4 ms·
The problem is that reality is messy. There are a lot of factors that gunk up a good theory. Higher demand can lead to higher wages if we restrict immigration
by jlgreco 14y ago
The problem is that reality is messy. There are a lot of factors that gunk up a good theory. Higher demand can lead to higher wages if we restrict immigration, but if American students raw out of highschool are not thinking 5 to 10 years into their future when they pick a major, supply is not going to jump like the growing industry needs it to.
The issue is compounded when popular media artificially lowers the level of "glamor" in the industry. Shows like The Big Bang Theory are entertaining, but I don't think many people watch them and say "that is what I want to be a part of".
Now, of course individual companies can spike their salaries and pull in talented programmers, but I think most of those will be cannibalized from other companies. If supply is dwindling then raising wages can work for individual companies, but not I think for the industry as a whole.
- grecy 14y ago> If supply is dwindling then raising wages can work for individual companies, but not I think for the industry as a whole. It's interesting you look at this from the perspective of benefiting the companies. My discussion was about the lack of benefit to the employees and people in the country in general. > supply is not going to jump like the growing industry needs it to. Industry only needs supply to jump fast so that profits can jump fast. Let's face it, if Apple can't get enough Software Engineers fast enough, iOS 7 might be delayed and profits might be reduced, but they're not going to fail because they can't get enough good employees fast enough. The approach of bringing in foreigners absolutely supports faster growth for the companies, and higher profits for the companies, but it's not doing anything to help employees or the people in that country on the whole. Is it really worth lowering the overall wages and standard of living of people in your own country so that the companies can make higher profits faster?
- Evbn 14y ago...and so people born on other pieces of dirt can have higher standard of living...
- grecy 14y agoAbsolutely that's a consequence. Have you spent any time in developing and undeveloped countries? Do you have any idea what would happen to your life if we averaged out the standard of living across all countries? After living in Ecuador, Bolivia, Peru, etc for years, I honestly believe the majority of people in the developed world would die if they were forced to live like that.