4 ms·
If that were true, sci-hub.se would be blocked in Germany on 1.1.1.1 (1dot1dot1dot1.cloudflare-dns.com), it isn't blocked, therefore it's not true. (Modus tolle
by cubefox 10mo ago
If that were true, sci-hub.se would be blocked in Germany on 1.1.1.1 (1dot1dot1dot1.cloudflare-dns.com), it isn't blocked, therefore it's not true. (Modus tollens)
- nkmnz 10mo agoYour reasoning is impeccable, bravo. But it's wrong. Both your premise and your conclusion are based on completely wrong assumptions.
- cubefox 10mo agoNot sure which premise you disagree with, but the conclusion follows from them.
- nkmnz 10mo agoI am a Service Provider ("Diensteanbieter") according to DDG and I don't block a single page, which makes your statement not only wrong, but rather so wrong that not even the complete opposite would make any sense.
- cubefox 10mo agoNot necessarily. Perhaps small service providers are exempt from blocking sci-hub.se. But Cloudflare is certainly not small.
- nkmnz 10mo agoHave you ever considered reading the law before attempting to discuss it?
- cubefox 10mo agoYou are clearly unable to cite a portion of the law which proves that Cloudflare counts as a service provider.
- nkmnz 10mo ago§ 1 Absatz 4 Nummer 5 Digitale-Dienste Gesetz: Im Sinne dieses Gesetzes ist oder sind „Diensteanbieter“ Anbieter digitaler Dienste;
- cubefox 10mo agoThat's just stating a tautology.
- nkmnz 10mo agoNo, it's not. It's a very precise way to state that the law has to be applied to a very wide range of service providers. This is a fundamental change compared to the previous regulation TKG. Now take the loss and next time, read the damn manual first.