6 ms·
Google may do some questionable things but it certainly is no Microsoft or Facebook or ebay/PayPal. Google contributes to open source software in a very signif
by ck2 14y ago
Google may do some questionable things but it certainly is no Microsoft or Facebook or ebay/PayPal.
Google contributes to open source software in a very significant manner and completely voluntary - from early in it's history. Not sure I can name more than one or two others at their level who have done that.
Google's biggest problem is lack of human beings vs technical automation ratio. When things go horribly wrong with their services (ie. ban) and you need a human, it's pretty much impossible unless you can reach the top of a popular website with the story of your problem.
- Steko 14y ago"Google contributes to open source software in a very significant manner and completely voluntary" So what, that means they can't break the law?
- capo 14y agoWho said they broke the law? I'm no expert on antitrust law but as I understand the FTC will basically try to argue a theory in front of a judge, and if it's indeed concerning which results rank where it's not a particularly strong theory. At this point it's really inertia that is keeping the FTC on track towards a lawsuit.
- Steko 14y ago"Who said they broke the law?" Stop moving goalposts, grandparent was clearly peddling what amounts to an "upstanding member of the community" defense. I'm not claiming Google broke any law, but they're not above the law, they can get investigated like anyone else.
- capo 14y agoNot sure if you've noticed but they are being investigated. Investigations however do not imply guilt, and this is not a criminal investigation so it's not analogous to your example. There is no clear and shut case here, no evidence of cartel-like behaviour or raising prices on consumers. The FTC will hire an economist who will argue that exists "market failure", Google will in turn hire several economists, scholars, and law firms to prove them wrong.
- redm 14y agoThe notion that competition is a click away is ridiculous when you look at all the infrastructure Google builds to make any algorithm work at scale. Its no different then saying, "Building a better Operating System is just a program away." Google is the de-facto standard and that gives it a huge amount of power, just like Microsoft on the desktop.
- capo 14y agoWindows was a de facto standard on the desktop because it was the de facto developer platform and so it was the only choice for a reasonable consumer experience. Search on the other hand is user facing, and as Microsoft keeps telling us search engines are basically the same. Oh, and they're all free.
- redm 14y agoThe point is they are both de facto platforms. The fact that its free is irrelevant, its not like its a non-profit, they are just making money via advertising instead of directly from a consumer.
- capo 14y agoOf course the fact that it's free is relevant, your argument is about switching costs and in this case the costs are literally nil. Also their search is not a platform it's a service (no API).
- chrischen 14y agoSwitching costs for consumers are nil, but what about for advertisers and publishers?