6 ms·
The argument made is not unique to software or computer algorithms. Chemical process patents are identical to computer algorithm patents in this respect, just r
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
The argument made is not unique to software or computer algorithms. Chemical process patents are identical to computer algorithm patents in this respect, just replace bits with molecules, and are among the oldest patentable subject matters. Long, complex sequential algorithms are a feature of many engineering disciplines.
Chemical engineering, to use that example, designs elaborate and complex dynamic systems by chaining together abstract chemical algorithms. Each one of those little algorithms is subject to both patent and copyright. Like with software most of the commonly used algorithms and clever hacks were either never patented or the patents have long expired. It is only on the bleeding edge that some chemical algorithms are under patent; as with computer algorithms there are an unbounded number of potential algorithms but some are more efficient than others. Specific implementations are still covered by copyright and are widely licensed (as libraries).
Most of the nominal specialness attributed to software as a domain for intellectual property does not really exist. Yet the rarely questioned assertion that computer software is special in some way has created a dearth of comparative studies that would likely be valuable from both a theoretical standpoint as well as a practical policy standpoint. Either these other areas, like chemical processes, are equally broken at a fundamental level and the scope should be extended beyond software, or there are differences in implementation across otherwise equivalent domains and we should borrowing from the better implementation. It seems like an oversight that no one is attempting to do either.
- nitrogen 14y agoSoftware is different because the cost of materials consumed is effectively zero and the barrier to entry is at most $35 for a Raspberry Pi, allowing anyone to code their way into a patent thicket. Software is also different because of its rapid pace of change, a pace that is threatened by insanely long patent terms (approaching as long as a good chunk of programmers have been alive).
- brindle 14y agoI'm a chemist and a software engineer. With all due respect there are a lot of similarities. People who do ground breaking research need to have a way of protecting their intellectual property, whether its patents, copyrights, and or reasonable license fees, etc...
- pron 14y ago> People who do groundbreaking research need to have a way of protecting their intellectual property... Why? Because you want to give them incentives to invest in costly research that wouldn't pay off without a limited monopoly. But what if research paid off even without such protection? And, more importantly, what if research is not even research at all, let alone costly? I know little of other industries, but practically none of the recent software patents are a result of costly research, and therefore deserve no protection.
- georgemcbay 14y agoPatents (at least as defined in the US Constitution) weren't created to protect intellectual property. The idea that they were is a recent invention that is at odds with history. Patents no longer serve their original purpose and the current system should be dismantled (though I know it won't be, because the big money is on the side of keeping the broken system). I'm okay with the idea of something new being created to give protection to intellectual property (on a much shorter timescale, say 2-5 years), but the current patent system is incredibly broken.
- Joeri 14y ago"People who do ground breaking research need to have a way of protecting their intellectual property" Define "ground-breaking". This is the myth of the patent system: the lone inventor doing dazzling unprecedented work that they can only recoup by being granted a patent. Those people don't exist. You may find one or two, but not enough to justify the overbearing patent system.
- zmmmmm 14y agoAnd to extend the argument (as in the article), if those same people can't actually sell their inventions because of interlocking patents held by competitors then the patents they do hold aren't much use. The idea of a patent is heavily predicated on one novel advance in an otherwise freely implementable design. But in software that is (or threatens to become) a myth rather than a reality.
- kbutler 14y ago
- wissler 14y agoYou're right -- if software patents aren't legitimate then no patents are legitimate. And in fact, no patents are legitimate. Worse than that, most people's concept of "legitimate" is not legitimate. What most people seem to have banned from their thinking is anything close to resembling a ethical argument. Just because something is legal, does not make it ethical. That reverses the true order: what inherently flouts the ethical underpinning of law must not be made legal. E.g., one should never legalize rape, to make rape legal does not change the fact that it is unethical to make rape legal. But typically, whenever you try to offer anyone an ethical argument concerning patents, it goes straight over their head. They've been conditioned to think that whether patents are legal or not is an entirely pragmatic decision having nothing to do with ethics but only with economics. And so the mayhem continues...
- rayiner 14y agoIf patents aren't ethical, then there are lots of things that aren't ethical, and I don't think the tech industry has the balls to confront those. E.g. trademark law supports the existence of the advertising industry, by creating protectable brands through restrictions on speech. Most web companies wouldn't exist in their current form if there wasn't a tremendous incentive for companies to build up those protectable brands through advertising.
- wissler 14y agoThere are two issues here: whether a given law is ethical or not as written, and whether the spirit of the law can be supported even if it is unethical as written. As it turns out, one can make an argument that copyrights/trademarks can be reformed, but patents cannot. The difference is that no one can accidentally "trip" over a sensibly defined copyright or trademark, whereas patents are intrinsically a legal landmine -- people can and often do accidentally infringe.
- rayiner 14y agoFirst, I'm not sure how accidental infringement goes to the heart of whether whether the laws are ethical or not. They're all fundamentally restraints on free expression. Second, you can accidentally infringe on a trademark, and can be prevented from using a trademark even if you came up with the term independently. Third, there is no reason why you couldn't add an "independent invention" defense to patent. Fourth, you have no basis for your claim that people "often" accidentally infringe patents.
- 0wza 14y agoThis what I thought too. Where is his comparison to patents in other areas? I liked this title because it is restricted to software. A title like "Abolish patents, full stop" is, to be blunt, sheer idiocy and all too common. I think there are some key differences between software "R&D" and chemical and biological R&D, and I can't see how any rational argument for reform could ignore those differences, but this "Noble Laureate" fails to mention any of them. Does he know something on the subject of patents that we don't?
