3 ms·
Joel dragged him into this by name. Clearly he thinks Joel is attributing ideas to him that he doesn't hold. Therefore it's not a matter of disagreement--he m
by dasil003 18y ago
Joel dragged him into this by name. Clearly he thinks Joel is attributing ideas to him that he doesn't hold. Therefore it's not a matter of disagreement--he may well fully agree with Joel's thesis--it's the demonization of his work by misrepresentation. In that light his response seems measured and appropriate.
- Angostura 18y agoIt may be measured, but it's not helpful. Let's assume that Joel is neither stupid nor malicious. Therefore he is having problems that presumably others are having. In this case it is useful to actually set out the nature of Joel's error, rather than simply saying "Joel is a dolt". Non-malicious criticism can often be helpful in letting you explore why people misunderstand you. Of course my assumptions could be wrong - he could believe that Joel is being malicious.
- DougBTX 18y agoHe could also believe exactly what he says, that Spolsky has a "lack of knowledge of what I do and what I say". FWIW, I think this is the post being responded to: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2009/01/31.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2009/01/31.html
- gdee 18y ago2. "Joel is a dolt" - Neither on the lines nor between them have I seen this in Kent's post. 1. "Joel is neither stupid nor malicious" - Stupid + Malicious != AllThereCouldEverBe... Pompous and AttentionCraving are missing for example. Others are too... 0. I _partly_ dislike both stands on software dev. methodology (Kent's and Joel's) so don't take this a fanboysm. I respect Kent's life work more though.