5 ms·
It would be a great metaphor if it were extended out to all the handicaps people face. That straight white male programmer who has struggled with mental illnes
by nostrademons 14y ago
It would be a great metaphor if it were extended out to all the handicaps people face.
That straight white male programmer who has struggled with mental illness since adolescence? He's on nightmare difficulty too.
The guy who was born with a silver spoon in his mouth but lost his father as a child? Hasn't been too easy for him either.
The girl who grew up with loving parents from a poor neighborhood and didn't see her first computer until college? Well, she's got some huge handicaps, but some pretty solid roots too.
I've been privileged in many ways, and I've also struggled in many ways. I'd like to think that I played the hand I got as well as I could, and extended a hand out to those who didn't quite have the same privileges whenever possible. I wouldn't really expect otherwise from anyone else.
- Alex3917 14y ago"It would be a great metaphor if it were extended out to all the handicaps people face." This. People often forget that 32.8% of Americans are disabled, including 27.1% of adults age 18 - 64. (According to the CDC.)
- ced 14y agoI was curious about that figure - here's the breakdown: Percent of adults with hearing trouble: 16.2% Percent of adults with vision trouble: 9.4% Percent of adults unable (or very difficult) to walk a quarter mile: 7.3% Percent of adults with any physical functioning difficulty: 15.6% The hearing disability is described as: Overall, 16% of adults aged 18 years and over experienced some hearing difficulty without a hearing aid (defined as ‘‘a little trouble hearing,’’ ‘‘moderate trouble,’’ ‘‘a lot of trouble,’’ or ‘‘deaf’’). Men were more likely to have experienced hearing trouble than women. The report is interesting. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/disable.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/disable.htm
- nostrademons 14y agoAlso, within any given year 26% of the U.S. population will suffer from mental illness, and 46% will suffer from it during their lifetime: http://www.nimh.nih.gov/statistics/1ANYDIS_ADULT.shtml http://www.nimh.nih.gov/statistics/1ANYDIS_ADULT.shtml Within any given year 15% of families are below the poverty line, and 58% will fall below it at some point in their life: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States Normal is kinda abnormal.
- rayiner 14y agoThe distinction is that this particular "handicap" applies to 51% of the whole population. It's not unreasonable to consider it more important than the other ones.
- nostrademons 14y agoSo, I don't think it's unreasonable to try and lower barriers for women who choose to go into tech. (I don't think it's unreasonable to try and lower barriers for anyone who chooses to go into tech, but like you say, targeting women affects 51% of the population, so it has a pretty high return on investment.) I think it's worth supporting our female colleagues, and celebrating what they achieve. (FWIW, a friend of mine has a blog that does precisely that: http://techladyallstars.com/ http://techladyallstars.com/) I object to framing the debate as a "handicap", because I've found that whenever you start identifying something as a handicap it tends to become one. (Edit: shit, just reread the thread and I did that. Poor word choice on my part.) My own experience is race; my father was sure that the reason that he kept getting passed over for promotions was because he was non-white, and as a result, he ignored all the other possible reasons that were under his control. I've been very careful not to identify myself in racial terms since, because I don't want to give those stereotypes power over me. I read Kathy's account of being oblivious to all the little microaggressions going on around her. I explicitly made a different choice: I knew from the beginning that there may be people who see me as "just a programmer" or "not leadership material" or "socially awkward nerd" or "undateable" because physically I look Asian. And so I figured I'd work on the parts that I could change, and everything else is somebody else's problem. They're entitled to whatever preconceptions they have; if that's a problem, I can go find other people to interact with. I really like that Kathy came here to clarify that she was sharing her personal experience, just as Laura shared hers, and now I'm sharing mine. Isn't the meta-problem here that we don't see each other as individuals, and that it's all the "1%" and the "99%" and the "51%" and the "49%"? And I think that if there're specific policies that make it easier for 51% of the population, that's a good thing. But that doesn't make it a handicap, nor should they be a protected group exempt from the same standards we apply to anyone else, nor should we forget that there are all sorts of other axes that we can categorize people by, and some of them have it a lot easier than others.
- freshhawk 14y agoYou are concentrating on the metaphor too much and missing the main point. Everyone struggles and is privileged in some ways. All these ways are not equal. I dislike the term "privilege" as it's rarely used in a useful context. But your reaction is the very definition of the word. "extended a hand out to those who didn't quite have the same privileges whenever possible. I wouldn't really expect otherwise from anyone else" You expect that from everyone else because you had a "privileged" upbringing obviously. Most people know that this expectation is naive. Extraordinarily naive I must say.
- nostrademons 14y agoFWIW, I am not white, nor was I rich growing up. My father was an immigrant and a non-native-speaker. I am straight and male, so I've got that at least. I'm curious just which attributes you think are more equal than others.
- freshhawk 14y agoI wasn't trying to rank which aspects are more career damaging. I was pointing out that "we all have our struggles, just be nice to everyone and expect the same" is the most bland of platitudes and seems very dismissive of the real and measurable biases evident in our culture that this kind of thing is trying to address. Any of the other handicaps or struggles you point out affect people who are not white, straight and male in basically equal numbers. So the comparison is not white/non-white vs average/autistic, it's native american gay women on the spectrum vs white straight male on the spectrum. That's the point. That's why I said you were missing the point. I admit that I assumed you were a white straight male because you conflated being non-white/gay/female with being handicapped.
- Crake 14y agoWell, if you don't agree with the social justice crowd, that automatically makes you a privileged white person. Duh.