4 ms·
If you have something that needs to be private don't put it on a web site. And certainly don't put it on a web site that is designed for sharing things with the
by jgrahamc 14y ago
If you have something that needs to be private don't put it on a web site. And certainly don't put it on a web site that is designed for sharing things with the people you are connected to.
- capisce 14y agoThey didn't, someone else did.
- bmelton 14y agoI second that, and think a fairly obvious extension to it should be "... and DEFINITELY don't put it on Facebook." At this stage, I think it should be a given that anything you put on Facebook (and perhaps any other web service) will eventually end up public to the world.
- LaGrange 14y agoAnd what would that achieve in that case? Nothing! Just as not being on Facebook achieves nothing — you'll just be completely defenseless if someone tags you in an image (which is horrifying — as far as I'm concerned, the only acceptable solution is to allow only tagging of actual users, and only the ones who consented to that).
- varikin 14y agoPlease read the article. They didn't do anything. Someone else added them to a group called Queer Choir. They were not prompted to join. Then it was added to all their friends' timelines that they were now in this group, including parents. At no time, did the student do anything. In fact, they had privacy controls setup to not show have updates posted to their parents timeline be default.
- bmelton 14y agoFor what it's worth, my response wasn't to the article, but to the GP from jgrahamc. I acknowledge that the event in question wasn't a result of something the users in question did -- but that illustrates my point all the more that Facebook should be avoided. Somewhat more ontopic, I'm a little hesitant to accede that someone adding you to a group makes you a member of that group in spirit. Sure, perhaps it convinces some folks that it's true, but so what? If somebody adds me to an open group entitled "People who hate women", I think it's easy enough for me to say "I didn't join this group, and I don't hate women. If I happened to actually hate women, I could see that being slightly more touchy, but whether or not anyone joins me to said group doesn't do anything to stop someone from simply accusing me of hating women, which is the same net effect (I believe). I'm sympathetic to those affected, but am generally unforgiving of anyone surprised that Facebook screwed something up.
- rossjudson 14y agoYou might see a change if one of Zuck's friends adds him to the "I LIKE SMASHING KITTENS" group. And another adds him to the "Fuck you, I'm rich." group.
- mindstab 14y agoRFTA They did not do that. What happened is it appears a friend who did know added them to a group and before they connected to joining that showed up on their feed. They did nothing. They were passive, and they were still outed because facebook didn't ask for permission and broadcast that they had been added by a third party to a group to their wall.
- jgrahamc 14y agoI did read it and I was making (poorly) a different point: the problem here is that you see the solution as technical ("Facebook should have better privacy controls") whereas I see the solution as personal ("Do not use Facebook"). I do not believe that it will be feasible for Facebook to both add functionality over time and preserve privacy and so the only solution is not to use Facebook at all.
- jonursenbach 14y agoNot using Facebook isn't really an option for kids these days.
- catshirt 14y agowhat?
- jgroome 14y agoNo way can I agree with that. Indeed, the "cool" thing for the time being is to NOT be on Facebook.
- lincolnq 14y agoJust because you say it does not make it true. Social considerations are some of the most powerful forces. People considered me "weird" because I wasn't on Facebook for a long time. Eventually I re activated my account, because I was tired of explaining to people why I wasn't on, and because I was missing out on photos and experiences and events that were only shared on Facebook. I agree that you can sometimes seem cool by seeming aloof to what everyone else is doing, but when it damages your social life, most people aren't going to do it.
- smokinjoe 14y agoThis comment appears fairly too frequently in response to this article. At least that gives away all those people who didn't read it.
- jmilloy 14y agoIn the context of what actually happened in the article (did you read it?), your advice amounts to "If there is anything about you that needs to be private, don't have an online presence."
- greenyoda 14y agoYou don't have to give up all forms of online presence to maintain your privacy. You just have to avoid being on a site where information about you can be leaked without your consent. For example, writing a blog doesn't open you up to the kind of privacy breach described in the article. Neither does posting on Hacker News, for that matter.
- randomchars 14y agoCan I get party invites on HN?