4 ms·
> At at this point, Apple just needs to get anything out the door To the extent Cupertino fucked up, it's in having had this attitude when they rolled out Appl
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> At at this point, Apple just needs to get anything out the door
To the extent Cupertino fucked up, it's in having had this attitude when they rolled out Apple Intelligence.
There isn't currently a forcing function. Apple owns the iPhone, and that makes it an emperor among kings. Its wealth is also built on starting with user problems and then working backwards to the technology, versus embracing whatever's hot and trying to shove it down our throats.
- cush 10mo ago> There isn't currently a forcing function Sorry but if there wasn’t a forcing function then “Apple Picks Gemini to Power Siri” wouldn’t be the headline
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> if there wasn’t a forcing function then “Apple Picks Gemini to Power Siri” wouldn’t be the headline A pair four-trillion dollar companies striking a deal in the hottest technology space since the internet getting headline treatment is not evidence of a forcing function.
- cush 10mo agoI mean, maybe if the headline was “For no particular reason whatsoever, under absolutely no pressure from their millions of customers to deliver on the promises they paid for nearly two years ago, Apple picks Gemini to Power Siri” Or maybe you’re arguing that Apple never did intend to commit to those promises and it was all intentional and part of a well orchestrated plan from the outset? Seems like an odd strategy
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> if the headline was “For no particular reason whatsoever, under absolutely no pressure from their millions of customers to deliver on the promises they paid for nearly two years ago, Apple picks Gemini to Power Siri” Which is not how headlines work. You may have an argument that Apple is under pressure. But your headline argument is bananas. > maybe you’re arguing that Apple never did intend to commit to those promises Where did you get that? The attitude I called "fucked up" is precisely rushing to make promises and then meet them. Apple's sales don't suggest customers are putting material pressure on Cupertino. Apple's share price doesn't suggest investors are panicking. The promises have already been broken. If Apple is pushing something out, again, because they feel they have to on the basis of those promises, it's–again-a fuckup.
- cush 10mo ago> Which is not how headlines work That’s the joke. I assure you they are panicking.
- hnlmorg 10mo agoThem having bolted on ChatGPT in the ugly way they did is evidence though. Their naff image generation tool (Playground) is further evidence. Apple are definitely panicking. And they should be too.
- walthamstow 10mo agoNot enough things are referred to as naff these days, which is funny because there's so much naff shit knocking around.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> Them having bolted on ChatGPT in the ugly way they did is evidence though That's evidence they forced themselves. Not that there was a forcing function. That's the whole point of the top comment. (Mine.) They rushed where they didn't have to. And I still don't think they need to rush.
- cush 10mo agoApple provides high-value services like iMessage, iCloud, iPhotos, Apple Maps, Apple Health etc. They hold mountains of people’s personal data and interactions. These services provide the personalized experiences that allows Apple’s hardware to be so sticky. These services are threatened by the emerging competitive landscape. Apple is panicking, and there is a forcing function, because their users are spending more and more time with LLMs having the most personal experiences they’ve ever had with any software, and Apple isn’t getting a piece of that pie. They’re in a very high risk position because this is the heart of their brand and as data is slowly siphoned away into apps and services that are providing the experiences their users are growing to expect, that moat and stickiness is eroding. That said, this precisely why it’s taken so long. While Apple is desperate, they are completely unwilling to disrespect their users trust and mishandle their personal data or compromise their privacy.
- hnlmorg 10mo agoThat’s some politician-grade logic you’ve got there: A company can be forced into a decision because they’re scared of losing market share, but that doesn’t count as them being forced because they chose they wanted to stay in business. The crux of the problem is that people use Gemini on Android. In fact Google have been doubling down on the AI features for years. And in a range of guise’s from camera enhancing vision models to smart personal assistants via Gemini. Just as Apple heavily promoted Siri back when it was pioneering. But Siri has stagnated for years. It’s basically the Internet Explorer 5 of the assistant domain. And the competition is so far ahead in capabilities that people are going to start questioning the innovation happening at Apple. In fact people already are. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Liquid Glass misfire was a desperate attempt to make their technology feel futuristic again. The fact is, Siri sucks. I almost never use it now. Apple knows this. We know it. Consumers know it. Apple know that they have to urgently fix it.
- bmitc 10mo ago> Its wealth is also built on starting with user problems and then working backwards to the technology Since when? > versus embracing whatever's hot and trying to shove it down our throats I agree here, to a degree. It's just that Apple tells its customers what's hot and then shoves it down their throats.
- virgil_disgr4ce 10mo ago> Apple tells its customers what's hot and then shoves it down their throats I don't really understand this. Is it shoving when something is actually popular? The iPod was legitimately extremely popular. Did Apple decide it was hot and then somehow force people to buy 450 million of them? I mean I'm just curious what products you're thinking of when you say "shoves it down their throats"
- bmitc 10mo agoIs the iPod your only example? That was a quarter century ago. What's hot about less ports, no headphone jack, no SD card, a tax when buying apps for your phone, planned obsolescence, antagonistic behavior towards app and software developers, an unchanged aluminum rectangle, thinner devices that look cool at the cost of performance and efficiency, heaviest laptops and phones on the market, phones made out of glass front and back, the touchbar, the notch, etc.?
- schrodinger 10mo agoJust don't buy what you don't like. There's no throat shoving going on.
- lxgr 10mo agoLately, they've arguably been starting from their own priorities (i.e. pushing and protecting their "services" revenue at all cost) and working backwards to an acceptable user experience from there. > Its wealth is also built on starting with user problems and then working backwards to the technology, versus embracing whatever's hot and trying to shove it down our throats. Then again, remember millimeterwave? But yes, as a general rule I think your point still stands.
- 46493168 10mo ago> There isn't currently a forcing function. Investors are the forcing function