4 ms·
World's biggest geoengineering experiment 'violates' UN rules
- 001sky 14y agoActual Headline > World's biggest geoengineering experiment 'violates' UN rules The word illegal in the HN headline is a bit of extra editorial, and should be removed. The inverted commas in this case are not trivial, as not all UN rules are Law, either per-se or in the (even then endlessly debated) eyes of 'International Law.'
- ceejayoz 14y agoIn this case, Canada and the US are both signatories to the violated UN rules. According to Wikipedia, US law incorporates the Convention, and I'd imagine Canada does the same.
- 001sky 14y agoThis is a good comment, I have no issues with having such a discussion in the comments. Its just bad form to <conclude> the outcome a legal proceeding in a headline, generally. If someone with additional information wants to jump in and clarify, for example, the role of international waters the competing issues of soveriegnty, and distinction between the actors of states and individuals, etc. would be very informative.[1] ______________ [1] A bit of additional color: International law differs from national legal systems in that it primarily concerns nations rather than private citizens. [Continuing...] National law may become international law when treaties delegate national jurisdiction to supranational tribunals such as the European Court of Human Rights or the International Criminal Court. Treaties such as the Geneva Conventions may require national law to conform. ...[A] state member of the international community is not obliged to abide by international law unless it has expressly consented to a particular course of conduct.[3] This is an issue of state sovereignty. etc. Not my area of expertise, but this is very much an area where such expertise would be quite useful. Not just international law in general, but also (presumably) the UN doctrines Law of the sea, ect. (covers private parties). http://www.un.org/Depts/los/index.htm http://www.un.org/Depts/los/index.htm
- ceejayoz 14y agoAlready well discussed at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4659053 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4659053
- nostromo 14y agoI'm a bit surprised at the negative tone of the articles. Yes, it's unproven that this will work as a fix for global warming. But what better way to find out than by running a large experiment? (This isn't just some crackpot theory, real scientists have looked into it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_fertilization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_fertilization) I've noticed two divergent environmental movements lately. The "do nothing" crowd that doesn't like wind energy because of birds and rejects nuclear because of fallout risks. And the more (in my view) pragmatic crowd that is open to trying new things to solve environmental problems.
- cryptoz 14y agoWhat if it doesn't work? What if it kills all the salmon and worsens global warming? The reason there's so much negative press is that this was done pretty much unilaterally and it was done to make quick cash. This type of large-scale geoengineering project is almost certainly what will get us out of the current global warming mess, in my opinion, but it must be approached carefully and scientifically. What science do we get out of this project? Virtually none. It doesn't appear there were any controls, or careful measurements, or whatever. Just a cash grab.
- nostromo 14y agoWhat if it does work? I do agree with you and I'm not trying to defend the way this guy has gone about this. However, the path we're on now is basically, "we know we're fucked, but let's do nothing." The UN is not going to be able to agree on anything more active than Kyoto. In the US, Romney is using Obama's previous comments on climate change as a laugh line. The EU has plenty of luddites themselves; they would never agree to fertilizing parts of the ocean for fear of negative side effects. For the scientific community to come to a consensus would take decades. So I agree that we need to be cautious. But right now it seems we're just rearranging the deckchairs on the titanic.
- freehunter 14y agoI have a theory that shooting holes in clouds makes the rain pour out. I can't get the UN to agree on it, but I do have a lot of bullets and a rifle. "It takes too long" isn't a good excuse for acting in an unsafe or illegal manner. If it does work, good. But the guy should still be punished for acting in an unsafe and illegal manner. If he damages the environment, he should be punished for breaking the law and for the damage done. If he succeeds, he should be celebrated for his solution, but still punished for breaking the law. Driving at a steady speed between freeway and city driving and blowing through stoplights will save on greenhouse gas emissions from accelerating a car, but it's still dangerous and illegal.
- mdonahoe 14y agoI had vagely heard of this before, but I didn't realize that tr goal is to have the carbon sink to the bottom of the ocean. I assumed that it would just introduce more active marine life. Not sure how this guy is going to get paid for his co2 credits.
- benologist 14y agoGawker are ridiculous. They've written a few paragraphs rewording the original article and then quoted 1/2 the article to wrap it up: http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/oct/15/pacific-iron-fertilisation-geoengineering http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/oct/15/pacific-ir... Edit: Yay someone fixed it.
- xbryanx 14y agoWe made a simple little ethics game about this very possibility for an exhibit on anthropogenic change: http://sciencebuzz.org/earth/scenario http://sciencebuzz.org/earth/scenario
- Gravityloss 14y agoIt didn't save my comments? At least I couldn't see them...
- d2vid 14y ago"History is full of examples of ecological manipulations that backfired." You mean like extracting billions of barrels of oil a day and burning them? We're already manipulating the environment. This is what I wish we were discussing in the global warming debate in the U.S. - not whether global warming was happening, but conservation versus mitigation/adaptation.
- wcoenen 14y ago> You mean like extracting billions of barrels of oil a day and burning them? The actual figure is about 85 million barrels per day [1]. [1] http://www.indexmundi.com/energy.aspx http://www.indexmundi.com/energy.aspx
- 001sky 14y ago"History is full of examples of ecological manipulations that backfired." You mean like extracting billions of barrels of oil a day and burning them? We're already manipulating the environment. -- This is so Ironic. The manipulation here is the Carbond credit system. That is why this guy is pouring crap in the Ocean. He is trying to score points on it. The carbon credit system is (therefore) the root cause/problem. So, I don't think you're argument is going per-se where you want it to go.
- chipsy 14y agoThis is, in the end, a reflection of the incentives governments have crafted in recent environmental policy. Now that there's an opening for profit, the market has rushed in to provide "solutions" of varying quality and ethics.
- hn_is_vile 14y agoThe problem with this particular experiment is the speed and scale of it. Both iron sulphate and iron oxide are being 'dumped' in the ocean all the time, by the world's rivers. The difference being the level of dilution. Algal blooms != algal growth. Algal growth is healthy for the ocean, marine life and the oxygen breathing carbon based life forms inhabiting the land masses of the planet. Algal blooms on the other hand, have none of those characteristics, can lead to anoxia in the area of the bloom, which kills marine life and results in the algae decomposing back into CO2.