I think you're right here. Also depends on the timing. If you're the first commenter, and you're 'kinda' right, you'll get far more upvotes than if you're late

I think you're right here. Also depends on the timing. If you're the first commenter, and you're 'kinda' right, you'll get far more upvotes than if you're late to the party and very right. I think the reason the 3rd comment got upvoted was that it wasn't a direct comment, but a response to someone else. Having said that, I think we're reading way too much into this.