- bo1024 14y ago> A title like "Abolish patents, full stop" is, to be blunt, sheer idiocy Why? Apparently a Nobel laureate in Economics disagrees with you, so maybe we should take the idea seriously. To see more of Maskin's arguments on software patents, you can read a paper of his on the subject at citation #6 on his wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Maskin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Maskin
- 0wza 14y agoAre you sure that's what he's saying? Is he suggested all patents are impediments? I just skimmed that paper and I see references to semiconductors and software. The word "pharmaceutical" only appears in the title of a one of the references. He never discusses pharmaceuticals. Maybe the IT industry has enough cash to make us all forget about other industries that use the patent system such as the pharmaceutical industry. Maybe we can stay focussed on software as a raison d'etre for everything. If patents hurt software, then they must be abolished. Never mind how this might impact other industries. The only thing I "disagree" with is that the focus is solely on software. Where were these "abolish patents" arguments from Nobel Laureates in Economic years ago, before the smartphone era? Why weren't they arguing against patents that make it more difficult for smaller players to develop drug treatments and make the treatments that are developed by large players more expensive for everyone?^1 Or maybe they were and I just didn't notice. I'm just not convinced that someone who focuses almost entirely on IT and particularly software truly understands _all_ the dynamics of the patent system. It makes me skeptical. Software is a recent entry into the patent game. The absurd behavior of a few IT companies and patent trolls emerging from IT (the term patent troll itself was coined by an Intel lawyer) is making us question the very notion of patents, for _any_ industry. Am I the only who find this a bit peculiar? Let's take a step back and look at the big picture. Before these IT clowns got so seriously involved with patents (the increases in the number of patents they've filed for and been granted in a relatively short span of years is, at least to me, quite shocking), how many scholars were proposing bold ideas about "abolishing [all] patents"? There have been serious problems with patents for many years. But maybe they have just never been exploited with such insulting flagrancy until now, thanks to the greater participation of the software industry and one fashionable hardware company in particular. Maybe the real pressing problem is not patent but IT executives and their child-like ideas about how to conduct business. 1. Years ago, there were people arguing for patent _reform_ (not abolishing an entire system) and warning of the frequency with which bogus software patents were being issued. And even just arguing for reforms, they seemed a bit crazy at the time. Needless to say they did not have "Nobel" attached to their names. My, how things have changed. I wonder what they think now?
- woodchuck64 14y ago> Most of the nominal specialness attributed to software as a domain for intellectual property does not really exist. Just rapid development and testing. Biotech, chemistry, hardware development are orders of magnitude slower. But development and testing of anything is getting faster every year. Hardware development and testing is now hugely accelerated with FPGA design flow, for example, which feels a lot like software developmnent with crappy tools, to me. All fields' patent abilities will probably live or die eventually by whether software patents live or die. Maybe that's why Maskin ignores the rest.
- sologoub 14y agoOne thing that seems to be missing from the interpretation of the article is whether or not the temporary monopoly granted by patents is necessary in software patents. When answering this question, one should definitely look at the speed of both innovation and obsolescence, combined with strength of competition. There have been a large number of good papers published all coming to this one conclusion - speed to market in current software markets is the ultimate strategic advantage and source of reward. Most other things can be copied quickly enough, but the landscape is evolving fast enough that innovators can constantly one-up the competition, reaping greatest rewards. By contrast, in capital-intensive, slower industries, these "guard rails" make a lot of sense - if it takes me years to make a breakthrough on the drug, but means of copying it a re super straightforward because I am required to publish the recipe for all to see, it makes sense to restrict the use of the recipe. I don't see anyone publishing Google search algorithms for all to see. In fact there is an entire industry that focuses on guessing what it is - SEO. To me personally, it boils down to this - if we make it super easy for competitors to ride your coat-tails by forcing you to disclose your secrete sauce, then it's fair to try and give you some protection. If we leave you to compete without that interference, than we should not extend the extra protection... (this is just strictly a personal view, grounded more in my ethical views than anything else).
- montecarl 14y agoIts a fun exercise to try to imagine what the medical/drug industry would look like sans patents. If it was infeasible for a corporation to spend many years and (m|b)illions of dollars to develop a drug because as soon as you did a competitor would copy it, would we still have drugs? If we did who would make them? In the future advances in science and computer modeling should make drug development much more rapid than it is today. This could vastly lower the cost to bring drugs to market and put drug development easily within the grasp of a large non-profit organization. Imagine that instead granting a private company the exclusive right to sell a drug, that instead everyone invested in its development and upon its discovery its formula was shared freely. For most drugs, the synthesis is not a major component of the cost. This would lead to rapid deployment of the drug at very low cost to those who need it. If there was no copyright law, you can be sure there would still be drugs! And perhaps health insurance companies would be interested in drug development. Fewer sick people and cheaper medicine should lead to greater profits.
- ekianjo 14y agoI think it all boils down to the origin of patents. To understand why patents exist, you need to remove all the crap you hear about "protecting innovation" and start from the beginning. Patents were no more, no less, exclusive, monopoly rights provided by Kingdoms to some of their vassals, usually from the nobility. Patents were not an invention of free trade, there were a tool to prevent free trade, and to prevent newcomers from taking over the established monopoly. They were state ordinances to ensure statu quo and protect the existing, mutual relationship between the King and the company, nothing else. No matter how you look at it, patents are nothing but a relic of Monarchical times. The system for attribution has changed, but the effect remains the same: companies are in rent-seeking mode when they ask for patents, not in the business of innovation of disruption.
- Evbn 14y agoYou overshot. Read the version in the US Constitution.