bad for India?
It's bad for India for exactly the same reasons. There is no desperation for innovation as a software job is easily available. This is also the reason India has not produced even a single Google or a Nokia.
Recently I was offered a contract job. I quoted the global market rate(after applying PPP). The response I got back was shocking and humiliating.
"India's GDP is $3700. Why is your quotation so high?"
I apologized for earning more than India's GDP and refused.
- eru 14y agoIf the carrot makes more people invest in skills than actually leave the country, India will easily profit. Also the ones who leave often send remittance, and may one day come back with new skills. > This is also the reason India has not produced even a single Google or a Nokia. There are other things wrong with India (and Nokia nowadays, too).
- realrocker 14y ago800 carrots for 100,000+, thus a red herring. I believe desperation for innovation is the key factor though.
- Evbn 14y agoGDP?
- realrocker 14y agogross domestic product.